Premium Essay

To What Extent Was Federal Government Responsible from Improving the Status of Black People in the Us in the Years 1945-55?

In: Historical Events

Submitted By jonb0211
Words 688
Pages 3
To what extent was federal government responsible from improving the status of black people in the US in the years 1945-55?

The status of black people living in America had changed incredibly in the years 1945-55. This is because of the different presidents, congress, and the Supreme Court. Although I believe that the federal government was highly responsible for improving the status of black people in the years 1945-55, this essay will also be examining other factors that may have helped; factors such as Martin Luther King, other groups, and the media.

To a certain extent, the Supreme Court played a considerable part in improving the status of black people in the US in the years 1945-55. For example, court cases such as Brown vs Topeka (1954), Browder vs Gayle (1956), and Morgan vs Virginia (1946) were all very important in improving the status of black people. This is because the Topeka case argued that the ‘separate but equal’ doctrine was a contradiction in terms, that is to say they believed that it was impossible for citizens to receive services that were both ‘separate’ and ‘equal’, The Browder case decision ruled that segregation of buses was illegal and the Morgan case ruled that segregation on interstate buses was illegal which meant that on buses both black and white people had the same status. This is why the Supreme Court played a considerable part in improving the status of black people in the years 1945-55, because all of these cases picked apart the legal basis of segregation which led to the status of black people being improved.

However, although the Supreme Court ruling in the case of Brown vs Topeka was a landmark decision that marked an end to the doctrine of ‘separate but equal’, enforcing the decision proved to be very difficult. Not only did middle class whites set up the White Citizens’ Councils to demand that segregation continued…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

How Accurate Is It to Say That the Status of Black People in the Usa Changed Very Little in the Years 1945-55?

...How accurate is it to say that the status of black people in the USA changed very little in the years 1945-55? I agree that the status of black people in the United States had little change in these years. There were things such as the Montgomery Bus Boycott, President Truman actions and the Supreme Court rulings (due to the NAACP actions), that did have some change to their lifestyles. However there were things such as Plessy vs. Ferguson (segregation in public transport), cases that did not improve their quality of life. There was more de jure change than de facto change, which is actually the most significant point, as a law itself meant nothing without its execution. Harry S Truman was a democrat and held presidential office in the years 1945-53. He was the first sympathetic president to civil rights. He understood that there were social developments in place and the black population began to have a voice through such organizations as NAACP. Black American soldiers, who came back from the WW2 were given the chance to have a college education. President Truman indeed helped change the lives of black people within the US. Just after the war he got involved in civil rights because he was moved the racial attacks that veterans were still receiving. Truman established the "To secure these rights" report in 1947 which highlighted that their equal rights were not equal at all and segregation was a huge problem. Knowing this, Truman tried to do as much as he......

Words: 1138 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Far Did the Position of Black Americans Improve in the Years 1945-55?

...far did the position of black Americans improve in the years 1945-55? (30 marks) The position of black Americans improved to a certain extent in the years 1945-55. The period certainly saw lots of ‘de jure’ improvements in the lives of black Americans, particularly those in the Southern states, but there were limited ‘de facto’ improvements to go with this. Nevertheless, some progress towards equality had been made in the areas of education, transport, public amenities, voting rights, employment and housing. There was a significant move towards equality in education in the period 1945-55. Court cases such as Sweatt v. Painter in 1950 and Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka in 1954 achieved great publicity and initiated the end of segregation in the education system. They also showed black Americans that the Supreme Court was on their side as it ruled in favour of the NAACP in both cases, the former dealing with the rights of students to graduate-level education and the latter dealing with the rights of younger students. This gave black Americans confidence that segregation could be successfully challenged. However, these ‘de jure’ victories led to little ‘de facto’ change. For example, by 1957, only 750 of 6,300 southern school districts had been desegregated. This was true despite the Brown II ruling by the Supreme Court, which stated that the desegregation of education should occur ‘with all deliberate speed’. Nevertheless, the Brown case was highly symbolic, as......

Words: 1412 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

How Far Do You Agree That the Impact of the Second World War Was the Main Reason Why the Position of African Americans Improved in the Years 1945-55?

...you agree that the impact of the Second World War was the main reason why the position of African Americans improved in the years 1945-55? It is clear that the Second World War played a vital part in improving the lives of African Americans between 1945 and 1955. However, the impact of the war was lessened by other factors that brought about change such as the civil rights groups and President Truman. These factors were able to convert de jure change into de facto change; something the Second World Wars alone was unable to do. World War Two had a dramatic effect on civil rights for Black Americans. Over 1.2 million black men joined the U.S army during the war and the experience radicalised them. Northern blacks were often trained in rural military camps in the Southern states, this was their first experience of formal racial segregation. They were appalled to know they were fighting a racist opponent, yet being treated as a second class citizen and receiving prejudice treatment back home. Consequently, the black soldiers used the ‘Double V’ sign, which meant they were fighting for two victories: victory overseas and victory over racism at home. The war also began to change the racist attitudes of whites. The United States and her allies were fighting a racist opponent, Hitler, who passionately believed in a ‘Master race’. In the past, white supremacy groups such as the Ku Klux Klan had presented racism as something that was both natural and noble, however, the racist......

Words: 1431 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

How Far Do You Agree That the Impact of the Second World War Was the Main Reason Why the Position of African Americans Improved in the Years 1945

...do you agree that the impact of the Second World War was the main reason why the position of African Americans improved in the years 1945–55? The impact of the Second World War was, without a doubt, crucial in improving the lives of black Americans over the years 1945-55, as it led to federal support of the cause. However, it wasn’t as important as the use of direct action which, for the first time, was able to convert de jure into de facto change. This, not the War, was therefore the most significant factor in the improvement; achieving something which federal support and the work of civil rights organisations which did not engage in direct action were alone unable to do. The impact of the Second World War was influential in improving the lives of Black Americans because it led to increased federal support of the Civil Rights movement. During the Second World War, approximately 1.2 million black joined the United States armed forces. Their experience in the army allowed understanding the extent to which they were being discriminated against. The hypocrisy of the USA was discovered, a country claiming to be fighting a war of freedom yet oppressed ethnic minorities in their own country. Being sent to Europe, where formal segregation did not exist, the soldiers were able to see what could be achieved from desegregation. African Americans were encouraged to. The War brought significant economic changes to the lives of black Americans. Initially munitions factories would not......

Words: 1438 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

To What Extent Did the Changes in Government Benefit Women and Young People in Germany Between 1918 and 1945?

...To what extent did the changes in government benefit women and young people in Germany between 1918 and 1945? Historians can agree to a certain extent that changes in government had advantages and disadvantages for women and young people in many different ways. The war had just ended in 1918, causing a lot of damage. This resulted in weak government as Germany was blamed for the war in which they had to sign the Treaty of Versailles causing decrease in money and low public morale. From Weimar republic to Nazi Germany there were many changes that government made which benefited women and young people. Weimar Republic was a democratic government formed after Germany's defeat in World War I, the Weimar Republic lasted from 1918 until 1933. It was named after Weimar, the city where the constitutional assembly took place. Life in Germany was positive for some women. Women during this time period in Weimar Germany had freedom and were even offered jobs that were considered ‘masculine’ for example teachers, doctors, lawyers, judges and even politicians. The reasons why women were given opportunities to work in powerful roles was because of changes in government policy during the war when men were drafted for war. In Germany, women were entitled to vote from the age of 20. In contrast, during this time period it was a rarity for women to have the right to vote in European countries. During this time period very few women were entitled to vote in European countries. However, in......

Words: 772 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

To What Extent Was the Federal Government Responsible for Improving the Status of Black Peoplein the United State in the Years1945-1964?

...To what extent was the Federal Government responsible for improving the status of black people in the United States in the years 1945-1964? In the years 1945 to 1964, the Federal Government was becoming more involved in helping the Civil Rights Movement. The Presidents in these years were the first to help the status of African Americans since Abraham Lincoln abolished slavery. Truman deesegregated the armed forces, Eisenhower created 2 civil rights bills, Kennedy put a civil rights bill on his agenda, and this was completed by Johnson. The courts were also heavily involved, making de jure change in many court cases, such as: Brown v. Board of Education, Brown II, Sweatt v. Painter etc. Also, bills that were proposed by the Presidents were passed through Congress, which showed that the traditional views of Congress were changing and were looking to help improve the status of African Americans. However, the Federal government was not solely responsible for improving the status of African Americans. Civil Rights groups such as the National Association for the Advancement of Coloured People (NAACP), Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC), Student Non-Violence Co-ordinating Committee (SNCC) and Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) were starting to take action to improve the status of African Americans, through courts and direct action. As well as this, media played a significant role in the improvement of status of African Americans, as they showed the protests and how......

Words: 1435 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

To What Extent Was the Federal Government Responsible for Improving the Status of African Americans in the United States in the Years 1945-64? (30marks)

...To an extent the Federal Government was responsible for the change of status of the African Americans in the period 1955-63, but there were other factors, such as civil rights groups and important figures such as Martin Luther King, which contributed to this change, and therefore it would be wrong to say that the Federal Government was the main reason behind the change. To a small extent the Federal Government’s actions did bring about a change in the status of African Americans as it provided legalisations being passed which in turn meant that they did want equality in America. The first president, which started the transformation of African Americans status in society, was President Truman. He wrote a report known as ‘To Secure these Rights’, which highlighted the problems Africans Americans were facing, and it also attracted publicity. Also Truman appointed William Hastie as the first black federal, which obviously showed a change in their status. Not only did their status improve but it also gave confidence to African Americans and showed that there were opportunities available for them. However, this didn’t bring any direct de jure change and so therefore wasn’t effective in the long term. Moreover, despite Truman stating solutions to all the problems he did very little in practice and his ideas were seen as too radical and wasn’t supported Congress. In the years 1955-1964, many civil rights leaders began to become more known, and took direct action in order to......

Words: 775 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How Far Do You Agree the Impact of the Second World War Was the Main Reason Why the Position of African Americans Improved in the Years to 1945-55?

...War was the main reason why the position of African Americans improved in the years to 1945-55? I agree thoroughly that the impact of the Second World War was the main reason behind the improvement in the loves of African Americans. There are two other factors which help elevate the position of African Americans after the war these were the Federal Government and the NAACP. The Federal Government can be split into two parts the President and the Supreme Court. Before the Second World War most of the African Americans were working in the south of the country in agriculture. For many they had been born into that life and their parents and grandparents had been slaves. World War two had large impact on the lives of African Americans because it gave a chance for people to start anew. Many people had become tiered of doing hard manual labour every day in the farms. The 1920 and 30s had already seen an increase in the number of black people coming down from the south to the northern and western areas. These areas were considered to be industrial areas. After the war started new jobs were created this meant the demand for workers increased. More black people stated to migrate to the north and west for a job. For many of the black people this could have been a raise in there level of confidence. A crucial part of the employment was in the army, many men had signed up to protect their county. Figures show the migration of black people to industrialised areas in 1940 and in 1945. San...

Words: 1328 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

How Far Were the Federal Government and the Supreme Court Responsible for the Changing Status of African Americans in the Years 1945-1968?

...The Federal Government in the United States is divided into three branches, Legislative; Congress, Executive; President and Judicial; The Supreme Court. The Supreme Court therefore forms part of the Federal Government. The Federal Government played a significant part to change the status of African Americans from 1945 to 1968 in the sense that the Presidents during this period; Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy and Johnson all started to become more involved in improving Civil Rights for Black Americans and passing acts. Eisenhower passed the Civil rights Act of 1957, Johnson passed the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and there were others which showed African Americans that progress was being made. The Presidents clearly initiated a change in America making sure de jure became de facto. However, there were many flaws in the work of the Federal Government and there were other factors which changed the status for African Americans such as the impact of the Second World War and the actions of the NAACP. President Harry Truman (1945-1953), established a liberal civil rights committee to investigate the violence against blacks. A report was produced called “To Secure These Rights” which underlined the problems that African Americans faced during this period. It said that the USA could not claim to lead the free world if Blacks were not equal. This proved that the Federal Government did play a part in changing the status for Black Americans as a previously racist President was motivated to......

Words: 2234 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

How Far Is It Accurate to Describe Black Americans as Second Class Citizens in the Years 1945-55?

...How far is it accurate to describe Black Americans and other ethnic minorities as second class citizens 1945-1955? (30 marks) A second-class citizen is a person who is systematically discriminated against within an area and to some extent, black Americans and other ethnic minorities were treated as second class citizens, not only socially but within politics, legislation and economically too. During the years 1945 to 1953 there were improvements but they were still not seen as equal citizens. The Jim Crow laws ensured that blacks were not seen as real Americans and were to be treated differently. Blacks were not denied the right to education or to vote, but the quality of education was much poorer for them, and the possibility of registering to vote was so low it almost didn’t exist. In 1945, during the Second World War African Americans in the USA were also fighting for justice and freedom. But this fight was not against the Germans or the Japanese. Rather, they were fighting to overthrow white supremacy in America. Socially and economically, black Americans were considered as second class citizens in late 1945. Over 1.2 million black men joined the United States army during the Second World War. The experience radicalized them. Northern blacks were trained in rural military camps in the southern states. This was their first experience of formal racial segregation. They thought they would be fighting for their country and yet their country treated them as second class......

Words: 1882 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

To What Extent Was Nicholas Ii Responsible for His Own Downfall?

...October 2014 How far was Nicholas II responsible for his own downfall? Tsar Nicholas was to a great extent responsible for his own downfall, the main factor being his decision to take over as Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces during World War One. Russia was economically and socially ill-prepared for war and the effects and the outcome of the war had a devastating impact upon the Russian people. There had been a continual build-up of discontent towards the Tsar as a result of Russia’s failure in the Russo-Japanese War, the ‘Bloody Sunday’ massacre and the failure of the Duma. However, it was World War One that was the ultimate factor in which the people acted upon their discontent toward the Tsar. Nicholas Romanov was appointed the Tsar of Russia in 1894 after the premature death of his father, Alexander III. Nicholas was thrust into being the Tsar of Russia at an extremely fast pace and was faced with the task of modernising the biggest country in the world to keep pace with the other super powers in the world such as Germany, Britain and the United States. Nicholas did not have the best of relationships with the people of Russia. Russia’s defeats in the Russo-Japanese war damaged the Tsar’s relationship with the people of Russia. ‘Bloody Sunday’ and the 1905 Revolution which followed, the failure of the Dumas, and the relationship that Rasputin had with the Tsar and Tsarina all led to a deteriorating relationship between the Tsar and the Russian people. Coupled......

Words: 2790 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

How Far Did the Position of Black Americans Improve in the Years 1945-55?

...position of Black Americans improved in the years 1945-55 politically Evidence- Morgan vs Virginia case, the vote, President Truman, Explanation- Irene Morgan refused to give up her seat on an interstate bus and was fined $100 inevitably led to the Supreme Court prohibiting segregation on interstate transport with the help on NAACP lawyer Thurgood Marshall. The Morgan vs. Virginia case did not lead to a change in practice however. The situation with many rulings was still very much de jure and de facto. Black people were given the vote so they were able to vote in more sympathetic political figures. This meant that someone who sympathised black people would be able to do something about it rather than ignore the racial inequality. President Truman established a committee to investigate race relations and to safeguard the rights of minorities. The report of this committee was published in 1947 was called ‘To Secure These Rights’. It called for many drastic changes to be made to the law including changes to black voting rights, reduce lynching by introducing new legislation and to end segregated facilities such as schools and public toilets. Link- This shows that the position of Black Americans did improve in the years 1945-55 politically. Analysis- Despite black people being able to vote, most Southern blacks could not and the possession of the vote did not bring Nothern blacks great gains. Also, poll taxed was introduced to further put off black people voting, as it was......

Words: 791 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How Far Is It Accurate to Describe Black Americans as 2nd Class Citizens in the Years 1945-55?

...these years witnessed some progress throughout the years 1945-55, making it accurate to describe Blacks as 2nd class citizens. Socially, things were unchanged although, the political aspect improved drastically, along with slight economical improvements. President Truman was very active when improving the status of the blacks. In 1947, his liberal dominated rights committee produced the report - ‘to secure these rights’. This report showed the ignored horrific reality of lynching and segregation towards the Blacks that was accompanied by many recommendations, consisting of police training. Truman appointed Blacks into important positions; such as, the first Black Judge William Haste, and Ralph Bunche, American ambassador to the UN in 1949. He issued executive orders to end discrimination in the armed forces, the top ranks resisted for up to two years until the demands of the Korean War set in. Truman’s efforts at de-segregation were rewarded with his re-election in 1948, where he gained a massive two thirds of the Black vote, portraying the large efforts Truman had undergone. Truman succeeded in making many positive changes for the Blacks and placing civil rights on the political agenda. The south saw many political improvements with allowing Black voters. World War II had a great effect on this, with only up to 2% of Blacks having the vote pre-war, whereas after, in the year 1945, roughly 15% of Blacks could vote. At this same time in the North, 16 states granted Blacks......

Words: 735 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

To What Extent Was Gustav Stresemann Responsible for the Increased Stability in Germany in the Years 1924-1929?

...To what extent was Gustav Stresemann responsible for the increased stability in Germany in the years 1924-1929? Between the years of 1924 and 1929, Gustav Stresemann had a huge influence over Germany and helped it regain stability after World War One and hyperinflation. Before he took charge and became chancellor in 1923 Germany’s economy was extremely unstable, Stresemann came to power to resolve many of Germany’s issues. There were many reasons why Stresemann was responsible for the stability, some of these included the end of passive resistance, the Dawes plan and the change in currency, all of these were good factors however some did hold some negative effects, He focused on improving the economy, relations with other countries and improving the social aspects of living. Although Stresemann’s actions and policies had both good and bad sides, overall it was because of these that Stresemann is responsible for the regained stability of Germany. Stresemann changed the currency when he became chancellor after 1923 from the deutch mark to the Rentenmark, this put an end to hyperinflation. Hyperinflation meant that the German currency became almost completely worthless with price rising by thousands from one day to the next. By making this change, Stresemann gave the Rentenmark a better value and allowed Germany to get out of the, what seemed endless, hyperinflation. However this had a negative effect too as the money the middle and working class lost during hyperinflation,......

Words: 723 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

“to What Extent Was Austria Responsible for the Failure of the Italian Revolutions in the Years 1820-49?”

...major periods where Italian revolutionaries attempted to achieve unification through uprisings. The first was in 1820-32 and then 1848-49, however they were unsuccessful both times due a few key reasons. The first reason is the military strength of Austria, as in both periods of revolt, the revolutionaries had no chance of sustaining provisional governments as the Austrian power meant that they were easily defeated and suppressed. Also, another major reason is the revolutionary groups themselves, the lack of unity between the revolutionary groups, the differing aims between the liberals and the radicals and their inability to gain mass support. The final reason, is the role of international countries, in the 1820-32 revolutions, one of the major reasons of failure was the lack of outsider help, particularly the French, additionally in the 1848-9 revolutions, the actual role of the French against them proved to be devastating. Austria’s power is responsible for the failure of the Italian revolutions, this is expressed in the 1820-32 revolutions, as in the Papal States, the liberals set up provisional governments known as “The Government of the Italian Provinces”. However, this didn't last long as Metternich moved his Austrian troops and although there were minor uprisings, the revolutionaries were defeated by the dominant Austrian army. In addition, reactionary governments such as Piedmont and Naples were protected with the help of the Austrian military, as highlighted in......

Words: 1196 - Pages: 5