Premium Essay

The Legal Regulation of the

In: Business and Management

Submitted By litiecho
Words 50477
Pages 202
THE LEGAL REGULATION OF THE
EXTERNAL COMPANY AUDITOR
IN POST-ENRON SOUTH AFRICA

Hannine Drake

THESIS PRESENTED IN FULFILMENT OF THE
REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF
LAWS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF STELLENBOSCH

Supervisor: Prof A.H. van Wyk

March 2009

ii

DECLARATION
By submitting this thesis electronically, I declare that the entirety of the work contained therein is my own, original work, that I am the owner of the copyright thereof (unless to the extent explicitly otherwise stated) and that I have not previously in its entirety or in part submitted it for obtaining any qualification.

Date: 25 February 2009

Copyright © 2009 Stellenbosch University
All rights reserved

iii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

In acknowledgement to all who have contributed to this work in some form: writing this thesis would have otherwise been like swimming through mud. To my supervisor,
Professor Andreas van Wyk, thank you for your leadership, patience, and academic skill in guiding me through the research process. To Adéle Mulder and Charl Marais, thank you for your continuous insight and perspectives, both academic and otherwise.
And finally to Hilda and Gerrie Steyn, who have been absolutely crucial throughout all my years of study, thank you for your indispensable support, in all its forms.

iv

SUMMARY

The worldwide increase of corporate failures on the scale of Enron and WorldCom has sparked a renewed international trend of corporate governance review. With the external company auditor blamed at least in part for many corporate failures, corporate governance reform also necessitates a review of the statutory regulation of the company auditor. In particular, the lack of auditor independence when auditing clients has been under the legislator’s spotlight. The problems associated with unregulated or poorly regulated auditors are well…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Legal

...1. State the administrative agency which controls the regulation. Explain why this agency and your proposed regulation interests you (briefly). Will this proposed regulation affect you or the business in which you are working? If so, how? Submit a copy of the proposed regulation along with your responses to these five questions. The proposed regulation can be submitted as either a separate Word document (.doc) or Adobe file (.pdf). This means you will submit two attachments to the Week 2 Dropbox: (1) a Word doc with the questions and your answers and (2) a copy of the proposed regulation you used for this assignment. (10 points) Department of Agriculture – I am a fruit lover and I like eating sand pears so much, so this new importation rule interests me a lot, and it relates with China. This will affect me just personally, I like pears, but the pears produced by the US don’t taste good for me, I miss sand pears in my hometown so much. This new importation rule makes my wish come true. 2. Describe the proposal/change. (10 points) This rule allows the importation of sand pears (Pyrus pyrifolia) from China into the United States. 3. Write the public comment which you would submit to this proposal. If the proposed regulation deadline has already passed, write the comment you would have submitted. Explain briefly what you wish to accomplish with your comment. (10 points) It’s great to allow import new fruit from China into the US. It’s a good chance for all American people......

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Gambling: the Refinement of Legal Regulations

...Gambling: The Refinement of Legal Regulations Political Science 1020E - 002 1938 words In the UK alone, 70% of adult citizens willingly engage in at least one type of gambling per year. While gambling is viewed as immoral by some, it is still also a source of entertainment for others. This hobby that can range from playing poker in Las Vegas to purchasing a three dollar scratch ticket, and whether the stakes are high or low, the government is wise for legalizing it. History has shown that when the state bans a common interest, even if it done with the intention of protecting the public from harm, criminal activity will arise in order to meet the demands of the citizens. The government can avoid these illegal activities by allowing the public access to gambling, and with control of gambling institutions governments can also make a significant revenue. This essay will discuss the economic advantage of government-controlled gambling, and the importance of refining current regulations in order to avoid harm towards those who choose to participate in gambling activities. The act of gambling is an act of free will, and liberty of the individual should be just as important to the government as the safety of its citizens. Since all actions have consequences, the government should claim responsibility for creating a public policy that ensures the least possible harm for the actions of its citizens. In the United States and Canada, 1.6 percent of adults are considered to be......

Words: 2140 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Legal, Safety, and Regulatory Regulations in Hr

...Legal, Safety, and Regulatory Requirements HCS/341 February 1, 2014   Legal, Safety, and Regulatory Requirements The course syllabus for Human Resources in Health Care by Brown (2010) makes a debatable statement: "Common sense and compassion in the workplace has been replaced by litigation" (Version One). I disagree with this statement. Common sense and compassion are relative to the supplier. Therefore, federal regulatory agencies have ebeen created to establish and enforce legal, safety and regulatory requirements. In an effort to originate these regulations, the federal government has established the U.S. Department of Labor, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and the Department of Homeland Security. Legal Regulations Legal regulations about topics such as wage requirements, work hour requirements, and medical or family leave time is enforced by the U.S. Department of Labor. One example of this agency's oversight is the provision of protected break times for breastfeeding mothers. According to "U.S. Department Of Labor" (2014), "The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act amended section seven of the Fair Labor Standards Act to require employers to provide reasonable break time for an employee to express breast milk for her nursing child for one year after the child’s birth each time such employee has the need to express the milk" (Wage and Hour Division: Break Time for Nursing Mothers).......

Words: 779 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Legal

...We will all face ethical dilemmas at some point in our lives and / or careers. The term ethics is not readily defined, but varies according to discipline. For example, philosophers define ethics as a study of morality, whereas health care providers might explain it in terms of meeting patient needs and owing a responsibility to the patient. We often examine ethical issues not with a specific approach, but rather with a “hybrid” approach, based on past experiences, our conscience, legal constraints, and social influences and pressures. Often, ethical issues touch on legal issues, or are regulated by laws and regulations. Laws or rules are usually established to set minimum standards for society to employ when dealing with others. The case of a woman battling for her life stirs controversy and becomes mainstream media worldwide. On February 25, 2009, 26 year-old Terry Schiavo was found by her husband, Michael Schiavo, after collapsing in their home (). She was believed to had an eating disorder known as bulimia, which can result in heart failure because of the lack of vitamins such as potassium(). Oxygen deprivation during the time of her collapse was believed to be the cause of brain damage, which doctors believed she was in a persistant vegetative state but not drain dead. However, the case sparks the medias attention eight years later when Terry’s husband Michael petitions to have his wife’s feeding tube removed whereas Terry’s parents contest Michaels petition to end her......

Words: 869 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Regulation

...Case Study 1 Kala Bontrager September 14, 2013 AC502:01 Regulation Professor Elaine Lerner In the case between Kim and Son, there is a large deal of consideration that must be made before one can determine who will win the case. Consideration is a means of a legit contract. In Introduction to Business Law, Beatty and Samuelson explain that a contract must benefit both parties, either by promise made to give something of value or by a bargain to both parties being made. This specific case, based on the rules of consideration, does reflect an adequate contract made by both Kim and Son. Between both Kim and Son, there was an agreement made on sides that are beneficial to all parties, a statement (no promise said), and the terms of each side of the deal and there are benefits/bargains to both parties a result of the lawsuit. Both Kim and Son have agreed to a part of the contract. Son offered to pay back what was lost to the best of his ability and Kim in return, said he would not sue. In this particular case though, it has been concluded that neither Kim nor Son fulfilled their end of the contract. Because of this it would mean that the contract was non-existent. Kim promised not to sue and he has, just as Son stated he would repay to the best of his ability, and he ended up not paying anything. One thing to consider is maybe it wasn’t Son’s ability to pay, resulting in why he couldn’t fulfill his end of the contract. Does this mean he broke the contract, if he did......

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Legal

...assume full responsibility for all risks that may arise out of, or result from my participation in the Celtics Sports Program, including but not limited to those risks described in Section 1, above. 3. Acknowledgement of Policies and Procedures – I acknowledge that I have read, know, and agree to all of the policies and procedures relating to my participation in the Celtics Basketball Sports Program. I understand that the safe and proper use of all facilities, equipment or participation in the activity is dependent upon carefully following these policies and procedures. I agree to comply with and abide by all rules, regulations and policies of the Rick Cantu Head Coach of the Celtics.. I understand that the Coach Rick reserves the right to remove or terminate my participation in the Celtics Basketball Sports Program for any violations of these rules, regulations, or policies. 4. Release, Indemnify, and Defend – I hereby release, waive, discharge, and hold harmless the Celtics Basketball Sports program , and all of their affiliates, predecessors, successors, trustees, officers, directors, faculty, employees, agents, and representatives, past or present (hereafter jointly referred to as “the Released Parties”) from any and all claims, suits, liabilities, judgments, costs and expenses (“Claims”) for any property damage, property loss or theft, personal injury or illness, death or other loss arising from or relating to my participation in the Celtics Basketball ......

Words: 813 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Regulations

...GM 520 Regulation-Week 2 The department of agriculture food and nutrition division is proposing changes to current nutritional guidelines for the national breakfast and lunch program. This regulation change interests me because I have young children who attend public school. The other reason that I am affected by this regulation is that I am a health care worker who is extremely worried about people today and how they eat. This does not directly affect my profession, but I can hope that children who eat healthier will grow to make better food decisions, thus cutting down on the epidemic of obesity. The regulation proposal is to change the current school nutrition guidelines to match with the 2005 “Dietary Guidelines for Americans”. The recommendation comes from the National Institute of Medicines report “School Meals: Building Blocks for Healthy Children”. The proposed regulation would increase availability of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, fat-free and low-fat milk with school nutritional programs. It is also proposed to change the levels of allowable sodium and saturated fats in the food choices. My comment is that nutritional programs are a benefit to children’s growth. Currently there are children who come from impoverished homes and they count on school meals for complete food nutrition. It is also vital to at a young age participate in healthy food choices for future healthy eating habits. Thus, this program should help in the long run with reduction in......

Words: 435 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Regulation

... C. The prospectus must be filed after an offer to sell. D. The prospectus is prohibited from being distributed to the public until the SEC approves the accuracy of the facts embodied therein. Non-WKSI issuer World Corp. wanted to make a public offering of its common stock. On May 10, World prepared and filed a registration statement with the SEC. On May 20, World placed a "tombstone ad" announcing that it was making a public offering. On May 25, World issued a preliminary prospectus and the registration statement became effective on May 30. On what date may World first make oral offers to sell the shares? A. May 10. B. May 20. C. May 25. D. May 30. A preliminary prospectus, permitted under SEC Regulations, is known as the A. Unaudited prospectus. B. Qualified prospectus. C. "Blue-sky" prospectus. D. "Red herring" prospectus A tombstone advertisement A. May be substituted for the prospectus under certain circumstances. B. May contain an offer to sell securities. C. Notifies prospective investors that a previously-offered security has been withdrawn from the market and is therefore effectively "dead." D. Makes known the availability of a prospectus. Which of the following disclosures must be contained in a non-WKSI issuer's securities registration statement filed under the Securities Act of 1933? A. A list of all existing stockholders. B. The principal purposes for which the offering...

Words: 1179 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Legal

...Compassion in the Workplace This paper will provide a clear understanding of the following question. Has litigation replaced common sense and compassion in the workplace? When reaching this topic I found that the National Center for Preventive Law has provided information stating that society has a heightened awareness of and acceptance of lawsuits. The workplace currently has the need to address drastic changes in society and employment law which have prompted increased litigation. In the last decade the shift to employment at will has increased. I disagree with the statement that common sense and compassion has been replaced with litigation in the workplace. Legal There are laws that prevent employer from saying and doing things to employee that is not lawful and legal. Generally, the laws that protect an employee’s rights arise from three sources. Those contained in an employment contract that the employee has signed and dated. Laws that arise under common laws these laws are called judge-made laws and statutory law these are the laws that are passed by a legislative body. In limited circumstances an oral employment contract can also provide an employee with an cause of action.  In my research I found the following laws allow employer to work effective under the following laws that have been implemented. Age Discrimination in Employment Act -- prohibits discrimination by employers on the basis of age. Americans with......

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Legal Regulations

...15 Lab #2 - Assessment Worksheet Case Study on U.S. Veterans Affairs and Loss of Privacy Information Course Name and Number: _____________________________________________________ Student Name: ________________________________________________________________ Instructor Name: ______________________________________________________________ Lab Due Date: ________________________________________________________________ Overview In this lab, you reviewed a real-world case study that involved the loss of privacy information, and you analyzed what violations occurred, the implications of those violations, and the possible mitigation remedies that could prevent future violations. Lab Assessment Questions & Answers 1. What is the difference between privacy law and information systems security? How are they related? 2. Was the employee justified in taking home official data? Why or why not? 3. What are the possible consequences associated with the data loss? 4. Regarding the loss of privacy data, was there any data containing protected health information (PHI) making this a Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) compliance violation? 5. What action can the agency take against the employee concerned? Copyright © 2014 by Jones & Bartlett Learning, LLC, an Ascend Learning Company. All rights reserved. www.jblearning.com Student Lab Manual 16 | LAB #2 Case Study on U.S. Veterans Affairs and Loss of Privacy Information 6. Would...

Words: 434 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Regulation

...Army Regulation 670–1 Uniforms and Insignia Wear and Appearance of Army Uniforms and Insignia Rapid Action Revision (RAR) Issue Date: 11 May 2012 Headquarters Department of the Army Washington, DC 3 February 2005 UNCLASSIFIED SUMMARY of CHANGE AR 670–1 Wear and Appearance of Army Uniforms and Insignia This rapid action revision, dated 11 May 2012-o Integrates the Program Executive Office Soldier products list guidance into the Uniform Quality Control Program (para 2-8). o Makes administrative changes (app A: marked obsolete forms and publications; corrected forms and publication titles; and corrected Web site addresses; glossary: deleted unused acronyms and corrected titles/abbreviations as prescribed by Army Records Management and Declassification Agency). *Army Regulation 670–1 Headquarters Department of the Army Washington, DC 3 February 2005 Effective 3 March 2005 Uniforms and Insignia Wear and Appearance of Army Uniforms and Insignia Corps of Cadets, United States Military Academy, only when their respective uniform regulations do not include sufficient guidance or instruction. It does not apply to generals of the Army, the Chief of Staff of the Army, or former Chiefs of Staff of the Army, each of whom may prescribe his or her own uniform. During mobilization, the proponent may modify chapters and policies contained in this regulation. History. This publication is a rapid action revision (RAR). This RAR is effective 11 June 2012. The portions affected by......

Words: 116203 - Pages: 465

Free Essay

Regulations

...The first topic I have chosen is “Should regulations for home schools be changed.” I chose this topic because there has been debates for years questioning the effectiveness of children whose parents have chosen to home school them. Excessive budget cuts to educational programs and overcrowded classrooms have led many parents to homeschooling. While many individuals feel that home school hinders students from learning at their grade level which ultimately withdraws social interaction with fellow peers, other individuals feel that home schools provide much needed structure that focuses on the child. The audience for this topic would be parents of school aged children who are thinking of homeschooling their children. The preliminary thesis statement for this topic is “State regulations for home schools should be changed to ensure at-risk children aren’t neglected, students are socially active in the community, and educators have access to adequate funding.” The two sources I plan to use are HSLDA and As Home School Numbers Rise, Regulations Fall an article from The Kansas City Star. The second topic I have chosen is “Should minors who commit violent crimes be tried as adults.” Chose this topic because violent crimes committed by juveniles is on the rise; and many of these crimes are being given a slop on the wrist because of the minors age at the time. Many of these juveniles become repeat offenders because the judicial system has not held them accountable for their actions....

Words: 477 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Internet Regulation, Legal and Ethical Issues Concerning

...INTERNET REGULATION Legal and Ethical Issues Concerning Internet Regulation Calvin White Park University Outline 1. Intro a. Regulating the Internet: Delicate, difficult, presents challenges 2. Body b. Past i. History of Internet Regulation 1. Early role of regulation a. Mediate connectivity between researchers, government 2. Milestones and events that shaped regulation b. 70s and before - Lab experiments c. 80s - Early commercialization d. 90s - Widespread adoption i. Early malicious activity ii. Educational organizations e. 2000 to present iii. The need to curb crime iv. The need to protect consumers and businesses v. The defense of our nation’s assets 3. Leaders in Internet regulation f. Efforts at home g. Efforts abroad 4. The challenges of regulation ii. Why broad regulation has proven difficult 5. Technology meant for other purposes 6. Grew too quickly c. Present iii. Structure 7. Present-day regulations h. How ongoing Internet regulation works 8. Who controls the Internet? i. Who enforces regulation? 9. How infractions are punished iv.......

Words: 3196 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Legal, Safety, and Regulation

...Legal, Safety, and Regulatory Requirements HCS 341 July 4, 2011 Legal, Safety, and Regulatory Requirements The phrase ‘common sense and compassion in the work place has been replaced by litigation’ is common in a majority of workplaces. Litigation is defined as carrying on with a legal contest by judicial process (Merriam-Webster, 2011). The phrase indicates that legalities have taken over the process of personally making sound judgments and being personally being aware of others issues. Concentration on workplace safety, legal issues, and other regulations has taken precedence to many aspects of our employment; in some cases, more so than customer satisfaction. The customers’ wishes and treatment in the past was always thought to be the most important thing and something that should never be negotiated. However, government and regulatory agencies have indicated that safety and legal rights of the employer, employee, and customer should be protected and primary concern. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) as well as the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) have set safety and regulatory guidelines which protect the employer from causing damage to property, employees, and customers. These guidelines can be viewed as protecting all parties involved in an organization as the employee is protected from workplace injury or exposure and the customer is protected from injury and exposure while being involved with an organization. The CDC has set......

Words: 755 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Legal

...Healthcare has reformed itself in many ways over the years; in the beginning doctors made house calls, surgeons kept the blood on their smocks to show their prestige. This gave way to patients being seen in hospitals and cleanliness promoting healthiness. Overtime caring for patients was not enough; safety and legal issues became apparent. Regulation in healthcare is a requirement now to keep not only patients safe but the organizations as well. The phrase “Common sense and compassion in the workplace has been replaced by litigation” is a statement I agree with. In personal experience when going to see a doctor, they are on such time restraint that it makes it difficult for them to properly treat their patients. Physicians have to adhere by their HMO’s, to be able to practice and have a business they have to follow rules set for them. Not only has it affected the employers but the employees as well. Shorter hours and greater demands have been place on employees in all kinds of business, laws and regulation has been put into place to protect employees’ rights. What should be common sense for people is not anymore. Every time a person turns on the television there is a story of someone suing another in healthcare from neglect during surgeries, unjustly being fired, or discrimination. Actions have been taken and agencies create to protect patients, employees, employers, and their organization against such acts. A few agencies that have been created are U.S. department of......

Words: 820 - Pages: 4