Premium Essay

Proposing a Project Portfolio Evaluation & Selection Process

In: Business and Management

Submitted By zahirc82
Words 2454
Pages 10
To: VP Bill Shackelford
From: Zahir Cassam
Date: February 3, 2014
Re: Proposing a Project Portfolio Evaluation and Selection Process

Executive Summary
Taking into account the poor performance of our current projects due to a weak portfolio management process in place, the Operations SBU has come to the determination that if we are to move forward in accommodating new projects along with our existing ones, the current system must be reviewed and redesigned for better decision-making. This proposal defines a framework for project portfolio evaluation and a project selection for adoption and it elaborates on the two phases that involve project screening, selection, prioritizing and balancing. More emphasis is given to the project selection criteria and score model as this is the main area where the gap of knowledge has been identified.
Our recent organizational determination to sustain by controlling costs and expanding our frontiers shall require much effort from all our SBUs and most importantly, it is crucial that we are able to incubate a proper process that shall boost good decision-making and mitigate conflicts when we come to screening multimillion dollar projects and implementing them as part of our operations. The said process shall be about evaluating our project portfolio and devising a methodology of selecting specific projects with the highest probability of helping our company achieve its strategic goals and fulfill our mission. From the Operations SBU perspective, the implementation of new projects without proper categorization, evaluation and selection will prove to be detrimental to our current operations and annual returns, and hinder our efforts in meeting our strategic goals this year. In this regards, we would like to propose the following Project Portfolio Evaluation and…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

An Integrated Framework for Project Portfolio

...International Journal of Project Management Vol. 17, No. 4, pp. 207±216, 1999 # 1999 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd and IPMA. All rights reserved Printed in Great Britain 0263-7863/99 $ - see front matter PII: S0263-7863(98)00032-5 An integrated framework for project portfolio selection NP Archer* and F Ghasemzadeh Michael G. DeGroote School of Business, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada L8S 4M4 The task of selecting project portfolios is an important and recurring activity in many organizations. There are many techniques available to assist in this process, but no integrated framework for carrying it out. This paper simpli®es the project portfolio selection process by developing a framework which separates the work into distinct stages. Each stage accomplishes a particular objective and creates inputs to the next stage. At the same time, users are free to choose the techniques they ®nd the most suitable for each stage, or in some cases to omit or modify a stage if this will simplify and expedite the process. The framework may be implemented in the form of a decision support system, and a prototype system is described which supports many of the related decision making activities. # 1999 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd and IPMA. All rights reserved Keywords: Project portfolio selection, project management, integrated framework, decision support Introduction Project portfolio selection and the associated activity of managing selected projects......

Words: 8671 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Portfolio Process

...Portfolio Process In order for the adoption of a portfolio management process (which would be new to this unit) to be successful, the following steps must be followed under the guidance of the portfolio management, and in collaboration with the individual project managers and PMO: • Transition from the existing pure-functional organizational structure to a matrix-style structure by which key functional executives, comprising a newly formed portfolio process committee, would be directly responsible for making portfolio-management decisions; • Identification of the strategic goals of both the SBU and the parent company, Sony, and reevaluating goals as the market or technologies shift, or as Sony adjusts its corporate strategies; • Adoption of appropriate methods and mechanics (i.e. strategic road map, target resource split, strategic buckets) for aligning these strategic goals with the project portfolio; • Management of the portfolio by means of a set of selection criteria for proposed projects, as well as reallocating, reprioritizing, and/or rescheduling current projects at various phases of the pipeline, (thus the portfolio and project management processes become interconnected, and the portfolio is constantly reevaluated). As the portfolio management process aims to preserve existing functional departments and minimize impact on the flow of existing operations, we recommend a transition to a project/functional matrix over the next 12......

Words: 1219 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Project Portfolio Management

...Project Portfolio Management Project Portfolio Management is a methodology to manage a company’s projects in a similar way that financial manager manages the company’s cash flow and related finances. According to Rouse (2013), “PPM (project and portfolio management) is a strategic prioritization methodology employed to analyze and manage current or proposed projects within an organization”. The purpose is to determine the best available sequence and group of projects to achieve organizational strategic objectives from concept to conclusion. Project Portfolio Management aims to align the projects, investments and resources with organizational priorities. Project Portfolio Management is a continuous process which comprises of project data collection, evaluation of each project, optimizing the performance of projects in portfolio and resources of company and execution of portfolio work. Companies have deployed project portfolio management solutions for establishing efficient processes to advantage of their IT infrastructure for achieving organizational objectives. Perry and Hatcher (2003) identified four categories as Ad hoc, structured, standardized and optimized on the basis of maturation level of IT. According to them, majority of organization had adopted Project Portfolio Management on ad hoc basis rather than a continuous process. Ad hoc is the level when use of IT, other resources and project priorities are not aligned with organizational objectives. In this stage, the......

Words: 2594 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Evaluation Process

...Process Evaluation Process evaluation is used to help you create infrastructure that supports your project or organization, and to evaluate how effectively that process functions. It will also help you assess short-term changes in skills, attitudes, and knowledge of the participants. Because changes in circumstances may require you to make adjustments in your plan along the way to meet your goals, you and your program officer may review your process evaluation during the term of your grant. You may find that your process evaluation is a springboard to developing other materials. For instance, it may help you generate checklists and timelines, which you can share with project staff, potential partners or funders, your clients, and the community. For capital grants, the process evaluation may be as simple as showing that funds were spent for the intended purpose and that the project was completed. Your program officer can help you determine how basic or developed your process evaluation should be. Before You Begin Your process evaluation helps you organize your thoughts about how you will meet your project goal and objectives through your activities, which should all be logically connected to each other. It is helpful to diagram these connections in a conceptual map of the project, or “logic model”. The logic model serves as a guide to help you define how your program will make a difference. We have included a sample logic model on the following page. The steps of the......

Words: 1498 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Selection Process

...E: Steps involved in selection process (1) Application Blank—The application blank is invariably used as one of the selection tools. The applications are the starting point of the selection process. Where application forms i.e., application blanks are used the data can become a part of the employee's record is hired. Further it provides factual information needed for evaluating the candidate's suitability. Application blank contains written record of the following informations: (a) Identifying Information—Such a family background, date and place of birth, age, sex. height, citizenship, marital status etc. (b) Information regarding Education—It includes information, his academic career, subjects taken at various school certificate and degree levels, grade, division or place awarded in school and college, technical qualification etc. © Information regarding Experience—Giving full details of past jobs such as nature of work, job responsibilities, periods involved, designations, salaries with allowances, reasons for leaving the present assignment etc. (d) Expected salaries and allowances and other fringe benefits. (e) Information regarding Community Activities consisting of details regarding extra-curricular activities, hobbies, positions. 2. Preliminary Interview—Preliminary or initial interview is often held in case of "at the gate" candidates. This interview is usually of a short duration and is aimed at obtaining certain basic information with a view to......

Words: 890 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Portfolio Selection

...Disadvantages of Markowitz approach: The Markowitz method is very sensitive to small changes in the initial conditions, that is in the choice of the data period. Sometimes even changing the analysed period by a few days will greatly alter the composition of the portfolio. Therefore, there is no certainty that the used parameters are stable enough over time. Markowitz’ optimizers maximize errors. It is not possible to estimate exactly the expected returns, variances and covariances. It is assumed that the returns of the optimised assets follow a normal distribution, which in practice does not hold in all cases. Therefore, estimation errors are inevitable. This is especially true when the number of stocks under consideration is large when compared to the return history in the sample - which is the typical situation in practice. As a result, the investor is suggested to invest in extremely under-diversified portfolios or in the portfolios which contain large short positions - which can be seen inVariance is a method of risk calculation through measuring variance around the expected return. However, only losses represent a real risk – therefore it is questionable, if variance is a proper risk-measuring tool. In Markowitz approach, only the expected return is taken into account when modelling the future expected uncertainties. It is a great simplification, as in fact many more factors are relevant – such as the employment rate, economic growth etc. In times of economic crisis......

Words: 471 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Project on Security Selection and Portfolio Construction, and even fixed interest securities which are subject, among other things, to inflation risk. It is indispensable for project investors to identify and manage the risks related to the investment. Investment Management Investment management is the professional asset management of various securities (shares, bonds and other securities) and other assets (e.g., real estate) in order to meet specified investment goals for the benefit of the investors. Investors may be institutions (insurance companies, pension funds, corporations, charities, educational establishments etc.) or private investors (both directly via investment contracts and more commonly via collective investment schemes e.g. mutual funds or exchange-traded funds). The term asset management is often used to refer to the investment management of collective investments, while the more generic fund management may refer to all forms of institutional investment as well as investment management for private investors. Investment managers who specialize in advisory or discretionary management on behalf of (normally wealthy) private investors may often refer to their services as money management or portfolio management often within the context of so-called "private banking". The provision of investment management services includes elements of financial statement analysis, asset selection, stock selection, plan implementation and ongoing monitoring of investments. Coming under the remit of financial services many......

Words: 4274 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Portfolio Modeling and Evaluation

... Portfolio  Modeling  and  Evaluation:   Beating  the  Market       ABSTRACT     During  the  period  of  2005  to  2010,  the  market  portfolio  (P1)  and  one   suggested  portfolio  (P3)  post  a  positive  absolute  return  of  0.80%  and  0.82%   respectively  which  underperformed  the  active  fund  portfolio  (P2)  0.91%.  This   report  follows  various  modeling  methods  in  order  to  back  test  the   performance  of  the  active  fund  portfolio  and  compare  its  performance  with   that  of  two  other  portfolios.  The  findings  indicate  that,  even  though  P2   achieves  the  highest  return  on  the  overall  performance,  the  limitations  such  as   the  macro  environment,  the  assumptions  set,  and  the  Shrinkage  method  used   that  accidentally  downsizes  some  valuable  stocks  in  out-­‐samples  as  they  are   closely  correlated  are  being  ignored.  By  contrast,  P3  will  probably  offer  a   “middle-­‐choice”  which  will  bring  a  promising  and  more  stable  return.                 1 ......

Words: 5765 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Selection Process

...eliminate candidates who fail to meet the minimum requirement of the job such as qualifications and work experience. After the elimination is done, the success candidates will be identified to be called for an interview. Second step is the selection test. This step are used to further evaluate the candidates in many aspects such as intelligence and personality. The test used in employee selection must be valid for the particular job. Some of the content of the test is aptitude test, physical test, personality test, psychomotor test, IQ test, technical test, job knowledge test and work sample test. Third step is employment or job interviews. Any successful candidates will be called for an interview to be evaluate his/her suitability with the job. Few type of interviews method such as one-to-one interview, board interview and group interview can be used in the selection. The fourth step is reference and background checks. This step are applied to verify truthfulness of the information provided by job applicants. Previous employer can provide work-related and personality information about job candidates while former learning institutions can verify applicants’ certificates and qualification to avoid fraud and forgeries. Fifth step is selection decision. In this step, any successful candidates will be informed after a decision has been made. A formal letter normally used for this reason. The last step is physical medical examination. A person needs to be medically fit to hold......

Words: 582 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Portfolio Selection & the Capm

...generated by the portfolio of the assets giving you the minimum variance for a given rate of return. Any set of combinations formed by the two assets with less than perfect correlation will lie within the minimum-variance portfolio and will be the convex. A perfect positive correlation +1 implies that as one security moves, either up or down, the other security will move in the same direction making a straight upward line. A perfectly negative correlation of -1 means that if one security moves in either direction the security that is perfectly negatively correlated will move in the opposite direction. Step 3. The older investor would take the portfolio including Harris and Urban, because they have the lowest standard deviation, hence it is a less risky investment. The younger investor would take the portfolio with Maya and Urban, because it has the highest returns, and can they can take on the risk. At an expected return of .75, the S&P 500 has a lower standard deviation than the stock portfolio with a standard deviation of 6.03 with the same return. Step 4. Bonds and stocks will not react in the same way to adverse events. By adding bonds to your stock portfolio, you can reduce your portfolio’s sensitivity to market swings. The capital market line is a straight, upward sloping line that illustrates the rates of return for efficient portfolios depending on the risk-free rate (in this case .45) of return and the level of risk (standard deviation) for a particular......

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Process Selection

...Chapter 6 Process Selection and Facility Layout After completing this chapter, you should be able to: 1. Explain the strategic importance of process selection. 2. Describe the influence that process selection has on an organization. 3. Compare the basic processing types. 4. Explain the need for management of technology. 5. List some reasons for redesign of layouts. 6. Describe the basic layout types, and the main advantages and disadvantages of each. 7. Solve simple line-balancing problems. 8. Develop simple process layouts. Glossary assembly line Standardized layout arranged according to a fixed sequence of assembly tasks. automation Machinery that has sensing and control devices that enable it to operate automatically. balance delay Percentage of idle time of a line. cellular production Layout in which workstations are grouped into a cell that can process items that have similar processing requirements. computer-aided manufacturing (CAM) The use of computers in process control. computer-integrated manufacturing (CIM) A system for linking a broad range of manufacturing activities through an integrating computer system. cycle time The maximum time allowed at each workstation to complete its set of tasks on a unit. fixed-position layout Layout in which the product or project remains stationary, and workers, materials, and equipment are moved as needed. flexible manufacturing system (FMS) A group of machines designed to handle intermittent......

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Recruitment and Selection Process of Airtel Bangladesh Limited: an Evaluation

...Recruitment and Selection process of Airtel Bangladesh Limited: An Evaluation CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.1. BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY This report is prepared to fulfill the partial requirement of the Internship program of the Evening MBA program of the Department of Management Studies, University of Dhaka. Similar to any other university or business school after completion of the MBA program (academic courses) every student must have to complete the internship program as a required course for the degree of MBA. The main purpose of the program is to know the real life situation. The topic of my report is “Recruitment and Selection Process on Airtel Bangladesh Limited: An Evaluation”. In the age of globalization and the modernization mobile phone has become a more important item to stay connected to their nearest and dearest ones. Not more than ten years before, people could not imagine about mobile phone which was considered to be luxury phone. But now people cannot think without the mobile phone and considered to be a necessary item. There are in total six telecommunication operators operating throughout Bangladesh. The six telecommunication operators are- Grameenphone Ltd, Airtel Bangladesh Ltd, Robi Axiata Ltd, Banglalink, Teletalk and City Cell. In Bangladesh, Airtel Bangladesh Limited is one of the fastest growing mobile service providers and is a concern of Bharti Airtel Limited, a leading global telecommunications service provider. The company offers a......

Words: 10961 - Pages: 44

Premium Essay

Project Selection and Portfolio Management

...H A P T E R 3 Project Selection and Portfolio Management Chapter Outline 70 Project Management: Achieving Competitive Advantage, Second Edition, by Jeffrey K. Pinto. Published by Prentice Hall. Copyright © 2010 by Pearson Education, Inc. 000200010270649984 PROJECT PROFILE Project Selection Procedures: A Cross-Industry Sampler INTRODUCTION 3.1 PROJECT SELECTION 3.2 APPROACHES TO PROJECT SCREENING AND SELECTION Method One: Checklist Model Method Two: Simplified Scoring Models Limitations of Scoring Models Method Three: The Analytical Hierarchy Process Method Four: Profile Models 3.3 FINANCIAL MODELS Payback Period Net Present Value Discounted Payback Internal Rate of Return Options Models Choosing a Project Selection Approach PROJECT PROFILE Project Selection and Screening at GE: The Tollgate Process 3.4 PROJECT PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT Objectives and Initiatives Developing a Proactive Portfolio Keys to Successful Project Portfolio Management Problems in Implementing Portfolio Management Summary Key Terms Solved Problems Discussion Questions Problems Case Study 3.1 Keflavik Paper Company Project Profile Case Study 3.2 Project Selection at Nova Western, Inc. Internet Exercises Notes Chapter Objectives After completing this chapter you should be able to: 1. Explain six criteria for a useful project-selection/screening model. 2. Understand how to employ checklists and simple scoring models to select projects. 3. Use more......

Words: 14292 - Pages: 58

Premium Essay

Portfolio Evaluation

...1) An Evaluation of Client Objectives and Constraints for the South Carolina State Pension Fund South Carolina State Pension Fund’s key objectives can be summarised below:  Provide an asset pool sufficient to meet the long-term pensions and benefits liabilities  Achieve a certain rate of return on the current pension assets for a given level of risk As a government pension plan, the fund has some understandable constraints, which are:  Need to invest in mature and stable large companies  Only a certain percentage of the fund could be invested in equities, meant to grow by +10% every year up to 40%  The remainder (up to 60%) to be invested in bonds Their objective of achieving a certain rate of return is a necessary step to ensure the pension fund is able to meet its future pension liabilities. However, having unrealistic expectations can prove to be harmful where in their case a 1.5% discrepancy in expectations had led to a 120% increase in unfunded liability! The investment constraint of having a pension fund made up majority of bonds can prove to be problematic. While it is true that bonds provide a steady income in terms of coupon plus the opportunity for capital appreciation; the fact that bond prices are inversely proportional to interest rates prove to be a risk for pension funds. Indeed, that is the case for South Carolina pension fund where in April 1996 the fund has lost $400mln due to a rise in interest rates. Also their constraint of investing......

Words: 3038 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Selection Process

...performs and implement the right process in to achieve success in their respective line of business . In to achieve this goal , it all starts by getting the right people for the job . This is where recruitment and selection process happens , which is handled by the Human Relation department This is one of the most challenging and hardest job of HR . Some of the main reasons why it is challenging is that they need to get people who really has the right match for the position . Roles and responsibilities in the job requirement must be present in the person that they will need to recruit or be selected or considered . Even from the point of selection , the HR analyst must be careful that there might be some misleading information that may be difficult to handle most especially if the Job is already given . That is why for other companies at the present , what they do is that the local HR of the company would be working with some top notch outsourcing partners that has more knowledge in getting the right people for the position . These people have deeper knowledge in the positions that is required . This is also the main focus of this , how recruitment and selection of people in the company can be a very important factor for productivity within the organization most especially ROI . In this it will try to provide some important and reliable information that will help prove that improvement in ROI can really be achieve if recruitment and selection is effectively implemented by the...

Words: 398 - Pages: 2