Premium Essay

On Confronting Ethical Dillemas

In: Business and Management

Submitted By eudelrosario
Words 1956
Pages 8
Elfred Ulysses del Rosario MS Entrepreneurship ID No. 11091193 On Confronting Ethical Dillemas The approach used for each case employs an elaboration of the various ethical concerns that are both stated and implied in each case. Along the way, it will also highlight certain moral values that should be recognized as appropriate resolutions to possible conflicts. The importance of this is to be able to identify and compare possible conflicting values as to which of them bears more moral weight regarding the decision or the necessary course of action. It is important to keep in mind that all views have their own foundations of moral appreciation according to certain values. Some of them do share some of it, but their differences give these views their distinct character. CASE 1: Ron Jones The process of bidding in procurement generally involves advertising a certain product or service needed by a company. Other companies providing the said goods are encouraged to participate in the process by providing the terms, specifications, and quotations about their goods. The company in need would then normally choose the lowest bidder, or the next lowest bidder should certain requirements on quality or other qualifications are not met. This is done to ensure that a company in need had considered all possible alternatives as basis for selecting a supplier to sufficiently provide their need at the most reasonable price and quality, and that no biased preferences were implemented during procurement. Because of this, suppliers are obviously competing against each other to secure the contract. And even though I may not have actively participated in any bidding process, whether as buyer or supplier, I believe that as competition, it should be governed by a given set of rules

and ethical norms. As we can see in the first case presented, there are several factors that violate norms…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Issues Confronting "Them" (People with Hiv/Aids)

...Issues Confronting ‘Them’ (People with HIV/AIDS) The issues confronting ‘them’—a metaphor society uses to refer to people with Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) and Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) is not only a physical health crisis but also a social crisis that has and continues to affect every sector of the United States. Accompanying the disease is an acute fear in society that fosters gross assumptions and a lack of education about AIDS. . Because social issues confronting the HIV population presents a series of critical civil rights problems, it is imperative that individuals living with HIV/AIDS are aware of their civil rights as well as know the resources to advocate for themselves when a provider threatens their rights. National legal organizations, like the ACLU AIDS Project is available to enforce their civil rights through litigation, public education, and legislative advocacy (America Civil Liberties Union, 2009). The main social iniquities attached to HIV are those of stigma and discrimination. Social stigmatism toward persons with HIV/AIDS is an infliction of suffering, which thwarts any attempts to fight the AIDS epidemic. Stigma, as a form of social control is a means to marginalize, set limitations, and exercise power over individuals who society considers different through certain characteristics. Social stigma rejects the social groups associated with HIV, (e.g. homosexuals, illegal drug users, sex workers (Bardj,......

Words: 858 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Confronting Inequality

...Confronting Inequality In the article “Confronting Inequality” Paul Krugman compares the new millennia to the 1970’s and has many financial stats to back his theory of income inequality. He backs up his claims with facts and figures, but also gives his own solutions to these problems. Krugman states, “ The ugliness of our politics is in large part a reflection of the inequality of our income distribution.” He states that in the 1960’s was that the governments was in place to sere the best interests of society and that many in modern society believe that government only serves “a few big interests”. His other argument is comparing or capital gains tax to that of other countries. Paul backs up his argument,...” very highly trained British employees face an effective tax rate almost 48 percent in France people with 15 percent in the United States”. Another point he made, he quotes Eric Uslaner and Mitchel Brown is, “In a world of haves and have nots those at either end of the economic spectrum have little reason to believe that most people can be trusted... social trust rest on a foundation of economic equality.” This quote makes me think that in his view everyone serves a function. Some more tan others and strive for economic equality is what we base our lives around. We need people to work in Slaughterhouses, build our cars, and clean our sewers. The fear is that people will not do these jobs without a monetary stimulant. How I interpreted Paul Krugman’s response was the...

Words: 748 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Ethical Teacher

...society, are perpetually connected to reflection. Beginning with John Dewey, during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, numerous scholars have articulated their viewpoints concerning the positive and negatives impacts of this reflective teaching, in addition to its influence on the moral dilemmas faced by educators. One of these people, Elizabeth Campbell, asserts her perspectives throughout her text, The Ethical Teacher, wherein she describes the relationship between ethical knowledge and moral agency, the link between moral dilemmas and ethical knowledge, and the methods of lessening moral tensions in education. Within her book, Campbell (2003) maintains that “ethical knowledge relies on teachers’ understanding and acceptance of moral agency as professional expectations implicit in all aspects of their day-to-day practice” (p. 3). These demands of moral agency are important for students’ learning and development. Consequently, it is essential to understand moral agency. Campbell (2003) declares that moral agency “relates to the exacting ethical standards the teacher as a moral person and a moral professional hold himself or herself to” and “concerns the teacher as a moral educator, model, and exemplar” for students (p. 2). Throughout the text, Campbell explains that teachers must be aware of, understand and accept those demands of moral agency. Furthermore, Campbell (2003) opposes the notion that educators’ ethics “remain embedded in the background of......

Words: 1930 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

An Ethical Dillema

...Ethical Dilemma – Samouel’s Greek Cuisine Joshua has spent several hours researching his portion of his team project. His job is to collect secondary data. The conflicting information that Joshua has found is still considered secondary data even though it is not from a reputable firm. Secondary business data can be very helpful in determining the correct business path for a company to go in. The data, though conflicting should still be incorporated and explained in his research findings to his group. The data is from a government -sponsored website and may be very valuable. Joshua should stay late and examine the quality of the data he has found on the conflicting website. He needs to look at the reliability and the validity of the data that is presented. Who is the information being provided through and how was it collected, and is it free from bias? What was the data in the study originally collected for and does that influence the outcome. The information is from a government sponsored website so there is some credibility in the source. I do not feel that Joshua should ignore this research in his findings. If Joshua feels that he does not want to include this data he should talk to his group and explain why he feels it is not relevant. It should not be hidden from the findings if it has a role to play in the research and can help the restaurant’s performance in the future. There is a value in secondary research and when it is used......

Words: 317 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilema

...Ethical dilemmas, also known as a moral dilemmas, are situations in which there is a choice to be made between two options, neither of which resolves the situation in an ethically acceptable fashion. In such cases, societal and personal ethical guidelines can provide no satisfactory outcome for the chooser. Ethical dilemmas assume that the chooser will abide by societal norms, such as codes of law or religious teachings, in order to make the choice ethically impossible. What Causes an Ethical Dilemma in Conducting Business? by Terry Mann, Demand Media Businesses must have ethical standards. Related Articles • How to Resolve Ethical Dilemmas in the Workplace • Examples of Making Ethical Decisions in Business • Ethical Dilemma in the Use of Information Technology • Ethical Exercises in Business • Importance of Ethical Conduct in a Business • What Is the Difference Between Ethical Business Practices & Legal Practices? In a perfect world, businesses and their employees would always do the right thing. Unfortunately, in the real world, ethical dilemmas are a common occurrence in the workplace. According to the Merriam Webster Dictionary, dilemmas are situations or problems where a person has to make a difficult choice; an ethical dilemma is a problem where a person has to choose between a moral and an immoral act. Employees must deal with pressures to perform and help the company succeed as well as personal temptations to take the easy way out. In the end,......

Words: 2383 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Confronting Ethical Issues

...Issue: Confronting Ethical Dilemmas Review of Subject: Situation 1, Problem Statement per Assignment 2 Description Kay Smith is one of your top-performing subordinates. She has shared with you her desire to apply for promotion to a new position just announced in a different division of the company. This will be tough on you since recent budget cuts mean you will be unable to replace anyone who leaves, at least for quite some time. Kay knows this and, in all fairness, has asked your permission before she submits an application. It is rumored that the son of a good friend of your boss is going to apply for the job. Although his credentials are less impressive than Kay’s, the likelihood is that he will get the job if she doesn’t apply. What will you do? Discussion Given the situation, it would be best to initially take a utilitarian view to consider what the greatest good for the whole team is. In addition, consideration of the situational context and the issue intensity would help to determine the appropriate level of response. Since Kay is a top performer, it’s not advised to replace her. It would make sense to recommend against her request, but to ensure that she understands her importance to the organization. Then, it would be applicable to take a justice point of view to ensure fairness for her in two folds: 1) Interactional: Thank her for reaching out to request permission and commend her for the initiative and interest to grow her career. And then, provide......

Words: 936 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Ethical

...Inventory * 9. The Case * 10. M A N U A L work scheduling is COSTLY and INEF FECTIVE * 11. KRONOS * 12. %IMP R O V E D P RODUC T IVI T Y H I G H E R CUSTOMER SATISFACTION * 13. How it works INPUTS PROCESSES OUTPUTS * 14. BUT w...a..it. * 15. UNPREDICTABLE WOR K HOURS * 16. UNSTABLE h o u r l y W A G E S * 17. Case SOLUTIONS * 18. 1 What is the ethical dilemma facing Wal-Mart in this case? Do Wal-Mart’s associates also face an ethical dilemma? If so, what is it? * 19. E T H I C A L DILEMMA faced by Wal-Mart * 20. Value 1 Re s p o n s i b i l i t y of increasing s h a re h o l d e rs ’ va l u e * 21. Value 2 Re s p o n s i b i l i t y of ensuring employee wel fare * 22. E T H I C A L DILEMMA faced by Associates * 23. Value 1 E a r n i n g a l i v i n g * 24. Value 2 L o o k i n g a f t e r f ami l y * 25. BEFORE we MO V E on * 26. STAKE HOLDERS c u s t o m e r s e m p l o y e e s m a n a g e r s * 27. O P T I O N S continue as is account for employee welfare close Kronos * 28. 2 What ethical principles apply to this case? How do they apply? * 29. Golden Rule Do unto others as you would have them do unto you * 30. Categorical Imp e ra t i v e If everyone did this, could the society survive * 31. Utilitarian P r i n c i p l e Which action achieves the higher or greater values? * 32. Risk Aversion P r i n c i p l e Which action produces the least harm? * 33....

Words: 596 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Google Human Ressources Dillema

...young students this could be the opportunity to jump straight into the cooperate work world, develop more professional skills while earning a college or university degree and having a competitive advantage in their early 20s with both in their pocket. Training is very important when moving into other countries. Their graduates might be highly qualified IT specialists but could be lacking the language skills. Giving young talents scholarships to develop missing skills or directly working with top institutes in different countries as they do in the US could ensure more qualified prospects while enjoying an ethical image in these countries. I big company like Google with big competitors like Facebook can not rest on their fame and will have to take responsibility in taking part in the countries education to ensure that talents to get wasted. Maintaining a positive and ethical image internally and externally will be crucial for the future. Companies that are desirable like Google will be most attractive for especially young talented “geeky” specialists that like the combination of being able to work independently on their own projects while following a bigger goal with other specialists like themselves to make the world a better place. The challenge here is to be able to work on more projects quantitywise without losing the quality of each of them. Internally Google will have to be clearer on what their rules and laws look like. People will need clear guidelines on how to......

Words: 3416 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Ethical Perspecctive

...My ethical perspective: (Beginning of course) Committing suicide, abortion and school violence- these are just a few headachy problems that school along with society are currently dealing with. However, the question here is: “Are they morally correct? “ Being at the age of a high school student and working in the student council, I already have and will surely further have difficulty involving with this challenging question. I was always curious and interested in the difference between ethics and morals. When I was making decision, there had been several aspects and sources helping me to figure out why I did that, it sometimes was from my family, or religion, even situation. In my opinion, I believe that I don’t really make moral decision and form values within a culture that affects me as well as formed system of thinking that I have developed for years. As the book, “Moral of the story”, explains the origin and the arising question of what is moral, committing suicide is one of the issues that I have already faced. Through secondary and now high school, I usually was told and read about the phenomenon of students themselves dying recklessly. When I was at 11th grade, I saw a boy jumping out from the fourth floor, because of the pressure of study that his parents expected from him. It saddens me to think that one could possibly want to choose death over life and I still don’t quite understand it. For me, it is a foolish and moral action. The shortest definition I’ve heard...

Words: 1007 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethical Dillema

...GROUP 1: Srujana Lingampally Document Information Document Details Group Members: | Date Created: | Group: | 1 | Assignment: | Lab 1 Ethical Dilemma | Course: | IT 6643 | Table of Contents 1. Ethical Dilemma 2. Paramedic Method for Solving Ethical Dilemma 1. Gathering the data systematically: 2. Analyzing the data systematically: 3. Negotiating a social contract agreement: 4. Judging each Alternative according to ethical theories 3. Conclusion 4. References 1. Ethical Dilemma GS Bank is the nation’s leading financial institution for all the personal financial needs in America. Jim and Cathy are the two database administrators working at GS bank and also best employees of the bank for almost 10 years. They are also good friends, help each other at work and live in the same community as well. One day, Cathy was running certain database monitoring job on banks customer database which had personal information such as credit card details, account balances, billing addresses of customers etc. Generally GS bank use to encrypt credit card numbers in the tables. When Cathy was running her monitoring job, she figured out that someone was decrypting these credit card numbers and saving onto their computer. When she further analyzed by computers IP addresses, she figured out that IP address belongs to her close friend Jim. She didn’t understand why Jim would decrypt customer’s credit card numbers and save it with him. Recently......

Words: 2572 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Confronting Inequality

...Confronting Inequality Response Paul Krugman in “Confronting Inequality” tries to explain how bad inequality is and the things that can bring inequality up or down. He gives reasons of why he and Americans should care about the rising inequality. Krugman says, “One reason to care about inequality is the straight forward matter of living standards. The lack of clear economic progress for lower and middle income families is in itself an important reason to seek a more equal distribution of income” (322). Krugman also uses many quotes from people who have had a big impact on America to help argue his point about inequality. Quote that stuck out on its own was the one Thomas Jefferson said, “The small landowners are the most precious part of a state” (323). This quote is stating that middle class is very important to a state. “High Inequality…Nation much weakened middle class, has a corrosive effect on social relations and politics…America has moved deeper into a new Gilded Age” (323). Krugman says, “One of the best arguments I’ve ever seen for the social costs of inequality came from a movement conservative trying to argue the opposite” (323). He then quotes the conservative Kristol “We shouldn’t worry about income inequality, because whatever the numbers say, class distinctions are, in reality, all but gone” (323). Although he doesn’t agree with this quote he uses it to better show the controversy between your average liberals and conservatives...

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Dillemas in Healthcare

...Ethical Dilemmas in Health and social care Shoall is a 19 years old woman who suffers from depression and has a history of binge drinking. She has now increasing thoughts of suicide. She does not want that her parents find out that she has these suicidal thoughts and therefore tells the social worker not to inform her parents. When the social worker finds out that Jenny was admitted into the hospital by taking an overdoses, she asks herself why she did not informed Jenny’s mother earlier about her suicidal thoughts. In this essay I’m going to analyse the ethical justification of the question whether the social worker should have informed the parents about Jenny’s suicidal thoughts. In social work it is very important to have respect for the clients right to self-determination. This means that service users should have the right to make their own decisions and solve their problems, whether the social workers agrees with his course of his actions. According to the codes of practice, article 1.3, social workers must support service users right to control their lives and make informed choices about the services they receive. So a social worker might help the client to choose an option, but she is not allowed to influence the client’s decision by using her personal bias and opinions. The right to confidentiality versus the right to self-determination is also an ethical dilemma, which social care workers experience. This plays an important role in suicidal cases. According......

Words: 812 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Decision

...Introduction Jill Jones has worked for Candy Corporation as the Vice President of sales. The ethical dilemma facing her is that of deciding the best course of action in the case where there are no clear cut choices between right and wrong. Jill is charged with the responsibility of reviewing Henry who, apart from being the Company Chairman’s son, is also an accomplished leader who has successfully managed the Miami Branch. The dilemma is further exacerbated by the fact that Jill and Henry have a problematic past. Henry had, in the past propositioned Jill, and upon her rejection of his unwanted advances, he then created an unpleasant environment for her prior to his Miami Branch posting. Jill, herself, is an accomplish and loyal employee who joined the company right out of high school and has climbed the corporate ladder while earning two (2) college degrees during her tenure. Identification of the Ethical Dilemma It appears that the situation between Jill and Henry was a form of sexual harassment, for these reasons: (1) Henry, the boss’s son, propositioned Jill early on in her career, (2) Jill rejected Henry advances, and (3) Henry was able to create a hostile work environment for Jill in retaliation. Jill is ow being tasked to review Henry and provide a recommendation regarding his promotion to CEO. The fact that Jill recognizes Henry’s accomplishments in the Miami Branch Office indicates that Jill would most likely be able to recommend him based on professional......

Words: 808 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Innovator Dillema

...Burgelman and Leonard Sayles, Inside Corporate Innovation (New York: The Free Press, 1986) 76–80. 16. I believe this insight—that attacking firms have an advantage in disruptive innovations but not in sustaining ones—clarifies, but is not in conflict with, Foster’s assertions about the attacker’s advantage. The historical examples Foster uses to substantiate his theory generally seem to have been disruptive innovations. See Richard J. Foster, Innovation: The Attacker’s Advantage (New York: Summit Books, 1986). 37 CHAPTER TWO Value Networks and the Impetus to Innovate From the earliest studies of the problems of innovation, scholars, consultants, and managers have tried to explain why leading firms frequently stumble when confronting technology change. Most explanations either zero in on managerial, organizational, and cultural responses to technological change or focus on the ability of established firms to deal with radically new technology; doing the latter requires a very different set of skills from those that an established firm historically has developed. Both approaches, useful in explaining why some companies stumble in the face of technological change, are summarized below. The primary purpose of this chapter, however, is to propose a third theory of why good companies can fail, based upon the concept of a value network. The value network concept seems to have much greater power than the other two theories in explaining what we observed in......

Words: 82673 - Pages: 331

Premium Essay

Ethical Dillema

...GROUP 1: Srujana Lingampally Surya Yelamanchili Chuks Erinne Munyaradzi Mujeyi Document Information Document Details Group Members: | Srujana LingampallySurya YelamanchiliChuks ErinneMunyaradzi Mujeyi | Date Created: | Jan 25, 2015 | Group: | 1 | Assignment: | Lab 1 Ethical Dilemma | Course: | IT 6643 | Task History Date | Group Member | Description | 1/25/15 | Srujana Lingampally | Initial draft | 1/26/15 | Srujana Lingampally | Ethical Dilemma Scenario | 1/27/15 | Srujana Lingampally | Gather data systematically | 1/28/15 | Chuks Erinne | Analyze data Systematically | 1/29/15 | Surya Yelamanchili | Negotiate social contract | 1/30/15 | Munyaradzi Mujeyi | Judge each of the alternatives | 1/30/15 | Group Members | Conclusion | Table of Contents 1. Ethical Dilemma 2. Paramedic Method for Solving Ethical Dilemma 1. Gathering the data systematically: 2. Analyzing the data systematically: 3. Negotiating a social contract agreement: 4. Judging each Alternative according to ethical theories 3. Conclusion 4. References 1. Ethical Dilemma GS Bank is the nation’s leading financial institution for all the personal financial needs in America. Jim and Cathy are the two database administrators working at GS bank and also best employees of the bank for almost 10 years. They are also good friends, help each other at work and live in the same community as well. One day, Cathy was running certain database......

Words: 2645 - Pages: 11