Premium Essay

Newcorp Legal Scenario

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Mr2008
Words 792
Pages 4
University of Phoenix Material

NewCorp Legal Scenarios

The following legal encounters involve NewCorp, your employer. You are required to provide a brief answer to questions asked at the end of each encounter. Your supervisor expects a substantive answer, not a recommendation to refer matters to an attorney. Your supervisor does not want to spend money on legal advice until after you provide an assessment. Legal Encounter 1

NewCorp hired Pat as manager of real property in Vermont. This position is responsible for activities related to maintaining leased office space. Pat supervised 51 employees and lower-level supervisors, and he dealt with tenants who leased commercial space. Pat relocated from another city 300 miles away, moved his family, and sold and bought a home. His wife quit her job to seek employment in Vermont.

After Pat worked for three months with NewCorp, his supervisor explained that things were not working out and that Pat would be discharged with 30 days of severance pay. Pat was surprised because his employer gave no previous indication of any problem. NewCorp’s personnel manual, which had been provided to Pat upon his acceptance of employment, outlined the process for dealing with unsatisfactory employees:

Notice of Unsatisfactory Performance/Corrective Action Plan If the job performance of an employee is unsatisfactory, the employee will be notified of the deficiency and placed on a corrective action plan. If the employee’s performance does not improve to a satisfactory level in the specified time period, termination will follow.

Pat acknowledged that he signed a document to show his understanding that the company observed employment at will with respect to discharge, but he believed the provision limited NewCorp’s freedom to discharge him at will. Pat also stated that NewCorp’s senior management was noticeably…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Assignment 1: Describing Scenarios in a Legal Setting

...Describing Scenarios in a Legal Setting: Assignment 1 Berlinda Brown Professor: Moses Cowan, Esq Legal 500 – Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance 22 April 2012 The following assignment tasks us with describing four different scenarios in a legal business setting. The first requires a description of the steps necessary to address issues involving an employee’s skills, competence, and abilities. Next we will steps to address management behavior and performance, while the third step asks that we how labor laws should be deal with under a specific scenario. The final and fourth description involves enforcing policies and procedures. We will begin with the scenario involving employee skills, competence, and abilities and give all other descriptions respectively. Describe what steps you would take to address the following scenario involving skills, competence, and abilities: In accessing the scenario, there are two perspectives from which this scenario may be viewed, the business and legal aspects. The business aspect lends one to hear what the employer has stated, review all of the training that has been given and evaluate the outcome of the training in relation to the individual’s skills, competence and abilities. The business setting may allow that we may review the persons actual qualifications in which we may find there is an alternative to the training given, meaning we may find the technique we have...

Words: 2192 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Newcorp Legal Issues

...NewCorp legal issues NewCorp does not have an in-house legal counsel and utilizes Team B staff members to serve as associate legal counsel. Primary responsibilities include advising and recommending courses of action to management covering a range of legal encounter scenarios. Team B members analyze each scenario and provide management with associated legal principles, potential liability concerns, and courses of action. During the past week the Team has received three scenarios and management wants a substantive collaborative effort within one week. Scenario One Pat has been working for three months when his boss discharged him with 30 days of severance pay, because of unsatisfied work performance. NewCorp Personnel Manual was provided to Pat upon his acceptance of employment. NewCorp personnel manual provides an outlined process for dealing with unsatisfactory job performance and provides a corrective action plan. Pat never was approached by his boss on any job performance issues (University of Phoenix, 2011). “Any divergent words or nonexistence of other legal clauses may demonstrate that the employer was obligated to have adequate cause prior to an employee's layoff or dismissal” (Employee Issues, 2009). The law has put limitations on employment at will as it is fallen into unpopularity because employees rely on the conjecture that they have an indispensable job safety provided to them through promises, measures, and policies that side with what is written in...

Words: 1911 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Legal Encounters

...Legal Encounters Legal Encounters In week five Team C examined three scenarios in which a company, NewCorp may or may not have done something illegal. The scenarios were examined and the results written to be handed to management to make a decision on a course of action. The team was responsible for providing management of any potential breaches of law that may have occurred. Legal Encounter One Pat has the right to ask for the reason he is being let go. However, NewCorp does not have to divulge this information because they are an at will employment company. NewCorp, does no t have to tell why Pat is being let go, and it is in their best interest to protect that information. However, if NewCorp at any time told Pat the reason for the termination was related to performance they are liable to uphold the " Notice of Unsatisfactory Performance/Corrective Action Plan." By giving Pat a company document that stated: " If the job performance of an employee is unsatisfactory, the employee will be notified of the deficiency and placed on a corrective action plan. If the employee’s performance does not improve to a satisfactory level in the specified time period, termination will follow." NewCorp has entered into a contract to do just that. This is protected under the contract law, which states "A contract is a legally enforceable promise" (“Breach of Contract Law & Legal Definition,” 2012) in the event of a breach of contract a civil case can be......

Words: 970 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Legal Encounters

...Legal Encounters LaTausha Freeman Law/531 December 10, 2012 Lillian Watson Legal Encounters This paper will answer questions posed during employment legal encounters based on law requirements to indicate liability and ramifications associated based on the scenario. Legal Encounter 1 Cheeseman outlines that employment is subject to the common law of contracts (2010). Pat entered into an agreement with NewCorp for employment; acting on the premise that NewCorp would uphold all terms of the employment agreement, made major personal and financial changes to be available for employment at the assigned duty location. Although Pat signed a document acknowledging his understanding that NewCorp had the freedom to discharge at will—Pats supervisor told Pat he was being discharged because “things weren’t working out”. NewCorp did not follow company procedure to notify Pat of unsatisfactory performance and neglected to offer a Corrective Action Plan. NewCorp, having a signed copy of the discharge at will document, could argue that the company was not required to offer Pat notification or the opportunity to follow the Corrective Action Plan process. An important factor in this instance is the implication that Pat is being released based on unsatisfactory performance. NewCorp is terminating the employment contract without complying with all clauses of the employment contract and as a result Pat is taking a financial loss. Additionally, an employer under the......

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Newcorp

...NewCorp Scenarios Legal Brief Adriana Astte Carolina Mercado Liliana Mejia Rodriguez LAWP/531 March 28, 2013 Professor Ken Marc NewCorp Scenarios Legal Brief Legal Encounter 1 What liabilities and rights do NewCorp and Pat have in this situation? What legal principles, such as statutory or case law, support those liabilities and rights? Liabilities include: wrongful termination, a breach of contract, and freedom of speech violation. Issue: NewCorp fired Pat without notice of unsatisfactory performance after being vocal at the local school board meeting. Explanation: Vermont is an at-will state; therefore Pat is an at-will employee giving NewCorp the right to fire Pat. That means that employees can leave the employment or be terminated without reason. However, according to Kohn (2012), the at-will doctrine applies “only in cases where there is no oral or written contract for an ascertainable or definite term of employment.” NewCorp’s personnel manual included a section on unsatisfactory performance. Pat signed the contract to show understanding of the policies. Pat also acknowledged that if performance was poor, Pat would have a chance to improve by being placed on a corrective action plan. This contract implied that if any employee was not meeting expectations would have a chance to develop. Given the situation that Pat and the family had just relocated from another city implies that NewCorp would have covenant of good faith which “limits......

Words: 1303 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Newcorp

...NewCorp Scenarios Legal Brief In the interest of the company and for the benefit of the employees who are involved in the following legal encounters and those who are not we are making the recommendations of how best to deal with each situation in a manner that will reduce the possibility of going to court or having to seek further legal counsel. It is believed to be the best advice that can be offered based on the information provided in each of these scenarios. Understand these are only recommendations resulting from the limited available information and our best understanding of the applicable case law related to each situation. Legal Encounter 1 Wrongful termination. Pat was hired to manage real property, after 90 days Pat was informed he was to be terminated the only explanation being “things were not working out”. New Corp is an at will employer and Pat signed an acknowledgment of this at the time he was hired. Pat may claim the company is not following the disciplinary action process laid out in the employee manual however this is not a legitimate argument because he is not being terminated because of some disciplinary action. There is a possibility of Pat claiming the termination is the result of his stance on some issue at a school board meeting however he was not pointed out or identified in any way as an employee of New Corp so there is no action that can be linked to his position or statements at the meeting. {OSHA No Basis for Public Policy......

Words: 299 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Three Encounters of Newcorp

...The Three Encounters 1 The Three Encounters of NewCorp Pamela A. McCullough University of Phoenix The Three Encounters 2 The Three Encounters of NewCorp FastServe Inc. is a 25 million dollar branded sports Apparel Company with an employee roster of 350 people working in the company in direct marketing. The company has two online marketing and distribution channels which they opened up for boys and girls. They now moved 10 percent of the workforce to manage the online distribution. In the simulation it states that technology began to pose problems for FastServe Inc. soon after the website went live. FasteServe inc. wanted their target audience to be Generation Y and although the 3-D ‘drape-n- see” mannequins on the site attracted that market it was hard for them to download from the site causing people not to buy any items from the site. This then became a problem which made it hard for technological investors to be feasible. Since this form of selling the merchandise was not working FastServe Inc. decided to move out of online distribution. The fallout of this decision was expected and the online division had to be downsized. Now the only thing to do is to keep employees based on their job performance and skill levels and give them a new job definition. All other employees will have to be released. The senior Management in the Human Resources department has to consider the legal implications of the decisions of the company.......

Words: 1505 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Legal Scenario

...requirements listed in the Florida Bar Rule 5-1.1 (J) Disbursement against Uncollected Funds; A lawyer’s disbursement of funds from a trust account in reliance on deposits that are not yet collected funds in any circumstances other than those set forth above, when it results in funds of other clients being used, endangered, or encumbered without authorization, may be grounds for a finding of professional misconduct. If any of the deposits fail, the lawyer, upon obtaining knowledge of the failure, must immediately act to protect the property of the lawyer’s other clients. Unfortunately, Spock could not immediately act to fix and protect his clients’ property due to the amount at hand and in turn, lost his license to practice law. In this scenario you see how Spock’s irresponsibility and lack of supervision over the Firm’s trust account led to a disastrous result. Spock failed his fiduciary relationship with his clients by not maintaining and overseeing the dealings with the clients’ money that he was entrusted with. As a result, Spock lost his license, practice, and credibility....

Words: 880 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

New Corp Legal Scenarios

...NewCorp Legal Scenarios Employment laws and regulation are created to protect the rights of employers and employees. The relation between employer and employee creates a variety risks that affects both parties. Businesses have to analyze the consequences of dismissing an employee, and take the appropriate measures to prevent legal issues; however, some agents are not aware of employment regulations and make decisions that violate the rights of employees, which create big risks for the organization. This context consists of legal encounters involve NewCorp; as an employee of the company, one is require to provide an assessment to latter refer matters to an attorney to save money on legal advice, and have a brief answer to the questions asked in each encounter. Legal Encounter 1 What liabilities and rights do NewCorp and Pat have in this situation? NewCorp have the rights to dismiss an employee at will; however, the company can be liable of wrongful discharge. Pat has the right to know the indication of the problem and to a corrective plan to improve his deficiencies before he is dismiss. What legal principles, such as statutory or case law, support those liabilities and rights? Employment at will is a doctrine supported by statutory law, and wrongful discharge is supported by case law. NewCorp hire Pat as a manager, Pat signed an agreement that show his understanding that NewCorp observed employment at will and it can discharge anyone without a motive; however, part......

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Legal Risk and Opportunity in Employment.Docx

...Legal Risk and Opportunity in Employment Tester Pester LAW/531 November 7, 2010 Lame Duck Abstract This paper analyzes the legal principles and remedies behind the three scenarios described in the simulation. Legal Risk and Opportunity in Employment Legal Encounter One NewCorp hired Pat Grey as a property manager. NewCorp fired Pat after three months. Pat thinks it is not related to performance but other outside issues. NewCorp maintains that it is not working out with Pat, so he is let go. Legal Issues 1. Doctrine of promissory estoppels. 2. At-will Employment. Vermont is an “at will state.” According to the definition of “at will” on the Department Of Labor, Vermont, (n.d) website, An employer may terminate an employee for any reason as long as it is not one of the protect classes e.g.:  race, color, national origin, religion, sex, age or mental, or physical disability. NewCorp has not terminated Pat for any of these reasons. Retaliation or discrimination against employees or applicants who have alleged employment discrimination is unlawful (Cheeseman, 2010). Pat has not made any employment discriminations complaints. Pat has also acknowledged signing a statement of employment at-will so he should be aware that he can be let go anytime for no reason. Pat can still establish a claim for wrongful termination under promissory estoppels. He will have to prove the termination breached a specific promise made by NewCorp (Cheeseman, 2010).......

Words: 1024 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Legal Risk and Opportunity in Employment

...Legal Risk and Opportunity in Employment Tester Pester LAW/531 November 7, 2010 Lame Duck Abstract This paper analyzes the legal principles and remedies behind the three scenarios described in the simulation. Legal Risk and Opportunity in Employment Legal Encounter One NewCorp hired Pat Grey as a property manager. NewCorp fired Pat after three months. Pat thinks it is not related to performance but other outside issues. NewCorp maintains that it is not working out with Pat, so he is let go. Legal Issues 1. Doctrine of promissory estoppels. 2. At-will Employment. Vermont is an “at will state.” According to the definition of “at will” on the Department Of Labor, Vermont, (n.d) website, An employer may terminate an employee for any reason as long as it is not one of the protect classes e.g.:  race, color, national origin, religion, sex, age or mental, or physical disability. NewCorp has not terminated Pat for any of these reasons. Retaliation or discrimination against employees or applicants who have alleged employment discrimination is unlawful (Cheeseman, 2010). Pat has not made any employment discriminations complaints. Pat has also acknowledged signing a statement of employment at-will so he should be aware that he can be let go anytime for no reason. Pat can still establish a claim for wrongful termination under promissory estoppels. He will have to prove the termination breached a specific promise made by NewCorp (Cheeseman, 2010).......

Words: 1024 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Newcorp

...Sandra Allen NewCorp Legal Scenarios 4/2/2012 Trina Eaddy Many legal issues can occur when hiring a new employee and not giving them all the information that is required by law. All information needs to be in clear detail and must be understood by the new employee. When a manager presents the information clearly, he or she is helping to prevent legal issues in the future. In this paper I will be talking about three different legal encounters. In each scenario I will be talking about what legal issues could happen in each one. Legal Encounter 1 There are some liabilities and rights that both NewCorp and Pat have in this scenario. If Pat decides takes action against NewCorp for terminating him, he cannot use employee at-will. At-will employment means that companies and employees can break employment without liability under the American law. Pat looked at his personnel manual that deals with unsatisfactory employees. In this manual it states that that no employee can be terminated until they are notified of the deficiency and then placed on an action plan. However, since NewCorp personnel manual states this information NewCorp could be looking at a law suit from Pat for termination. Legal Encounter 2 This scenario is shows sexual harassment is happening at NewCorp. This scenario is in violation of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. When people work together he or she should not get involved with anyone he or she works with. Supervisors should not get......

Words: 622 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Newcorp Scenarios Legal Brief

...NewCorp Scenarios Legal Brief LAW 531 April 16, 2012 NewCorp Scenarios Legal Brief Question 1: What liabilities and rights do NewCorp and Pat have in this situation? What legal principles, such as statutory or case law, support those liabilities and rights? Answer: State of Vermont is an “at-will” employment state. The definition of “at-will” means the employer or employee can terminate the contract at any time without liability to other party. This gives NewCorp the right to fire, hire, or terminate for any or no reason as long as it is not illegal. When the employer terminates the contract it is a revocation of authority and when the employee terminates the contract it is renunciation of authority. NewCorp used revocation of authority to discharge Pat and did not violate any rights. Pat acknowledged that the contract he signed clearly said that NewCorp observed employment at will with respect to discharge. Written employment agreements are always enforceable in the court of law (Cheeseman, H. (2010). On the other hand when Pat signed and accepted employment he received the NewCorp personnel manual. In the manual he found that NewCorp has the policy or process in place for dealing with unsatisfactory employees. This gives Pat an implied impression that NewCorp “at-will” policy is limited. If Pat gets legal help and shows that he relied on the provision of the manual in continuing his employment with company or that the law of promissory estoppel applies, Pat......

Words: 1288 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Legal Scenarios

...NewCorp Scenarios Legal Brief Many organizations in the United States of America do not have the budget for staff counsel within their company. NewCorp is a business that has found themselves in legal matters and is seeking an assessment on ways to handle these circumstances from a consultant in the organization before refering matters to an attorney and incur costs. This assignment reviews three scenarios involving NewCorp. We will examine liabilities the organization and complainant are subject to as well as any statutory or case laws relevant to support the findings. Legal Scenario One Legal scenario one explains that NewCorp relocated an employee named Pat to manage the real property division of the business. After 90 days of employment NewCorp determined that Pat was not an appropriate fit for the position and terminated him with 30 days of severance pay. Pat feels as though he was wronged because he was not given the opportunity to improve through a corrective action plan as promised upon hire. Because of this, Pat believes that NewCorp should not be able to discharge him at will and believed that this action was taking place because of statements made outside the workplace. NewCorp and Pat both have rights in this scenario. Fortunately for NewCorp they are located in Vermont that is considered an “at will” state. This means that an employer can terminate an employee for any reason at any time as long as it does not relate to a Title VII protected class that......

Words: 1294 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Newcorp Scenarios

...Scenario 1 In the employee manual, it clearly states that if an employee’s performance is unsatisfactory that the employee will be put on a corrective action plan. This presents a liability issue for NewCorp. One of NewCorp’s managers did not follow the proper steps to let an employee go. This is a legal problem and the employee does have a clear position for a lawsuit. It would be my suggestion that NewCorp would try to rectify the problem before said employee seeks legal advice. If NewCorp would wish to avoid a costly lawsuit the best alternative would be a form of alternative dispute resolution to negotiate a settlement. Scenario 2 As a supervisor Sam is under the rules of management. It is unethical for a supervisor to enter into a relationship with a subordinate. There are the possibilities for the subordinate to say they were afraid for their job if they did not go along with the supervisors advances. That being said, when Paula ended the relationship and Sam continued to pursue her, Paula should have brought this to the attention of HR. This is a potential sexual harassment case and could cost the company a lot of money, time and effort if it is taken to trial. The situation is also a potential discrimination case and could lead to even more PR problems. It is my suggestion that Paula be offered a position in another department to avoid the discrimination case and avoid any further contact with Sam. It is also my suggestion that Sam be put on a probationary......

Words: 493 - Pages: 2