Premium Essay

How to Tell a War Story

In: Historical Events

Submitted By rburner11
Words 1771
Pages 8
Richie Burner
ENWR-106
How to Tell a True War Story
26 February, 2013

If you don’t know how to analyze writing and don’t understand metaphoric speaking then this is not a story for you. O’Brien constantly goes against every Americans thoughts of a war story; he tells the reader that they’re all fake. O’Brien believes war stories don’t actually have to do with people do with heroic things, because every solider is a hero. The average person who was not in combat would not get a true war story because no one has experienced what soldier’s experience. They have seen things and felt things emotionally that no other person will ever see or feel. A ex soldier out look on life is completely different than your average person because they are use to different life style. So all this boils down to one thing, no one will ever understand soldier’s and O’Brien uses “How to Tell a True War Story” to prove this. Through out the story O’Brien talks to the reader as if they don’t know anything. Although he has to approach the reader like this so he can thoroughly explain his point. Since no one understands a soldier’s life he has to write this way, the misunderstanding of soldiers is proven within the first page of the story when rat explains his friend to his sister in a letter that he sent her. “ Stainless steel balls, Rat tells her. The guy was a little crazy, for sure, but crazy in a good way, a real daredevil, because he liked the challenge of it, he liked testing him self, just man against gook” (O’Brien 287). This is one solider explaining another solider to a person who is probably mourning her brother’s death. Im sure the sister of the solider does not want to hear how crazy he was and how he would volunteer for things no body wanted to do. You’re probably thinking well why not, at least she knows he was brave. True but also she is more worried about her brothers…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Structure Analysis on How to Tell a True War Story

...Analyses How to Tell a True War Story In “How to Tell a True War Story,” Tim O’Brien varies from a straight forward approach because of the horrifying contents of war. Instead, his approach is one of repetition, where he retells the death of Curt Lemon, but with different versions. He adopts this structure to make it more tolerable to his audience, express that true war stories never seem to have an end, and demonstrate how truths become contradictory. True war stories by nature are so gruesome and devastating, that the author has to compromise its accuracy by inserting nonfactual, yet more palatable details to cause his listener to believe. The author supports this point when he says, “All you can do is tell it one more time, patiently, adding and subtracting, making up a few things to get to the real truth” (296). In another section he says, “Often the crazy stuff is true and the normal stuff isn’t because the normal stuff is necessary to make you believe the truly incredible craziness” (289). Interestingly, O’Brien reinforces this idea again with the example of the story that Mitchell Sanders tells. Sander says to him, “I got a confession to make… last night, man, I had to make up a few things… yeah, but listen, it’s still true…those six guys, they heard wicked sound out there…they heard sound you just plain won’t believe.” In those examples, we clearly observed how the author uses his peculiar structure to reveal the necessity to season war stories to......

Words: 643 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How Does Hossieni Tell the Story in Chapter One

...How does Hosseini tell the story in chapter one? In chapter one we are introduced to the narrator in first person however we are not told who. We are immediately aware something bad has happened in the winter of 1975 as Hosseini uses the weather to have an impact on the event in the first sentence and continues to describe what went on in the next few sentences. This stands out to the reader and comes across as the main event in the book, the thing the reader wants to find out. Hosseini seems to be using a double frame yet we don’t know what has happened but we know we are going to find out later on. Time is significant as it is used in the chapter heading and in the first sentence, as a reader we think Hosseini uses time to show his feelings and to tell the story through them. Hosseini quickly introduces us to a place: the ‘alley’, and uses a lot of strong verbs such as ‘crouching’ and ‘crumbling’ which also mirrors how he feels about what happened. The first paragraph of the chapter is to set the story which is in contrast to the second one where there is a flashback to ‘one day last summer’ another link to time. In the first paragraph Hosseini tells us about the past in Pakistan whereas in the second paragraph he mentions San Francisco so we know the story is going to change places. The story is in chronological order, even though it is told the date of the chapter is 2001, the story being told is in order and the story is kept in the past. The characters introduced in......

Words: 652 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mark Twain's How to Tell a Story

...Review of Mark Twain’s “How to Tell A Story”: The American humorous story In “How to Tell a Story” by Mark Twain, he attempts to explain how one should tell a “humorous” or funny story. He also goes on about the how an American humorous story differs from a European comic or witty story. Twain explains that when one tells a humorous story, the manner in which the story is told is much more important then the actual content. The humorous story is told gravely and the teller does their best to obscure the fact that there is anything funny about the story. Rambling or a longwinded explanation of irrelevant facts is often used to conceal the “nub” or punch line at the end of the story. Finally, quite possibly the most important characteristic of an American humorous story, the pause that is a recurring feature through out the story. This review will examine how Twain uses these principals in “How to Tell a Story” explaining the art form that is the American humorous story. The first characteristic of how to tell a humorous story is in the teller’s demeanor when telling the story. They must remain serious, straight-faced, dull-witted, etc. as to not lead on to how funny the story may actually be. Twain explains the difference between telling a comic and humorous story with “The Wounded Soldier”. When told as a comic story the reader uses energetic voices to depict different characters and trivial name 2 calling “you mean his head, you booby” (Twain, 13) which brings......

Words: 804 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How to Tell a True War Story

...Brianne ENGL 1126 Summary of How to Tell a True War Story How to Tell a True War Story is written by Tim O’Brien. It is set in Vietnam between the years of nineteen fifty-four and nineteen seventy-five. In this section, the story starts out by talking about a man named Rat Kiley. Kiley is writing a letter to a friend’s sister telling her how good of a man he really was. He also writes about different stories that happened and how he was the first to volunteer for things, just to emphasize the greatness of this man. The sister of the deceased man does not write back to Rat Kiley which greatly upsets him. The story goes on to identify the man as Curt Lemon. Eventually, it is clear how Lemon died. Kiley and Lemon were tossing a grenade back and forth to each other when suddenly Lemon ended up stepping into a booby trap. Another man in the military by the name of Mitchell Sanders tells O’brien a story to teach him lesson. The story is about two men who set out to the mountains on a mission. After a few days of living up there, the men hear strange noises. It gets worse and worse so they order that the land below them be attacked. They pack up their stuff and walk down the mountain. When they reach the bottom their commander asks them what they heard and the men reply with nothing. Sanders claims the moral of the story is that no one listens, you need to listen to the quiet. He goes on to say that the moral of a war story cannot be extracted without a deeper meaning......

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How to Tell a War Story

...How to Tell a True War Story from The Things They Carried In a true war story, if there's a moral at all, it's like the thread that makes the cloth. You can't tease it out. You can't extract the meaning without unraveling the deeper meaning. And in the end, really, there's nothing much to say about a true war story, except maybe "Oh." True war stories do not generalize. They do not indulge in abstraction or analysis. For example: War is hell. As a moral declaration the old truism seems perfectly true, and yet because it abstracts, because it generalizes, I can't believe it with my stomach. Nothing turns inside. It comes down to gut instinct. A true war story, if truly told, makes the stomach believe. This one does it for me. I've told it before - many times, many versions - but here's what actually happened. We crossed that river and marched west into the mountains. On the third day, my friend Curt Lemon stepped on a boobytrapped artillery round. He was playing catch with Rat Kiley, laughing, and then he was dead. The trees were thick; it took nearly an hour to cut an LZ for the dustoff. Later, higher in the mountains, we came across a baby VC water buffalo. What it was doing there I don't know - no farms, no paddies - but we chased it down and, got a rope around it and led it along to a deserted village where we set up for the night. After supper Rat Kiley went over and stroked its nose. He opened up a can of C rations, pork and beans, but the baby......

Words: 2159 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

War Stories

...War Stories Earnest Hemingway and Tim O'Brien both draw from personal experiences in war to write “A Soldiers Home” and “How to Tell a True War Story”. The character Krebs in “Soldiers Home” and the narrator in “How to Tell a True War Story” both display the psychological and emotional tolls that war takes on those who have experienced it. Both of these stories give the reader a view of the experience of war from a soldier’s perspective. While Hemingway focuses the emotional apathy of Krebs, O'Brien's perspective is much more graphic and detailed, with strong descriptions of the scenery, the sights and sounds. The methods used by O'Brien and Hemingway vary, but the end results are similar. Both authors draw from personal experience from war to tell their stories and create the characters there in. In “Soldiers Home” Krebs has a hard time rejoining society. He feels out of touch and unappreciated. This is pointed out when Hemingway states “By the time Krebs returned to his home town in Oklahoma the greeting of heroes was over” (Hemingway 187). Krebs was unable to relate to the people in his home town, as most had already heard the war stories and “His town had heard too many atrocity stories to be thrilled by actualities. Krebs found that to be listened to at all he had to lie, and after he had done this twice he, too, had a reaction against the war and against talking about it” (Hemingway 187). The fact was that the truth was either too boring or too strange. The......

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

How Does Hosseini Tell the Story in Chapter 10

...techniques to illustrate the story including foreshadowing, historical context, imagery and juxtaposition. Primarily, the chapter is written in retrospective narrative like majority of the novel, although in this chapter the writer uses present tense and imperatives associated with second person in order to get the reader to sympathise by involving them directly. By describing the atmosphere of the truck and “a young woman across from us”. Hosseini adds a sense of immediacy to the opening chapter due to the instant jump to the date “March 1981”, five years after Hassan’s rape. The five year gap abruptly changes the structure of the novel, but also indicates that nothing has changed nor has anything significant happened in the story until now when Amir and Baba decide to flee because of the Soviet Union invasion in Afghanistan. Whilst on their way to Pakistan, Amir describes his “car sickness as yet another of my array of weakness, l saw it on his embraced face”. This conveys that Amir still feels desperate to constantly please his father, hence why he puts himself down because in order to gain Baba’s respect and love. In addition, the car sickness is yet another key weakness of Amir and it symbolises his inability to please/ satisfy his father, (hence why Baba feels “embarrassed” by Amir) but also the car sickness is way for Amir to deal with his guilt to rescue Hassan in the alley. This contrast the difference between Baba and Amir, because it shows how unlikely they......

Words: 316 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Does Fitzgerald Tell the Story in Chapter Four of the Great Gatsby?

...How does Fitzgerald tell the story in Chapter Four of The Great Gatsby? Chapter 4 of The Great Gatsby is one in which Nick continues to gradually piece together information about Gatsby, hearing about his romance with Daisy through the voice of Jordan Baker. Several settings are presented, conveying significant messages about the characters and the ‘roaring twenties’. Chapter Four is one where Nick travels with Gatsby to New York and spends time with him in several different places. New York is presented as being both magical and somewhat repulsive, similar to how Nick feels ‘within and without’ the strange world of the ultra-rich. Viewing the city from the bridge, Nick describes it as promising ‘all the mystery and beauty of the world’, however, immediately after, ‘a dead man’ is described. This could be implying that the ‘jazz age’ is not all that it seems to be, with Fitzgerald revealing that the ‘mystery and beauty’ is only a façade hiding a much darker truth. In addition, the way that the ‘valley of ashes’ is described as opening ‘out on both sides’ could convey the poignant message that death is inescapable in this seemingly wondrous environment. Alternatively, Fitzgerald could be comparing the setting of New York with Gatsby. Before we are introduced to Gatsby, he is presented as almost mythical, magical, but mysterious, just as the city appears from a distance. However, meeting Gatsby could be seen as disappointing, as he is simply an ordinary, wealthy man with......

Words: 579 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How Does Rossetti Tell the Story in ‘Cousin Kate?’

...three when Rossetti uses the phrase ‘He lifted you from mean estate’, showing that when Kate left the ‘cottage’ with the Lord he raised her social status, this could explain the two women’s attraction for the ‘Great Lord.’ Within the setting of the ‘palace’ Rossetti uses an avian motif to depict the two women. Rossetti refers to Kate as being ‘bound’ in a bird cage though her marriage to the Lord: ‘you sit in gold and sing.’ Rossetti presents the ‘palace’ to be an aggressive, constraining force on both of the women’s lives as, Kate as she is ‘bound’ in the palace and the narrator as she has been ‘outcast’ due to her ‘shameful’ experience with the Lord in the ‘palace.’ Rossetti uses the unnamed, homodiagetic narrative voice to tell the story throughout the poem. The narrator is unnamed however the narrator’s persona is presented through the first person narrative. The fact Rossetti does not name the narrator emphasises her ‘outcast’ status of the narrator from the rest of society. The narrator no longer has a place in society and therefore no longer has a name in society. Rossetti shapes the tone of the narrative throughout the poem to mirror the narrator’s feelings towards the events the she is recounting. The tone changes from regret: ‘why did a great lord find me out’, in the first stanza Rossetti presents the narrator’s regret for leaving with the Lord. Rossetti does this at the start of the narrative so that readers feel sympathy towards the narrator. The tone,......

Words: 1218 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Does Fitzgerald Tell the Story in Chapter 5 of the Great Gatsby?

...In Chapter 5 of The Great Gatsby the story is told through the theme of love and relationships as Fitzgerald introduces the reader to the revival of Daisy’s and Gatsby’s relationship, followed by a detailed description of their exploration of Gatsby’s house. It is in Chapter 5 when Gatsby shows his true self, as these emotions are revealed to the reader as the chapter progresses, with Gatsby becoming more confident around Daisy. When Nick agrees to invite Daisy for tea, we see another side to Gatsby when he offers Nick a job, which ‘might pick up a nice bit of money’. This use of voice emphasises the fact that Gatsby’s ‘side line’ business is not likely to be respectable. This glimpse into the gangster side of Gatsby foreshadows Tom’s investigation into Gatsby’s ‘drug-stores’, which is revealed to be bootlegging. Later on Nick describes Gatsby as ‘pale as death’. This violent metaphor foreshadows Gatsby’s death at the end of the novel. Gatsby was ‘glaring tragically’ into Nick’s eyes, which is the first description in the novel that suggests Gatsby is no longer in control. Up until now, Gatsby’s performance is close to perfect, so the sudden vulnerability of the hero is surprising to the reader, and stresses just how strong his feelings are towards Daisy, who is waiting inside Nick’s house. Fitzgerald uses pathetic fallacy as rain appears when Gatsby and Daisy meet for the first time, ominously foreshadowing their relationship and Gatsby's fate. When Daisy finally......

Words: 616 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Does Austen Tell the Story in Chapter 16

...Chapter 16 allows the progression of the relationship between Elizabeth and Wickham. It consists almost entirely of dialogue subsequent of Elizabeth witnessing the cold interaction between Darcy and Wickham. The chapter moves the story forward and begins by diving straight into the visit to Meryton, along side this is Austens third person omniscient narration and use of omnipresent irony to highlight Mr Collin's unctuous manner. Upon arrival at the Phillip's house the girls "had the pleasure of hearing" that Wickham has accepted the invitation and was then in the house. This is telling of the girls early perception of Wickham and the reader is also included in this. The narrator then goes onto satirically mock Collins via authorial intervention as he compares Mrs Phillips home to Lady Catherine De Bourgh's "small summer breakfast parlour", Phillips does not take so kindly to the comment at first until she is made aware of Lady Catherine and is then said to of "felt all the force of the compliment", this is fitting with the motif of pride and first judgements. Collins then goes onto mention Lady Catherines "eight hundred pound" chimney piece, Austen again mocking Collins obsequious character. Austens often contrasts situations and characters, she describes Wickham as "far beyond them all" in reference to the other officers, whilst speaking so highly of Wickham, Austen goes on to condemn the Bennet sisters uncle through an epigrammatic statement, referring to him as......

Words: 847 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ratios Tell Stories

...UV1765 RATIOS TELL A STORY—2005 Financial results vary between companies for a number of reasons. One reason for the variation can be traced to the characteristics of the industries in which the companies operate. For example, some industries require large investments in property, plant, and equipment, while others require very little. In some industries, the product-pricing structure allows companies to earn significant profits per sales dollar, while in other industries the product-pricing structure imposes a much lower profit margin. In most low-margin industries, however, companies often experience a relatively high volume of product throughput in their businesses. A number of industries are also characterized by lenient credit terms, while others sell for cash only. A second reason for some of the variation in financial results between companies is the result of management policy. Some companies reduce their manufacturing capacity to match more closely their immediate sales prospects, while others carry excess capacity to be prepared for future expansion. Also, some companies finance their assets with borrowed funds, while others avoid that leverage and finance their assets with owners’ equity. Of course, one other reason for some of the variation in reported results between companies is the differing competencies of management. Given the same industry characteristics and the same management policies, different companies may report different financial results simply......

Words: 1871 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

How Does Fitzgerald Tell the Story in Chapter 1?

...How does Fitzgerald tell the story in chapter 1? Chapter 1 is used by Fitzgerald to create the world in which you are about to read into, by characterising the characters within the book almost straight away through the first person narration by Nick Caraway. For example “her face was sad and lovely with bright things in it, bright eyes and a bright passionate mouth.” Here Daisy Buchanan is characterised to seem romantic, “lovely…bright passionate mouth.” Through this, and various other chapters in the novel, we can see how she portrays the theme of romanticism in the novel, however this will directly contrast with how she is materialistic and seems to be more in love with possessions and money rather her husband, and so she is more in love with the idea of wealth and what her husband can provide for her rather than being in love with him. The juxtaposition of “sad and lovely” can create questioning within the reader as to where there is something beneath the surface that explains her misery, due to the adjectives contrasting one another. This could suggest that Daisy is trying to put on an act to the public, yet Nick sees through the persona and sees the sadness within her. The repetition of “bright” creates a sense of youthfulness in Daisy, which contrasts to where she lives; East Egg, which is known as the ‘old rich’ side. This description can also contrast with another location near to Daisy, “the valley of ashes” as the people are described as “ash-grey” which shows...

Words: 738 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How Does Browning Tell the Story in the Laboratory

...How does Browning tell the story in the Laboratory Robert Brownings, The Laboratory tells the story of a woman entering the “devil’s smithy” in order to create a poison, in which would kill the woman because she was seeing a man. The Laboratory is told in first person narrative so immediately it makes the poem very imitate with the reader and so we feel like the woman is speaking to the reader about her problems and how she is going to kill the woman. The quote “he is with her” shows how she doesn't like how the man has gone for the woman but also the tone of this is very spiteful when she says this and shows how the woman is arrogant. As the woman speaks she uses imperatives like “grind” and “pound” the use of these violent imperatives show her edging on and how she is reinforcing her pleasure showing how she is enjoying herself with what she is about to do. The quote “I am no it haste” also shows how she is enjoying the pleasure of the poison. The woman can also be viewed as scornful shown in the line "he is sure to remember her dying face", suggesting she wants a seemingly innocent woman to die ugly, simply because she spoke to a man she should not have by the woman. Browning also uses the use of exclamttives to show the characters journey through the poem, “a filigree basket!”, this exclamative shows how the woman is getting more excited about the poison and it shows the delight in which she enjoys. Browning also uses context in his he telling of the story in...

Words: 783 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Tell of Two Stories

...Literature Instructor: April 6, 2015 Haunted by the decisions we make! How can the decisions we make affect us and those around us. The two stories I have chosen are “A Rock Trying to Be a Stone” by Sergio Troncoso and “The Things They Carried” by Tim O’Brien. These two stories both have the main characters having to battle internal conflicts versus themselves. Some of the literary techniques used in these two stories are conflict, exposition, first-person point of view and resolution. Both of the main characters face conflicts of the individual verses self. The decisions they make not only affects them but also everyone around them. The decision we make in life when trying to overcome an internal self-conflict could change our lives, the lives of our family and those around us. In the “A Rock Trying to Be a Stone”, the author used first-person point of view as his literary technique. The narrator takes part as the main character telling us the stories as he sees and experiences it. He does a thorough job describing the main characters and the environment where the climax happens. We have the ring leader Joe, he is older and bigger than the others boys. We have Fernandez the one who seems like the dumb immature one. Next we have Chuy, he is a mentally challenged kid who goes along with the other boys. Last we have the narrator, he does not divulge his name during this short story but he seems very leveled headed about things that are going on around him.......

Words: 1190 - Pages: 5