Premium Essay

Discuss the Advantages of Replacing the Current System of Voting in the Uk.

In: Social Issues

Submitted By hanik08
Words 982
Pages 4
Discuss the advantages for replacing the current system for electing MPs with another one.
There are two main types of electoral systems in the UK. They are First Past the Post (FPTP) and Proportional Representation (PR)
First Past the Post is the voting system used to elect MPs to 'seats' in Parliament. In this system 'winner takes all' and the system also usually gives a clear majority both in a constituency or at national level. This means that a candidate in a constituency only needs one more vote than the nearest rival to win the seat. This is similar to political parties in general elections as they only need to win one more seat in the House of Commons to have a majority.
The advantages of using FTPT is there is very little chance of extremist parties being elected to Parliament under because they are unlikely to gain enough votes to come into power in any one constituency. Also, generally the results of elections using FPTP can be calculated quickly. So, this makes it easier to transfer power to another party if it becomes necessary.
One of the main criticisms of FPTP is that the number of votes for a party in general elections is not accurately shown in the number of seats won. An example of this could be the 1997 election when the Conservatives gained 18% of the vote in Scotland but not one but didn’t win a seat. This is can be seen at constituency level, where the winning candidate may have only received one third of the votes cast. So, a government could be elected on a minority vote. This happened in 1974 when Labour won the general election on the number of seats they gained but the Conservatives had a larger share of the vote across the country. This would show poor representation of the population in the government that was formed.
Another criticism could be that, smaller parties are not fairly treated under FPTP. Although they may have large…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Electronic Voting System

...Applying MESE processes to Improve Online E-Voting Prototype System with Paillier Threshold Cryptosystem Web Services Version 1.00 A project submitted to the Faculty of Graduate School, University of Colorado at Colorado Springs in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Engineering in Software Engineering Department of Computer Science Prepared by Hakan Evecek CS701 Dr. Chow Spring 2007 This project for the Masters of Engineering in Software Engineer degree by Hakan Evecek has been approved for the Department of Computer Science By _______________________________________________________ Dr. C. Edward Chow, Chair _______________________________________________________ Dr. Richard Weiner _______________________________________________________ Dr. Xiaobo Zhou Date Table of Contents Online E-Voting System Project Documentation 4 Abstract 6 1. Introduction 7 2. E-Voting System Related Literature 9 2.1. Public Key Cryptography 9 2.2. Homomorphic Encryption 10 2.3. Zero Knowledge Proofs 10 2.4. Threshold Cryptography 10 2.5. Cryptographic Voting Protocol 11 2.6. Issues in secure e-voting system 12 2.7. Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart (CAPTCHA) 13 2.8. Chinese Remainder Theorem (CRT) 14 3. Online E-Voting System Project Description 17 3.1. Paillier......

Words: 7163 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

Current Uk Economic Conditions

...Section B - Current UK Economic Conditions Information and definition UK The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is also known as UK, United Kingdom or Britain. United Kingdom is a member of European Union, G 8, G-20, World Trade Organization, Common Wealth of Nations, United Nations Security Council, NATO, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). United Kingdom is a well developed country. It has a rich economy brought up by economies of its individual countries England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Landon which is the capital of UK and England is the most important financial center for international business and commerce. UK is one of the most important globalised countries of the world. GDP GDP, or Gross domestic product is a measure of a country's economic activity, namely of all the services and goods produced in a year. It is arguably the most important of all economic statistics as it attempts to capture the state of the economy in one number. Quite simply, if the GDP measure is up on the previous three months, the economy is growing. If it is negative it is contracting, and two consecutive three-month periods of contraction mean an economy is in recession. GDP is based on a huge survey of businesses and government departments compiled by the Office for National Statistics. Credit rating The BBC News explains that “Credit ratings are issued by credit rating agencies, private companies who sell their financial......

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Automated Voting System

...personnel in a voting station or precinct. The researcher seeks a fully automated voting system that is secure, accurate and reliable so that the system to guarantee elections the voters can trust the implemented system in our school. In today’s modern age where computer has become a way of life, it is evident that a majority of the countries institutions still do not adopt the high technology and practicing this process in the real life. This innovation, like all of our solutions, will help the students exercise their rights to vote during some of toughest, most disputed elections. Students can verify that their on screen elections were recorded accurately to review their votes to invite public trust and establish the credibility of election and apply this process in real time and having a system that is fully automated, user – friendly, time effective and efficient. Voters can also experience a customized interface by uses graphic elements such as image, logo of an officer or their parties to be able to the students being already familiar of a candidate. Also, voting systems allow voters to cast their choice more quickly and allow the results to be known and had a chance to review their votes. This voting process reduces the cost of holding of an election because it requires greatly reduced human and economic resources. It has been designed to make this simple procedure. Creating what we believe is the most transparent automated-voting process......

Words: 1920 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

With Reference to Appropriate Scholarship, Discuss the Advantages and Disadvantages of the News Service Provided to the Uk Population by the Free-Market Sun Newspaper and the Public Service Bbc.

...With reference to appropriate scholarship, discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the news service provided to the UK population by the free-market Sun newspaper and the public service BBC. This essay is going to discuss what a free-market is, what a tabloid is, how the Sun newspaper operates, what is a public service, how the BBC operates and it will compare the advantages and disadvantages of the Sun and the BBC. A free market is a market without economic invention and regulation by government except to enforce ownership and contacts. It is the opposite of a controlled market, where the government regulates how the means of production, goods, services and labor are used, priced, or distributed. When established, the press was organized as a ‘free market’ system, in a private ownership. The theory was that this would be best for democracy and society, a “Free marketplace of ideas”. Anyone can start a newspaper. The market empowers the consumer and fosters freedom. Nowadays, only a small part of the press is concerned with public affairs. 80% of the papers are tabloids, less than 20% of the content of the popular press is “public information”. According to the dictionary a tabloid is a newspaper with pages about half the size of a standard (broadsheet) newspaper. However, in more recent years the word tabloid has become synonymous with words like gossip, scandal and ‘exclusive’. By circulation The Sun is the tenth biggest newspaper in any language in the world...

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Analysis of an Electronic Voting System

...Electronic Voting System TADAYOSHI KOHNO∗ A DAM S TUBBLEFIELD† DAN S. WALLACH§ February 27, 2004 AVIEL D. RUBIN‡ Abstract With significant U.S. federal funds now available to replace outdated punch-card and mechanical voting systems, municipalities and states throughout the U.S. are adopting paperless electronic voting systems from a number of different vendors. We present a security analysis of the source code to one such machine used in a significant share of the market. Our analysis shows that this voting system is far below even the most minimal security standards applicable in other contexts. We identify several problems including unauthorized privilege escalation, incorrect use of cryptography, vulnerabilities to network threats, and poor software development processes. We show that voters, without any insider privileges, can cast unlimited votes without being detected by any mechanisms within the voting terminal software. Furthermore, we show that even the most serious of our outsider attacks could have been discovered and executed without access to the source code. In the face of such attacks, the usual worries about insider threats are not the only concerns; outsiders can do the damage. That said, we demonstrate that the insider threat is also quite considerable, showing that not only can an insider, such as a poll worker, modify the votes, but that insiders can also violate voter privacy and match votes with the voters who cast them. We conclude that this......

Words: 12856 - Pages: 52

Premium Essay

Prstv Voting System

...The Irish Electoral system of PR-STV is Fundamentally Flawed and should be replaced by the Single Member Plurality System In today’s environment of political apathy and scepticism it is particularly important that we scrutinise our political policies and procedures, so as to bolster a confidence of our countries governance in its people. Electoral systems are perhaps one of the most important aspects of the political process as they are the people’s main mechanism for having their voices heard. The main challenge for any political system is to strive to assist in creating a government that is an accurate representation of its citizen’s desires and future hopes for its political direction while ensuring stable governance. This essay will discuss the Irish electoral system of Proportionate Representation through the Single Transferable Vote (PRSTV) and whether a Single Member Plurality (SMP) system is a viable and worthwhile alternative. By first giving a brief history of the Irish electoral system as well as an explanation of how both systems operate. Then laying out some of these electoral systems advantages as well as disadvantages. Dáil Éireann and its members, Teachtai Dála (TDs) have been elected by the PRSTV electoral system since Irish independence in 1922. There are two main reasons for this. In the early 1900s a period in which Ireland was going through great political change PRSTV had historical support by the nationalist movement, which had the biggest......

Words: 1618 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Discuss the Controversies, Changes and Potential Outcomes of the Current State Pension’s Situation in the Uk

...accordance with the new rules for the pension the full single tier pension will be only given to people with at least 35 years national insurance contributions or credits. Individuals reaching state pension age from 6th April 2016 onwards would be affected with the new single tier, flat rate state pension changes being put in place. During mid 2014, parliament agreed the Pensions Act 2014; to introduce a single tier, flat rate State Pension, to replace the current basic and additional pensions in place for individuals reaching the pension age. The State Pension age to be increased from 66 to 67 between April 2026 and April 2028. Furthermore to set terms for reviews of the State Pension age every 5 years. The new state pension has been put in place to introduce a simple and much fairer system where individuals will have some knowledge about what they will be entitled from the government so they can plan there retirement savings. However this will replace the complexity, high levels of means testing and inequality. In the current state pension regulations women get lower pensions than men, this is inequality. Individuals will need to have contributed at least 35 years NI contributions to qualify for the full single tier state pension. For those that have between 10 and 34 years of contributions will receive only part of the state pension. However, other means tested benefits such as pension credit will remain but the savings credit element will be bought to an end.......

Words: 752 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Voting System

...CHAPTER 2 FOREIGN LITERATURE “Electronic Voting Literature” Voting on the internet using PC's everyday offers only weak security, but its main disadvantages are in the areas of anonymity and protection against coercion and/or vote selling. The Presidential elections of 2000 brought national attention to problems with current American methods of casting and counting votes in public elections. Most people believe that the current system should be changed; there is much disagreement on how such changes should be made. Dr. Michael Shamos of CMU provides a sharp counterpoint [6] to Neumann and Mercuri's views. While his “Six Commandments” summary of requirements for a voting system is very similar to others' requirements, he's less afraid of the catastrophic failures and sweeping fraud made possible by imperfections in electronic voting machines actually occurring in a real election. Shamos is also much less impressed with paper ballots than are Neumann and Mercuri. He places a great deal of faith in decentralization to make fraud difficult to commit and easy to detect. Dr. Shamos even likes DRE machines. (We must take into account the fact that this paper was written ten years ago, long before the 2000 elections and before more modern mathematical results like Chaum's; some of Dr. Shamos' opinions may have changed since then. While Dr. Neumann's talk cited here is of similar age, his pessimism with regard to machines has had little reason for change.) Rebecca Mercuri......

Words: 1446 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Assess the Advantages of the Various Electoral Systems

...Assess the advantages of the various electoral systems One of the many electoral systems is the First-Past-The-Post system (FPTP), the current system for electing MPs to the House of Commons. There are 659 separate constituencies across the UK each electing one single Member of Parliament. In order to vote you simply put an ‘X’ next to the name of the candidate you support. The candidate who gets the most votes wins, regardless of whether he or she has more than 50% support. Once members have been individually elected, the party with the most seats in Parliament, regardless of whether or not it has a majority, normally becomes the next government. FPTP tends to lead to a two-party system where two major political parties dominate politics within a government. The system tends to produce single party governments, which are strong enough to create legislation and tackle the country’s problems, without relying on the support of any other party. In these single party governments, the FPTP electoral system provides a close link between the MP and their constituency, due to the system also representing the views of the people, as the candidate with the greatest support wins through a fair process. However, only one MP is elected in each constituency, so all the voters who did not vote for him or her are not represented. Their votes do not help elect anybody and so are wasted, they could have stayed at home and the result would not have been altered. In addition to this, there is a...

Words: 961 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of E-Voting

...Advantages & Disadvantages of E-voting An electronic voting system (on-line voting, internet voting) is an election system which uses electronic ballot that would allow voters to transmit their secure and secret voted ballot to election officials over the internet. With the prosperity of internet over the years, inventers start to make the use of electronic voting in order to make the voting process more convenient and raise the participation of the civic. From now on, engineers have repeatedly created new technology to improve the feasibility of electronic voting system. Advantages of e-voting The advocate of electronic voting claims that the convenience, mobility, tally speed, less cost, and flexibility are the main advantages. Following are the descriptions of the advantages. • Convenience : With the well-designed software and system, the voters can simply use his voting equipment with the minimal time and skill to finish the voting process. • Mobility : Voters can cast their votes at a specific polling place, home, or any place in which they can get access to the internet. People can even use the mobile device such as cell phone or PDA to vote. There is no restriction on the location. • Tally Speed : Once the voting time is over,the computer can immediately calculate the result of the election. It is much faster than the traditional ballot counting method operated by people. • Less Cost : Compared to paper ballot voting,electronic voting saves money......

Words: 666 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Stability Rather Than Volatility, Now Characterises Voting Behaviour at Uk General Elections. Discuss

...Stability rather than volatility, now characterises voting behaviour at UK general elections. Discuss There are many reasons why people choose to vote. Whether they have a strong view that agrees with the party they are voting for, or they are tactically voting so a certain party that they really don’t like doesn't get into parliament. Most of the time voting is devided into short term and long term decisions, which means that a certain member of the family will vote differently than usual because of a certain law that a party wants to pass. Recently, and leading up to the 2015 General election, there have been declining levels of class alignment. This means that a member of the public that usually votes conservative, might decide to vote labour, or vice versa. This shows the volatile side of voting as these statistics change depending on what the parties promise, however, it is becoming more common for people to vote the opposite to what they usually vote for because of party policies. This makes it very hard for people to predict the way other people are going to vote. Another point of volatile short term voting, is the declining levels of party id. This means there has been an increase in floating voters. The 2010 general election resulted in a coalition with the Liberal Democrats, and the Conservatives. In some respects, this was a surprising coalition and many of the parties laws they promised to change, never happened. Again this has had a knock on effect for the...

Words: 596 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

System Voting

... The motto of the project is to build an enterprise site, which should be able to allow people to cast their vote online. SYSTEM ANALYSIS Existing System Remote voting is exercise into two different ways. 1.proxy voting The person who is unable to be physically present authorized other person on behalf of him. 2. close envelope ballet In this the person cast is voter, enclosed in an envelope and post to register post. The problem with this system is that not always the ballets are riched in time. The proxy person may exercise other ballet then the one synthezised the person. Proposed System In propose system remote and user’s can exercise .There voter within any favour using this system any level of voting like ,lokha sab voting,rajya sab voting etc. In the proposed system we can get the result without manually counting.The computerized counting is simple and we can access any information of any party. Advantage of the proposed system 1. Time saving 2. Working load reduced to a large extent 3. Less prone to errors 4. Information available at time 5. Man power reduced 6. Many tasks are automated 7. It also provide security for the data Modules description 1. Election commissioner: It check about the user details like id proof and no proxy voting cannot be done. This is election commissioner home page . 2.Generate voter id:It check details like name,password,state,address,block,area about......

Words: 2522 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Uks Constitution

...there is evidence to also suggest that the UK needs constitutional reform. One huge advantage of the UK constitution is its ability to be flexible and change according to modern opinions or issues. An uncodified or unfixed constitution like the UK’s allows it to me able to keep updated with new social and political situations. It easier to create an Act of Parliament according to a new situation, than to amend a codified constitution. For example, in reaction to this idea of ‘new politics’ and the public’s desire to be able to influence the government between elections, lead to the introduction of referendums in 1997. The UKs democracy has withstood the tale of time and is seen as a huge strength of the UK’s constitution. The UK’s constitution is an example of the UK’s custom and tradition linking generations and has been tested in history to prove that it works. The constitution has adapted and developed over time: it is a ‘living’ constitution due to the idea that it is able to grow. In despite of parliamentary sovereignty, there are a number of ways in which the democratic character of the UK is maintained and the power of the government scrutinized and reduced where necessary. For instance, the House of Lords and judges were reduced in number through Parliamentary Acts due to growing unrest about the influence of unelected official’s government. An uncodified constitution continues to establish representative democracy in the UK: policy making is done by elected......

Words: 754 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Discuss the Factors Likely to Influence Current and Future Patterns of Health in the Uk

...M2: Discuss the factors likely to influence current and future patterns of health in the UK D1: Evaluate the influence of government on factors that contribute to the current patterns of health and illness in the UK There are many factors that are likely to influence current and future patterns of health in the UK. I will be discussing binge drinking particularly in teenagers and obesity issues in the UK. This is because I believe that the biggest health issues affecting the UK at present are influenced by lifestyle choices. There are many current health issues within the UK that are affecting current health patterns and are likely to affect the future patterns of health. The government has introduced policies and legislations that should tackle these factors affecting health patterns. Binge drinking used to mean drinking a lot of alcohol over consecutive days, however now binge drinking refers to drinking a lot of alcohol over a short period of time whether this is to get drunk or to feel the effects of the alcohol on them. This has only more recently changed as teenagers have been seen to drink considerably more alcohol. Different Medias have shown that teenagers have been seen to binge drink more than the average adult drinks. “Media coverage has been given to news that “British teenagers are the third worst binge drinkers in Europe” Teenagers may have many reasons to drink such as issue as home, to fit in, peer pressure or even to feel a sense of thrill from the......

Words: 2834 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

M2 Discuss the Factors Likely to Influence Current and Future Patterns of Health in the Uk

...| | Grading Criteria | 1 | 2 | P3 | Describe current patterns of ill health and how they are monitored | | | | | | | P4 | Explain the main factors affecting current patterns of health in the UK | | | | | | | M2 | Discuss the factors likely to influence current and future patterns of health in the UK | | | | | | | D1 | Evaluate the influence of government on factors that contribute the current patterns of health and illness in the UK. | | | | | | | Learner declaration I certify that the evidence submitted for this assignment is my own. I have clearly referenced any sources used in the work. I understand that false declaration is a form of malpractice. Learner signature: Date: Scenario You have been asked to carry out a study on the health and wellbeing of two areas within the UK. Task one P3 Describe current patterns of ill health and how they are monitored (i) Calculate the life expectancy for a male and female born in the UK today. How has this changed since the 19th century. (ii) Describe the way in which the health of people in the UK is recorded and monitored. (iii) Using data from public health reports (National Statistics online, department of health etc) provide an overview of the current main patterns of health in the UK. Task four P4 Explain the main factors affecting current patterns of health in the UK http://www.bridgingthegap.scot.nhs.uk/understand...

Words: 487 - Pages: 2