Free Essay

Discourse Community Ethnography

In: English and Literature

Submitted By bobbykelly1
Words 1127
Pages 5
Robert Kelly
Holly Kopcha
ENGL 2089 106
3/6/2016
Marching Band The marching band is a community all their own. They all speak to each other in a language that is all their own. It was always easy to spot someone in school who was a “band kid” because of the way they carried themselves or the way they talked or the people they associated with. Kids in the marching band hang out with each other during and outside of school. They are a community all their own with unique characteristics. The marching band has specific goals that they set for themselves as well as for the group. Individually the members of the marching band have their own goals that they need to accomplish for the ultimate goal of making the group better. Each member will practice their music at home or in the practice rooms during class in order to get better at memorizing and accenting their music. They do this to help the group sound better when they are at competition. Band member also have a goal to memorize their drill sheets. This helps them to where they are supposed to be on the field at a certain time. Doing this helps the group look more unified in their formations.

The group’s goals are to perform well at competitions and ultimately win a trophy for their school. To obtain this goal the group will practice for 2-4 days a week. Depending on the day or what needs work they will either work on drill or their music. Drill is the position in which the person should be in a specific time during the show. The music needs to be memorized and synchronized with the drill. The better these two are pulled off, the better the score will be and better the chances are of getting a trophy for your school.
I was in the marching band and I saw these goals firsthand when I was in high school. I would practice with my friends and work hard at competitions in order to win. The marching band has a clear set of goals which essential for the label of a discourse community according to John Swales. The members of the group have their own goals such as memorization of music as well as the memorization of drill sets. These together make the group better and better help obtain the groups goals of winning a competition and getting a trophy for the school.
In a marching band there are ways that the band communicates with each other as well as with the instructors. During the season a lot of time is spent with many people in the band. In between practices and football games as well as recreational band outings or bonfires. These are mechanisms for communications mostly in the form of conversation. The band also used facebook to communicate major events and announcements to the band as a whole.
According to swales a discourse community must have mechanisms of intercommunication. The use of facebook and various social interactions that include conversations are these mechanisms of intercommunication in the marching band. This being said the marching band has this particular characteristic of a discourse community.
In the marching band, information trickles down amongst the members of the band from the instructors. Announcements are made in order to pass along information around the marching band and the members receive and interpret this information. In return the marching band members will provide their feedback to this information. Some express their excitement and others their dissatisfaction. The instructors use this feedback to make the band a better place for its members and apply it to future members as well.
Swales explains that discourse communities possess genres that are communicated for the rest of the world to know what kind elements are being used in this community. In the marching band students are usually not involved in sports and focus more on the latest music and socializing around the band room or band section of the bleachers. These possessed genres show that marching band is a discourse community.
The marching band definitely has its own language that they use off the field and while in rehearsal. Swales states that discourse communities have their own form of lexis and the marching band is no exception. In music rehearsal the band uses language that only a musician would know. While reading music the band uses phrases such as whole note, forte, and decrescendo. This is a lingo that the marching band uses that not many others would be familiar with. The band also uses a different lexis when they refer to terms on the field. When looking for spots to mark the band will use the yard lines as references. Not many people can obviously see that the yard lines are what the band uses as guide points. This is called drill and its what band uses to determine each individual placement on the field.

These special words that the marching band uses are unique to only the marching band and according to Swales is a major characteristic of a discourse community. The different language that is used on and off the field is something that is learned while in the marching band discourse community and is not something that can be observed from the outside of a group. From my experienced in the band I learned these terms and their importance and saw that others in the group were able to understand and effectively communicate with each other.
From my experience in marching band I was able to see the different ranks of the band and rise through them from freshman to senior. The marching band has a very strict hierarchy that consists of seniority as well as class rank. Members of the band with the most experience were often the ones that developed into leaders and became well respected members of the community. Swales mentions that in every discourse community there are ranks amongst its members. This is very true in marching band.
The members of band are always coming and going. They leave either by quitting or graduation and the join though either coming of age or just a random urge to join. In the band there is usually an equal balance of novice and senior members which Swales states is essential to the formation of a discourse community.
Marching does indeed possess all of the characteristics needed to be a discourse community according to Swales. The band possesses ranks, lexis unique to the band, goals, communication tools, and genres. I have seen firsthand all of these traits during my time in marching band there is no doubt that marching band is in fact a discourse community.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Discourse Community

...The definition of a discourse community is a group of people that have the same interest, shared the same goal with one and another, have the same language/ vocabulary, and have communication with one and another. According to John Wales the author of The Concept of Discourse Community. Discourse community can be anything, but it must meet his six characteristics that includes; common goal, intercommunication, members, lexis, information and feedback, and genre. If a group can meet the six characteristics it can be consider as a discourse community. After reading the article, I have realized that there are a lot discourse community among us without we even acknowledge it, for an example; like a book club,a sport club, a culinary club,and a yoga club. The one that I am going to use as an example for the discourse community is my Asian Community. The common goal that my discourse community has is to bring all the Asian youth to become one unity with one and another. My Asian community is a very small discourse community, but despite the size we have one big goal which is to achieve for all the Asian youth to stand together as a unity no matter what languages we speak. This group started because a friend of mine from high school had an idea to bring all Asian students in my high school to just spend quality time together, talk about each other cultures, and relate with one another. She felt there is a distance between all of us in school, and fortunately this group grew bigger...

Words: 542 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethnography

... my mother grew up in a patriarchal ideology where women always had limited decision making participation. Men had more authority to exercise power over women and had control over all household decisions. Particularly women were not allowed to take independent decision regarding education, spend money and go outside of the house. In spite of the significant socioeconomic development in Bangladesh statistics show that women still have low percentage in decision making participation. Women’s education is one of the most important factors which have significant effect on women’s decision making. The association between women education and decision making participation has very poorly observed in Bangladesh. Therefore, I decided to do my ethnography to assess how my mother’s education influences her household decision making participation. My mother was born in 1959 in a Muslim family in a small city in Bangladesh. In her period of time, women were confined within the four walls of the house. Her parents did not allow her to receive education and participate in any outside work. My grandparents thought it was waste of time and money to educate their daughter. Early marriage, religious misinterpretation and the narrowness of their outlook were mainly responsible for this. Due to strict seclusion or pardah, enjoin by Islam my grandparents were not ready to send their daughter to the male teachers. Moreover, the prevailing norm of the Muslim family and society are only to teach......

Words: 919 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Discourse Community (Musician)

...Connor Sikes Instructor: Liz Edsen English 1300- 002 25th, September 2013 Discourse Community (Musician) "Its a great thing about being a musician; you don't stop until the day you die, you can improve. So its a wonderful thing to do"(Marcus Miller). When I became a musician, a quote like this ran through my mind like a spinning record. It still amazes me how even after eight years I still have so much to learn down the road. Being a musician has really enlightened me with the motivation to put the effort in making and playing great music with others or by myself. Music is a form of expression in which many emotions can be shown from happiness, depression or rage. Music gives people the chance to express themselves without using words of their own and instead through emotional music or just simply a great song they love. Musicians without question successfully manifest Swale's characteristics of a discourse community. When it comes to musicians, setting goals is the first step to achieving success. If musicians don't know exactly where they want to go, then how can they know which paths will lead them there? Music has been alive since the beginning of time basically. Mankind in general used many forms of sound like rocks in the stone age, medieval times used wind instruments like flutes or a recorders, and the renaissance era used string instruments such as Violins or Piccolos . Music has many types of genres to this day from jazz, rock, country, classical, and many......

Words: 951 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Discourse on the Discourse

...Cesar Paulo S. Castor V 9/27/2013 Ph100 A Discourse on the Discourse In A Discourse on the Method, Descartes talk of his desire for certainty and truth and the method he uses to determine truth and falsity. The text shows Descartes method of making certain the knowledge he obtains and he does not limit this to philosophical knowledge he uses his method in seeking all forms of truth be it the sciences, theology or philosophy. Throughout the text Descartes talks of the importance of certainty and truth and begins by stating that the ability to distinguish what is true and false, or “good sense” as Descartes called it, is not a talent inherent to a few chosen intellectuals who received education but as something that everyone possesses and can develop. He backs this up by making an account of his years studying in both the literature of the ancients and the sciences and despite all his studying ended up realizing that he was still had doubts about what he had learned. He realized that knowledge and certainty could not be gained from books alone because some wrote not to find truth but to make ideas plausible and to Descartes anything that was tantamount to plausible was the same as false. (Descartes 2006, 10) What was important to Descartes for discerning true from false was not book smarts but more on life experience and exposure to different opinions. The method he uses to find certainty is something that uses discernment from one’s own reason to make it......

Words: 1501 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethnography

...Israel (Ethnography) In order to understand this folklore, it is important to understand the t=definition of ethnography and what it entails. It is a form of writing invented by sociologists and anthropologists in the twentieth century. Its literal meaning is that ethnography is writing about people. In this form of writing, the scholar lives in a certain group of people and then writes about his or her experience with the group and their way of live. This became a literal means of research over time when people studied folks and put down their experiences in ink, they discovered it more effective to study and understand. It acted as a method for comparison between different folklorists who studied the same group over a stretch of different years. The major difference between ethnography and anthropology is that while anthropologists studied each aspect of a community separately ethnography tries to relate all the aspects under a single system. In order to gain a good perspective of ethnography in a culture, Israel provides the best study object. It is a country with diverse religious, ethical, and social practices. Most regions have this diversity but Israel has staunch believe in Judaism, Islam and Christianity. Apart from religion, the other folklores have a relationship with each group. In this text, the author argues that the religious books people in Israel use are sources for folkloristic practices, an example is the bible which brings up marriage in Genesis......

Words: 557 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ethnography

...For my ethnography project I chose to study the life at the 459 Commons restaurant located on LSU’s campus. This dining hall is mostly occupied with freshmen students who live in the surrounding dorm rooms. The main focus of this ethnography is to compare the norms of the workers when the 459 is crowded with students and when it is less crowded. A norm is defined as a group held belief about how members should behave in a given context. How does the standard of behavior change when many students are eating at the restaurant compared to when few students are eating at the 459 Commons? Although the norms of the workers are the main focus of the ethnography, hierarchy also play a important role at the 459 Commons. The 459 Commons is a restaurant that is provided to meet the everyday food necessities of the students at LSU. It sells many different types of snacks, entrees, and drinks. They sell breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Next-door is the 459 Outakes convenience store where you can grab quick snacks and drinks. On various nights they will have themed dinners for example “fiesta night” where Mexican food is served. As you enter the restaurant, there is a counter in the front with a few registers in which they scan your tiger card for Tiger cash or Paw points. You then walk in and there is a buffet in which workers stand behind and serve food. In the next room there is a machine in which customers can get fountain drinks. There is also a soup and salad bar. The 459......

Words: 562 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Engineering Discourse Community

...Awnalisa Walker Discourse Community The ability to communicate effectively is important in many aspects of live. From social lives to professional lives, conveying information within groups of people or communities serves several purposes. The different groups one communicates with to achieve these goals are called discourse communities. In a discourse community, the communication between its members is vital because it causes them to have shared knowledge and similar interests. Due to the different communities having distinct interests, the way they converse can be altered to best suit each group. For example, a group of doctors would talk about medical subjects unlike sport fans would talk about a sport. I am a mechanical engineering student and therefore identify with the engineering discourse community. In this field, the community use different platforms of communication to reach its members. The internet is an effective way of communicating with engineers and the website Engineering.com is a useful resource to share information. Engineering.com is a site used by engineering professionals or companies to communicate ideas and information with other people in the engineering community. I came across this website while searching for engineering websites on the internet. I would expect other people to find this site by the same means I did. What drew me into the site was what was said in the ‘About Us’ section. The site prides itself on bringing, “…the most......

Words: 930 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Musicians as a Discourse Community

...Musicians as a Discourse Community A discourse community is a group of people who share a set of basic goals and have their own ways of communicating about those goals. A large discourse community that I personally fall under is being a musician. Every instrument has its own jargon and those who play these instruments know the lingo and different brands and what makes certain techniques better than others. Musicians use music to express themselves and challenge themselves to accomplish more. Something as simple as hearing a new song can motivate the musician to learn new chords and put in the effort and practice to learn something new, or even put their own spin on the song. Musicians are a great example of a discourse community with all of the different instruments to learn and specific aspects to each instrument. Musicians understand the value behind making goals, for it is the only way to really learn. Either the musician has one instrument or several on the mind but it all starts the same way; researching the instrument and setting a goal. For example, when I started playing guitar, I planned to practice for thirty minutes every day until I learned the basic chords. After a week or so, I had the chords memorized and my fingers didn’t feel awkward stretching between the frets as they had before. The growth and development of a new musician is special and individual to every person. When a musician really loves a style of music or a specific artist, it is almost......

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Discourses

... \nvt'$ mvmj of thf "i'emW^ le$t ^mH, THE DISCOURSES OF EPICTETUS. WITH THE ENCHEIRIDION AND FRAGMENTS. TRANSLATED, AND A WITH VIEW NOTES, OF HIS A LIFE OF EPICTETUS, PUILO80PUY. By GEOKGE long, M.A. NEW YORK: A. L. BURT, PUBLISHER, EPICTETUS. Very that he little was a is known* native of and of the life of in Epictetus. Phrygia, the in Maeander the a it is saia Hierapolis, a town tween be- the the to Mgeander branch of named of Paul it in the of Lyons. the Hierapolis of Colossi that time is mentioned epistle from people (Coloss. there of the was iv. a 13); which church date of fact his master has been concluded at Christian The Hierapolis birth of the apostie. The Epictetus life is that is unknown. he a was a only Rome, recorded and of broke the his was early slave in Epaphroditus, There is a profligate that the freedman master to on emperor his slave's dence evi- Nero, story leg by torturing of or him; but the that it is better trust to the Simplicins, who an commentator the weak how Encheiridion in he Manual, from but says Epictetus It is not in was body became that found and a lame early age. said modern slave; parents it has the......

Words: 160374 - Pages: 642

Premium Essay

Ethnography

...Tiffany Taylor April 1, 2015 Mini Ethnography When is one more time too much? Loud and constant honks from ……Parades of multi colored vehicles in all shapes and sizes fill every lane possible……Commonly referred to as Sin City, Las Vegas, NV is not only the playground for adults with the false hopes of making it big with the simple slide of plastic chips; it’s also one of the most diverse areas in the country. Driving up and down the strip, billboard lights and flashy hotels line both sides of the street for as far as the eye can see. With the larger than life building, scantily clad women, suited up men, children and characters of all sort filling every sidewalk imaginable. It seems everyone is on some sort of life mission. The term “hustle and bustle” does not do it justice by any stretch of the imagination. Las Vegas is merely just a large, vast empty desert. In 1931 someone had the idea to place a casino out there not realizing that it would spawn a huge uproar and create one of the touristy places in the U.S. It has become an American icon to this very day. It appears on many TV shows, movies and is referenced and visited by folks all around the world. Since 1931 until present day the hotel room count has gone from 63 to over 62,000 rooms to accommodate all these people. From one end of the strip to the other is approximately 4.2 miles long. It’s almost as if it is a lighted pathway to everything imaginable. The lights bring this certain glow......

Words: 1342 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Community Ethnography

...Objective: The aim of this ethnography task is to have an inside-out comprehension of the mentees lives and the context in which they seek after their aspirations. Besides, this task empowers us to welcome the flow of urban neediness and sharpens us to the everyday issues confronted by the sitara. As business under-studies this will offer us some assistance with identifying opportunities at a business level. The activity was divided into 4 phases while collecting data and also understanding the context of the Sitara’s environment around him and taking into mind the influence which these will have. We will start with Phase I which is the immediate circle of influence for the Sitara. Family & Demographics Father- Arvind Jha – 38 years Mother-Nilu Arvind Jha– 36 years Sisters- Neha – 16 years- studying in 10th standard Nidhi – 13 years- studying in 7th standard Ankit - mentee- 14 years- 8th standard Address: 2/8, Bharat Nagar, 4 Bunglow, Versova Link Road, Andheri (W), Mumbai The family is an exceptionally humble and extremely kind hearted. They discover satisfaction in little things and don't timid to make the following guest feel comfortable with their grin and inviting mentality. This prompts the conclusion that the Sitara is raised in a humble environment. The whole family fancies the achievement of the Sitara and wants him to succeed. The sitara’s father has a small lorry outside Bharat Nagar where he sells vada-pav and other eateries. The mother is a......

Words: 664 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ethnography

...For my ethnography project I conducted the study in Starbucks. My cousin is a supervisor at one of the locations and I figured it would be easy for me to conduct my research seeing as though they have free Wi-Fi, and everyone seems to take advantage of free Wi-Fi. I also thought it would be a good place to observe a diverse group of age ranges and see both males and females interact. Starbucks have a wide variety of customers that come in, especially a wide variety of businessmen and businesswomen. I believe that this was a perfect spot to conduct my observations. I was thinking about conducting my research at my current job but I figured I would choose somewhere where I did not know any of the people there, so I figured this would make my observations more interesting. Going into this project I thought I would see a diverse age group that ranged from children, students to young adults and retirees. I also thought I would observe females interacting with females, males interacting with males, and females interacting with males. During these observations, I hoped to observe how people interact differently based on what kind of situation they are in (business versus social), and I also hoped to observe behaviors between different genders. Starbucks was a great place to conduct this research because I always see professionals meeting up with their business laptops. I conducted these observations on a Saturday afternoon, and I stayed for about three hours. I figured a......

Words: 1139 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Rowing as a Discourse Community

...Owen Cardwell Dr. Rafaella Meriwether WRT 105 28 October 2015 Rowing As a Discourse Community After 4 years on the Bethesda-Chevy Chase high school crew team, it's hard to remember a time when I had never heard of crew, sweep, head races, sculling, stroke seat, seat races, eights, splits, regattas, or "way nuff.” Crew is a team sport that involves rowing a lightweight boat, or shell, as fast as you can. Bethesda-Chevy Chase Crew has about 100 members, including both men and women. There are 8 coaches, 2 each for the novice (or first-year) men and women, and 2 each for the varsity men and women. The team is connected by the personal bonds that form from the relationships. It is stated on the B-CC Crew website that “All athletes, coaches and parents support each other. We treat each other fairly and cultivate an environment of mutual respect.” But it is also connected by the specialized terminology that everyone has to learn and use every day.   Specialized language is used to describe the boats that are used, the seat positions of the rowers in the boats, the rowing techniques, the races, and the commands that given to the rowers on and off the water. I will provide some examples of each. The boats are called shells, and they are fitted with riggers and oar locks. There are two types of rowing. Sculling is the type of rowing where each rower uses two oars. Sweep is the type of rowing where each rower uses one oar, and there is usually also a coxswain who steers......

Words: 2462 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Humane Society- a Discourse Community

...The Humane Society as a Discourse Community According to the Linguist John Swales, a discourse community is “a group that has goals or purposes, and uses communication to achieve these goals.” One example of a discourse community is the Humane Society of Memphis and Shelby County. The Humane Society of Memphis and Shelby County is a non-profit organization that cares for over 6,000 animals each year. The Humane Society has numerous goals and ambitions, but one strong mission. The mission is to assure a better life for companion animals by providing shelter, finding loving homes and promoting respect for their place in our lives. The discourse community of the Humane Society of Memphis and Shelby County uses both written text and graphics to communicate between its rhetors and readers.             The Humane Society of Memphis and Shelby County has been living out its mission and goals since it was founded in 1933. One of its main goals, which is continuously being fulfilled by the members in its discourse community, is to place adoptable animals in “forever homes.” Their goals are to serve the people and animals of Memphis and surrounding areas by providing several services, such as low cost spay and neuter programs, humane sheltering for lost, abandoned and neglected pets, return of lost pets to families, humane education, pet therapy services, strengthening the human-animal bond, providing disaster preparedness, and adoption services. The community and its members are......

Words: 1732 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethnography

...(Parlett & Hamilton 1972). Stufflebeam's CIPP model handles the same data in a similar chronology, plus feedback, labelling them context, input, process and product (Stufflebeam 1971, Finch & Bjorkquist 1977). Context evaluation considers whether or not to offer the programme at all and includes its parameters: clients, goals and objectives. Input evaluation relates to the resources and strategies appropriate and necessary to achieve the goals and objectives. Process information is seen by Finch & Bjorkquist (1977) as concerned with determining what objective effects the programme has on the students participating in it, but places little value on the students' subjective experiences or the hidden cumculum. Blank's (1985) evaluation of a community nursing course sought 'to determine the public health nursing content in the preparation of nurses and the degree of consistency that exists among [the] programs'. She makes a basic assumption that professionalism should provide the framework for standardizing the curricula, which seems to have little rational connection with patients' or clients' needs in the Public Health Nursing Service, or indeed to professional accountability as defined by Allen (1977). Process Process is considered more extensively by Reichardt & Cook (1979). They consider two aspects of process analysis to correspond to two different purposes, to monitor the context, population and programme of the course, providing feedback, and to establish causal......

Words: 5966 - Pages: 24