Free Essay

Cruelty in Gattaca

In: Film and Music

Submitted By ignoreme
Words 709
Pages 3
Gattaca presents a chilling vision of a “not-too distant future”. A future in which, despite numerous safety checks and precautions being taken, human greed and selfishness endangers the happiness, progress, and very souls of humanity. I am referring, of course, to the criminal injustice of a man committing fraud in order to secure his right to pilot a group of five other people on a potentially dangerous mission while suffering from a heart condition which could kill him (and, by inevitable extension, them) at any moment. Though Gattaca tries very hard to paint him as a hero, Vincent Freeman is despicably self-centered, and stands to ruin a great many lives, if one considers his actions in the film through a serious lens, rather than a dramatic one.
It’s not surprising that many people can watch the movie while missing this detail - it makes every effort to show a world in which individual freedom is suppressed, and must triumph. It hardly goes a scene without inviting us to consider the plight of gifted ten-fingered piano players, unable to produce the currently fashionable music, or brilliant minds restricted to menial work because of their genius’ natural origins. It is a setting brilliantly suited to the story of a man unjustly disregarded attaining the dream he so richly deserves. This makes it somewhat unfortunate that it is actually the story of an unchained sociopath destroying everything in his way.
Vincent’s case isn’t like the ones discussed above. He isn’t being held back from his dream by some arbitrary stereotypes or jaded aesthetic standards. He has a real medical condition which means that his heart may fail at any moment, starting a few months before his space mission. We first hear about this at the moment of his birth, and as I said above, for all of the social ills of the world of Gattaca, nothing in the film indicates their medical science is often wrong, just wrongly applied. Moreover, despite a lifetime spent swimming, doing sit-ups while hanging upside down, and generally remaining in stellar shape, Vincent collapses gasping (and suffering from an irregular heart rhythm) after only twenty minutes of moderately-fast jogging. These provide clear evidence that he is not merely an “invalid” in the sense of society’s silly outlook - he is actually an invalid, life-threateningly ill.
And what happens if that illness results in his death during his mission? The exact nature of “Jerome”s work on the spacecraft isn’t entirely clear, since somehow, he is an astronaut mere days away from his mission who spends the majority of his time sitting at a desk and typing at a computer. We can assume it involves astrogation, since his ability to chart courses is praised by his supervisor - by the same token, it would appear that there is no reliable way for computers or mission control to plot a course for the ship while it’s away.Therefore, should his illness actually kill him (as there is every probability that it will) within the next year, it is quite possible that this will spell death for the rest of his crew - a crew of people who also spent their lives building towards this event, just as Vincent did, with the only difference being that they did not perpetrate fraud or recklessly endanger lives in order to do it.
But Gattaca isn’t concerned with those people. Much like Vincent himself, it sees the search for individual freedom as pertaining to just a single individual. Just as we are expected to have no curiosity about Anton’s efforts to be successful in spite of his “inferior” enhancements, or whether got to taste any success of her own, or if Eugene could have taken a better lesson from Vincent’s travails than to kill himself when they were done, we are expected not to consider the needs and achievements of anyone outside of this one man. They tidily remove themselves as they no longer serve his narrative arc, and Jerome’s fellow astronauts must hope that, with that narrative arc completely resolved, Jerome himself is not removed, leaving them to die, unmourned by a film whose chilling vision of the future is surpassed only by its dim take on human empathy.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Cruelty

...Cruelty The prophet David from the Bible who spoke of false accusations people make, an angry dragon from Scandinavia whose fury could not be withheld, and a man who knows the brutality of human nature. Though all different situations, they share a common theme, cruelty. Cruelty in gossip, cruelty in temper, and cruelty in nature. Cruelty can be found in all types of literature even as old as the Bible. “Deliver me not over unto the will of mine enemies: for false witnesses are risen up risen up against me, and such as breath out cruelty” (Psalms 27:12). This quote is asking God not to let us give into our enemies, and for us to not believe the brutality of people’s false accusations. The prophet David was the one who conveyed this quote. By speaking out about the cruelty of people he is indirectly saying that God is the only person you need to seek approval from. He is also saying that no one else’s words or savageness should matter. Though David’s message is centuries old, it proves that a verse, or phrase can contain the same significance even centuries later. Only decades later cruelty was still evident with World War II and the Nazis, and in modern day situations such as terrorism. Many other works of literature are also proof of this same idea. One example of a piece of literature that conveys cruelty well is the story of Beowulf. “And the signs of its anger flickered and glowed in the darkness, visible for miles tokens of its hate and its cruelty...

Words: 941 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Gattaca Essay

...Gattaca is a science fiction film where the society is portrayed to have their needs and desires of humans met, but not as well as they should be. The story takes place in a society where technology has been drastically progressed in areas of genetics and biology, in which your DNA determines where you belong in life. But with these progressions comes discrimination of those who are not genetically perfect, repressed individuality and loss of personal freedom. The moral of this movie is ‘there is no gene for the human spirit’. Though one can be genetically modified before birth to become perfect as the society expects, that does not apply for the human spirit where modifications are not an option. This film is a perfect example where perfection stands before happiness, where if you didn’t have the right blood, you would not become successful. Vincent is a ‘normal’ child who later on in his life takes the identity of Jerome, an athlete who has genes that allows him to travel in space, but despite this advantage, he is not satisfied with his life. Reasons being: he was the one least favored by his parents, he was not able to accomplish his dream mainly due to his heart condition, and the only future he could have would be to become a sanitary engineer. Perfection is what society expects, and if you are a ‘defect’, then you are discriminated against. Conformity is also an issue in this movie. It is proved by his parents as they decide to follow the society’s footsteps by......

Words: 804 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Animal Cruelty

...Animal cruelty Recently a series of cat-abused cases had infuriated all walks of lives in Hong Kong. Actually the cases of animal abuse are rising unceasingly in these years. The former chief of Health and Food Bureau Dr. York Chow Yat-ngok(2011) claimed that it had received 534 complaints related to animal abuse in 2011,which was the three times of the 187 cases in 2008. There are three major causes lead to animal abuse. Firstly, it may relate to the broken childhood of abusers. According to an article, a former animal abuser, who killed three dogs when he was young, said the roaring of dogs always scared him when he was still a child. Therefore, when he grows up, he showed hatred towards dogs. A foreign psychologist revealed that a large part of animal abusers had the experience of suffering from domestic violence in their childhood. The hatred make them become abusive to others especially defenseless animals in their later lives. Secondly, there are too many stray animals in Hong Kong. Some volunteers feed stray animals regularly. Street animals then always gather on the street and lead to hygiene problems and aroused discontent of citizens. Thirdly, some immature teens abuse animals just for fun. It seems to be a trend recently that record the process of abusing animals and then put the clip on YouTube, and gaining the sense of pride by accumulating the clicks. To make it clear, before searching the solution of relieving the animal abuse problem, we need...

Words: 1205 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Gattaca Reflection

...GATTACA Reflection Paper Gattaca’s main character, Anton, is a prime example of how altering a human genetic makeup creates even more problems with discriminated and inequality than the human race is capable of handling. Anton wasn’t given an opportunity in the society to prove himself because the potential employees of companies were not tested on their skills or knowledge but on their physical and mental qualifications. This same society also used derogatory terms for people like Anton. Simply because his parents decided that he would come into the world naturally instead of through gene therapy or alteration. Terms like “faith birth'; and “invalid'; were used against Anton to make him inferior to others that have had genetic alterations. Genetic engineering could be extremely beneficial, but when used in the fashion as it was used in the Gattaca it could change things forever. Currently sheep and other animals are being cloned, soon primates and humans could be cloned also. Further investigations should be done on the real benefits of clone and if it is really necessary. These experiments (when used correctly) could be used to gain insight on what our genes determine in our personalities. Although human cloning and genetic engineering would be a huge achievement to the entire human race such as it was when we landed on the moon in 69, a persons life shouldn’t be changed dramatically. No employer or insurance company should know if a person has been......

Words: 455 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Aminal Cruelty

...are bred specifically for animal testing and without animal testing, these animals would not even see the light of day. People believe that by eating meat, you are also killing animals therefore there is no reason for you to oppose animal testing. Even though some countries lay down strict laws on the treatment of animals during these researches, I still stand my point that animal testing should be made illegal globally. Indeed, many lives are saved due to animal testing but who are we to dictate whose live is more valuable than another. Saving a human live at the expense of an innocent live just does not seem fit. Therefore, I encourage more people to understand the technology behind animal testing so they will start to be aware of cruelty-free products and stop the use of it....

Words: 767 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Gattaca

...Midterm 1.) In Gattaca I would be a conflict theorist professor in a university there. I would be a conflict theorist because in the planet of Gattaca only the best of people are able to take into space or be apart of the program. As a professor I would only teach this perspective because Gattaca only has two types of societies, valid and invalid. Conflict theorists believe in that inequality exists because those in control of a disproportionate share of society’s resources defend their advantages on everyone else. The society isn’t made by shared values but by the hands of those in power. Those who are invalid are in poverty and suffer and those who are valid have the best of jobs and the best in society. It is appropriate to teach this at the university because those at a university are those of valids, and the structure needs to be taught that the valids run the society and the invalids are of the lower class who do not have shared values as them. The valids with the most resources given to them by birth power over the invalids in every social form. 2.) Dating rituals of Valids are based of DNA. Using anything they can to get DNA of the other person to see their positive and negative attributes. Mainly it is used to see whether they want to date them based of their DNA. Reproduction is done in two ways, “faith births” and “natural births”. Natural births is where Valids come from and Faith births is where invalids come from. The norm was Natural birth......

Words: 508 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gattaca

...Genetic engineering: Gattaca is a biological film that talks about the theme of the power of science where children are pre implanted with genes to enable them to posses the best traits when they are born. The misuse of science to enhance individual’s capabilities is what rules Niccol’s society of Gattaca. The misuse of science, particularly the field genetic engineering is depicted through the written code of the inter title, the audio code of voice over. The written code of the inter title “I not only think that we will tamper with Mother Nature. I think Mother wants us to” (William Gaylin) represents the opinion that perhaps God himself is not perfect, as He created a flawed world and that having the ability to change it means that it should be changed. This is strongly depicted in Gattaca whereby the Gattican society try to make it perfect and flawless by using science in particular, genetic engineering to add desired genetics to unborn babies and take away the undesired ones. Ultimately causing more destruction to Gattacan society then perfection. The misuse of science is further depicted through the audio convention of voice over, “I never understand what possessed my mother to put her faith in God’s hands rather than the local geneticists”. Parents in Gattaca choose the “very best” of themselves for their children, eliminating all their imperfections. Vincent was a godchild, meaning he was conceived without the use of genetic engineering or any other science resulting in a...

Words: 1590 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Gattaca

...In the movie Gattaca the main character Anton was discriminated against because of his gene makeup. Anton never even had a chance in the society in Gattaca because the potential employees of companies were not tested on their skills or knowledge but on their physical and mental possibilities. Just because his parents decided that he would come into the world naturally instead of through gene therapy or alteration. Terms like “faith birth'; and “invalid'; were used against Anton. I think gene therapy has it promises, but when used in the fashion as it was used in the Gattaca I think its progress should be carefully monitored. Right now sheep and other animals are being cloned. Soon primates and Humans could be cloned. I think we should further investigate human cloning for research on the parenting process and other physiological experiments that can only be used now on identical twins separated at birth. These experiments when used could be used to gain insight on what our genes determine in our personalities. I also think that the achievement of us humans cloning ourselves would be a great achievement for the entire human race such as it was when we landed on the moon in 1969.       In the movie Gattaca they barely showed the moral consequences of the actions. Anton’s father showed more pride in his brother than Anton, but what about Anton making friends, was he doomed to be a social outcast in friendships also? The second rate swimmer so depressed by being second in a race...

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Gattaca Essay

...Gattaca is a great science fiction film, and it was quite realistic. Gattaca deals with a future where parents tell the genetic traits of their child. Vincent Freeman has always fantasized about traveling into outer space, but is grounded by his status as a genetically inferior "in-valid." He decides to fight his fate by purchasing the genes of Jerome Morrow, a laboratory-engineered "valid." He assumes Jerome's DNA identity and joins the Gattaca space program, where he falls in love with Irene. An investigation into the death of a Gattaca officer complicates Vincent's plans. At Vincent's birth, a DNA test says that he has a 99% chance of developing a heart defect and dying before he is 30. This leads him to live a life with the fear of dying early. He is denied the chance to achieve his dream which is of being a space pilot. He doesn't even have support from his parents. His father once told him that the only time he was going to see a space shuttle would be if he were cleaning it. But Vincent refuses to accept his defeat, and finds a way to change his future. He has a deal with a crippled Valid, Jerome, and uses his genetic identity. Vincent finds all the substances used for DNA testing, and layers his biological fragments that make up Jerome on top of his own identity. He applies for the space programme using the wrong identity. The film is somewhat slow moving and deals with the human relationships between the ones with perfect genetics and the ones without......

Words: 737 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Animal Cruelty

...I am against animal cruelty or abuse because animals deserve the right to be treated with love, affection, and respect. No animal should suffer cruelty or abuse by the hands of humans. Many people think animals can be discarded like nothing. They deserve the right to live in an environment that gives them the affection, care and love that they deserve. They should not be treated with neglect, used for industrial animal farming or for psychological disorder. Neglecting an animal by not providing the basic care required for an animal to thrive; such as food, water, shelter and veterinary care is against the law. Neglect can occur in many different ways from abandonment, starvation and mistreatment. Abandonment of an animal occurs when the animal is thrown out like trash. Walking the in the streets suffering from the elements. Starvation is another form of neglect; not providing the necessary nutrition is crucial for them to survive. Without water or food animals die of starvation. How can you stand and watch an animal suffer? Humans without emotion, feelings or heart should not deserve the right to own an animal. Chaining up an animal is a form of mistreatment. Some animals are used for fights or as prey for training. Animals that are injured due to mistreatment do not get the medical care they need. Those who misbehave are not discipline right instead they are mistreated by getting kicked or punch. They take their anger out on a defenseless animal. Industrial animal......

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Gattaca Essay

...Gattaca is a movie directed by Andrew Niccol and the film is set in the "not too distant future." Andrew Niccol's perception of the future isn't what most people expect, but once thought about carefully it seems quite believable. This movie presents us with a new method in which society strives for perfection and it also makes us wonder if genetic engineering is morally correct. Your place in society in Gattaca is based on your genetic makeup and the way you were born. People born the way we know as natural are "in-valids". On the other hand people born with the aid of genetic engineering are "valids." An "in-valid" has his future set out to be a cleaner or other insignificant job in society which doesn't require an education. A new form of prejudice has been recently debated about, which is the idea of having greater or second-rate genes. Within the movie, the natural method of birth is genetic engineering, which is unlike what our society perceives to be natural. Genetic engineering leads to genetic selection from the parents who choose to eliminate any defects, diseases or genetic illnesses. Some parents may want to leave several genetic traits to chance rather then selecting the attributes of their son or daughter. To what extent is this process of conception morally right, if even right at all? Morally speaking, genetic engineering in any conception should only be used in extreme circumstances. If the natural method of conception isn't possible in the parents then......

Words: 706 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Animal Cruelty

...able to save millions of lives. In a way, it makes world better place. Currently, diverging viewpoints of animal rights are held by jurisdictions throughout the world. Mexico for instance, has very little to no law protecting animal rights (though, slowly started implementing animal right laws recently). On the other hand, in Switzerland, jurisdiction against animal cruelty are among the strictest in the world, such as requiring appropriate cage sizes for rabbits or sufficient amount of exercises for dogs. In United States, however, Animal Welfare act was introduced in 1962. Generally, animal protection laws around the world approves of killing animals (in a humane manner) for food, clothing, material and research and tries to minimize unnecessary suffering of animals. The laws also prohibits killing of endangered species to prevent extinction of rare species. Nonetheless, some individuals even choose to become a vegetarian to help reduce worldwide consumption of meat. After all, resisting meat requires high willpower and strong devotion, it shows how compassionate people are about animal rights. But animal cruelty does not only stop on slaughtering of animals, there are many instances in which animals are abused. In some zoos for example, animals are kept in cages that are too small or when farmers couldn’t afford to feed their horses, they abandon their horses, leaving them starving to death....

Words: 535 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gattaca

...In the movie Gattaca, it explores the unexpected possibilities and consequences of discrimination against those that are not genetically modified. The movie shows that babies who are born with the slightest thing wrong with them can be fixed and made perfect. In the movie most of the babies are made genetically engineered, while Vincent was conceived by love. When Vincent was born his parents were told he had an life expectancy of 30.2 years and that he was most likely going to die from heart failure. Vincent grew up weaker, slow development in the body, and he needed to wear glasses. In my opinion, in order for Vincent to believe in himself he has to overcome his genetic disadvantage, mentally at least. In the quote, “ My real resume’ was in my cells.” , which means that not matter what qualifications he thought he had mentally is DNA could the story better. I believe nature (DNA) is more important than nurture (home environment) in determining whether a person will be successful or not. Because from the very beginning you will know your child strongest and weakest point. That way you can instilled the other important things in him or her while they are young. As for being successful or not you will know as a parent the potential your daughter or son has that way you can keep them on the right track because you know their future holds a lot for him or her.You should still protect your child no matter what but you will know different precautions to take so everyone......

Words: 265 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Animal Cruelty

...lovers. While this press undoubtedly raised awareness of the perils of animal cruelty, there are still hundreds and hundreds of cases that go unnoticed every day. For how loving and caring animals are to human beings, it is about time that we stand up to those who mistreat them and give animals the support they need and deserve. There have obviously been several animal activist groups over the years such as PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) but there is still so much we can do to raise awareness of this issue and make a difference. There are varying degrees of animal cruelty, however, one no better than the other. It is important to recognize each one and the motives behind the owner’s abuse because there needs to be different ways to handle these crimes. There is blatant abuse, such as in the Michael Vick case, where owners put animals in an atmosphere that is detrimental to their health and well-being. As for Vick, he bred and trained dogs to become vicious fighters as a part of his operation called “Bad Newz Kennels” (Schorn 1). CBS Sports Anchor James Brown asked Vick in an interview what had motivated him to continue to run this operation despite him knowing the risks and consequences of doing so (1). Vick cited that despite knowing everything he was doing was wrong, it was the competition and adrenaline that kept him in the business (1). The second form of animal cruelty can be best described as overall neglect from the owners. Oftentimes......

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Gattaca Film Analysis

...Joshua Barott Professor Peterson Writing 121 30 July 2012 Four Little Nucleotides In an age of rapidly advancing technology, there are those who argue for slowing it down, so it can be critically and ethically examined. However, there are many who believe the opposite, and that there should be as few restrictions as possible. The movie GATTACA is an example of a dystopian future where the advancement and role of technology in our society has been allowed to run unchecked. Ironically, GATTACA, through its obsession with perfection, has created a world less perfect than the one that came before. The value of human life, individuality, relationships, and morals are corrupted. In GATTACA, we are presented with a society where genetic engineering and perfection are worshipped, and anything less is unacceptable and is discriminated against. As Vincent says in the movie, “We have discrimination down to a science.” Every aspect of a person’s life is determined by their genetic code: their job, their personal relationships, and even their basic civil rights. Yet even the genetically advanced suffer from “the burden of perfection.” The world of GATTACA is so totalitarian in nature that human rights are trampled upon and individuality is suppressed. Surely, this is not a perfect world. Vincent would certainly agree. He laments the ways in which society has changed in the ongoing pursuit to create perfection. Old values can no longer contain the same message and relevance. The......

Words: 1043 - Pages: 5