Premium Essay

Audit Rotation

In: Business and Management

Submitted By peterhead24
Words 1662
Pages 7
Mandatory Audit Rotation

Introduction
In 2002, Enron became the largest case of fraud in history. It caused it investors to lose sixty billion dollars, two million two hundred thousand in pension plans, and five thousand six hundred jobs (Enron Sentences Will Be Tied to Investor Losses). This all could have been avoided if public companies were forced to changed independent auditors every five years. Throughout this paper, I will be talking about mandatory audit rotation and why I think it is a great idea. First I will talk about the Sarbanes Oxley act and what it requires when it comes to partner rotation. It is important to know what the current rules and requirements are before we discuss how they should be changed. The next item I will discuss is auditor independence and how it is affected by audit rotation. After I talk about the current rules and independence, I will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of mandatory audit rotation.

Sarbanes-Oxley Act In 2002, President George W. Bush signed the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 to protect investors from the possibility of fraudulent activities by corporations. This act was aimed to improve financial statements of corporations and prevent fraud. In section 203 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, it gives the requirements of partner rotation. “The new rules provide that an accounting firm will not be independent if either the lead audit partner or the concurring partner performs audit services for more than five consecutive fiscal years of an audit client. Extending beyond the mandate of Section 203, the final rules also requires a five-year "time-out" period before a partner may return to a particular audit engagement. The new rules also require partner rotation for audit partners. Audit partners, other than the lead and concurring partners, must rotate off an audit engagement after seven years and are…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

It Audit

...Best Regards, Sara Colle, Aaron Hughes, Mohammed Kahn, Paul Koller Business Continuity Planning and Disaster Recovery 1. RISKS – Loss of customers, loss of profits, loss or reputation, loss of government approval to do business Hurricane Sandy recently paralyzed New York City, the financial capital of the world. This event highlighted the importance of Business Continuity Planning for organizations. Disasters come in various forms including: fire, pandemic, terrorism, biological attacks, tornadoes, hurricanes, typhoons, flooding, earthquakes, and acts of god. Bob’s Inc.’s management has confirmed that a full Business Continuity Planning and Disaster Recovery plan exists and is annually tested and updated. Global Technology Audit Guide (GTAG) suggests seven key components to Business Continuity Planning and Disaster Recovery. Our team inquired about the status of each component with management. Management’s responses are summarized in italics at the end of each component below and can be found in entirety in Appendix A. 2.1. Management Support — Management must show support to properly prepare, maintain, and practice a business continuity plan (BCP) by assigning adequate resources, people, and budgeted funds. Bob Inc.’s IT Management confirms that entire organizations management and department heads are in support of BCP/DR. 2.2. Risk Assessment and Risk Mitigation — Potential risks due to threats such as fire, flood, etc., must be identified,......

Words: 5459 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Audit

...capacity to fulfill the need for reliable and authoritative financial material not only because of the reputation or prestige of the certified statements, but also because of the significance generally attached by the business man to the functions of the auditor and his reports. These functions, and the scope of these reports, have in the past been definitely related to the character of and changes in business activity. Audits and reviews are basically procedures performed on the financial statements of a company, for the purpose of determining whether the financial statements include any material misstatements. Misstatements are essentially wrong numbers due to numerical errors, fraud, or errors in interpreting the accounting rules. Misstatements are material if they are large enough to make a difference to a user of the financial statements, such as a bank or investor. And the person who involved in auditing is known as auditor. It also provides the techniques necessary to examine the internal control system of a company and perform operational or compliance audits by internal or external auditors. The early conceptions of the functions of the auditor were such as to confine him to the duties of a mere checker and verifier of debits and credits. As business became more complex in its interrelationships there has been a compensating broadening demand for the acceptance of new and formerly unrecognized responsibilities by the auditor. History of......

Words: 6792 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Audit

...capacity to fulfill the need for reliable and authoritative financial material not only because of the reputation or prestige of the certified statements, but also because of the significance generally attached by the business man to the functions of the auditor and his reports. These functions, and the scope of these reports, have in the past been definitely related to the character of and changes in business activity. Audits and reviews are basically procedures performed on the financial statements of a company, for the purpose of determining whether the financial statements include any material misstatements. Misstatements are essentially wrong numbers due to numerical errors, fraud, or errors in interpreting the accounting rules. Misstatements are material if they are large enough to make a difference to a user of the financial statements, such as a bank or investor. And the person who involved in auditing is known as auditor. It also provides the techniques necessary to examine the internal control system of a company and perform operational or compliance audits by internal or external auditors. The early conceptions of the functions of the auditor were such as to confine him to the duties of a mere checker and verifier of debits and credits. As business became more complex in its interrelationships there has been a compensating broadening demand for the acceptance of new and formerly unrecognized responsibilities by the auditor. History of......

Words: 6792 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Mandatory Firm Rotation

...Mandatory Firm Rotation Background With the fast advent of globalization, countries, regions and governments have become more interdependent. Companies all over the world including small- and medium-sized entities work together and across geographies to attain sustainable growth. With the world becoming more borderless, it is then imperative that a strong financial planning must be made available for universal adoption. The international business environment relies on unbiased, clear, consistent, relevant and high quality standards. The task to develop and review internationally accepted standards was given to accounting councils and organizations such as IFRS Advisory Council and the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). With the shared thoughts for a better and universally applicable accounting, accounting-related boards and councils, managers and accountants all over the world constantly review existing standards and examine its implementation. One issue that has been a hot topic of recent debates is the concept of Mandatory Audit Firm Rotation that was released by the PCAOB (TYSIAC, 2012). The Issue The conception of mandatory firm rotation is not fresh and was even considered by the U.S. Congress in the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. The Congress however dismissed the concept in favor of the mandatory engagement partner rotation (Point of View, 2012). However, years after the conception of mandatory firm rotation was revived. Last August 16, a concept......

Words: 1246 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Three Crop Field Rotation

...The significance of three field rotation During the Middle Ages Europe saw many innovations in farming that lead to growth in its population and wealth. One of the most significant advancements was the three field rotation system used in farming. Prior to discovering this new method of farming, farmers would plant crops on one half of its agricultural field living the other half uncultivated. In doing so they were able to harvest crops while uncultivated land would remain preserved. When a crop is continuously grown in an area of land, it robs the soil of nutrition needed to avoid crop failure or possible famine. This method was effective but made the harvest underwhelming. The three field rotation helped increase annual crop yields that benefitted the population, economy and the health of domesticated animals. Farmers discovered they no longer had to cut off half their land for soil preservation but only a third. On one third of the land farmer could grow crops that benefited the uncultivated soil and the food supply of the peasant population. Farmers would grow peas or legumes on a third of the land, by doing so they were able to grow protein rich crops that helped the peasant with a source of a high protein diet. Peas and legumes also provided nitrogen that helped fertilize the uncultivated soil. In the other cultivated third of the land farmers would grow crops such as oats, rye or wheat that they could feed to its livestock. Normally farmers relied on using Oxen to......

Words: 530 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

On the Job Rotation

...the same places. In this way they do not lose time while they are training or learning. After a plan is developed for what should be taught, employees should be informed about the details. A time table should be establish with periodic evaluations to inform employees about their progress. On-the-job training techniques include orientations, job instruction training, apprenticeships, internships, assistantships, job rotation and coaching. Off-the-job techniques include lectures, special study, audio visual conferences or discussions, case studies, role playing, simulation, programmed instructions, and laboratory trainings. Most of these techniques are too costly. Methods of trainings can be basically divided to four types, namely, a. the telling method b. the showing method c. the role playing method d. the discussion technique * ON THE JOB TRAINING (OJT) In several firms, OJT is only method of training available. The most common OJT types of training include orientation, job- instruction, internship, apprenticeship, and coaching and job rotation. OJT offers several benefits to the organization. It relatively inexpensive; trainees produce something while learning; does not result in work disruption; does not require elaborate preparations like selection of place, arranging facilities and drawing trainees; and quick feedback is available to trainers. However, the above benefits can be realized, if OJT is organized systematically. Systematic OJT......

Words: 9448 - Pages: 38

Premium Essay

Audit

...Audit Committee Material Weaknesses in Smaller Reporting Companies December 2nd, 2010 OUTLINE: I. SUMMARY OF THE ARTICLE II. PROBLEM STATEMENT III. SUGGESTIONS FROM THE AUTHORS IV. RELEVANCE TO AUDITING ENVIRONMENT V. CONCLUSION I. Summary of the Article This report summarizes the article published by Gramling, Audrey A, Hermanson, Dana R, Hermanson, Heather M in the CPA journal of 2009. The main focus of the article is to show the importance of audit committee in auditing and analyze problems of small companies face in developing effective audit committee. The critical issue of the article is material weaknesses related to audit committee and possibility of management’s override of internal control within small companies. Before, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, audit committees in public companies were under more pressure to understand not just a company's financial statements, but to challenge management and auditors on key accounting, internal control and compliance issues. After the financial scandals that caused firms like Enron and WorldCom to collapse, audit committees have risen from relative darkness to center stage in modern corporate world. As it’s indicated in the article, the new role, the typical audit committee is charged with many duties. Because new role of audit committee increased complexity and accountability, it's easy for directors of small public companies to feel besieged when...

Words: 1917 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Audit

...Section A: Audit Practice Part b (i): Why is the audit of cash important part of the audit? From an auditing standpoint, cash is an important account because cash transactions affect all other business and financial processes. Businesses acquire cash by selling goods or services, disposing of fixed assets, or acquiring debt or equity. The same businesses put their cash to use through purchasing, paying employees, and buying inventory. Audits are an important part of business. Cash audits check that money has been handled properly, and performance audits ascertain whether employees are doing their jobs properly. Corporations are likely to undergo tax audits to ensure proper tax reporting and withholding. Audits may be performed in-house by management or human resources, by a third-party consulting firm hired specifically to perform the audits or by IRS agents who are auditing company tax records. The audit of cash is considered an important part of an audit mainly due to almost all business transactions will be ultimately settled through the cash accounts, the audit of cash accounts also assists in the verification of other asset and liability accounts as well as revenue and expenses. Some of the investor relies on the accuracy of the cash account to evaluate the financial health of the company. They use current asset which include the cash account to compute several financial measures. Other than that, cash is the highly liquid asset in a company and it is an area of high...

Words: 9221 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Audit

...auditors are not independence. The whole audit progress would be argued that the auditor had given the bias opinion to the client if there was no independence. Therefore, the accounting profession such as auditor and qualified accountant has faced the pressure for improving the quality of the audited reports. Jackson, Moldrich and Roebuck (2008) view the audit quality from perceived and actual quality. Actual quality shows the material errors risk level in financial statements and it can be reduced by the auditor. While perceived quality is the users confidence level in financial statements and effectiveness of the auditors in reducing the misstatement in financial statement done by management. However, there are variety of factors might affect the audit quality, but only 4 identified factors which is size of audit firm, auditor’s tenure, auditor’s experience and pricing pressure will be discussed in this paper. 2.1 Independent Variable 2.1.1 Auditor’s Tenure and Audit Quality The studies on auditor tenure cannot be separated with the auditor switching studies which formally known as auditor rotation. Auditor rotation can either is mandatory or voluntary. Voluntary rotation is the clients have option to switch auditors while mandatory rotation is pushes clients to change auditors after a fixed period (Mohamed & Habib, 2013) Previous researches had indicated that auditor’s tenure is related to the impact on audit quality. According to Geiger and......

Words: 3078 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Auditor En Audit-Firm Rotation

...Auditor en Audit-firm rotation In december 2003 kon Parmalat een obligatielening van 150 miljoen euro niet terugbetalen, terwijl het 4.5 miljard aan liquide middelen zou hebben. Dit geld bleek er echter niet te zijn, er was fraude gepleegd met betrekking tot de jaarrekening en er was leningdocumentatie vervalst. Later verdween Parmalat zelfs van de beurs. Naar aanleiding van het Parmalat-schandaal en een aantal soortgelijke boekhoudschandalen in de afgelopen eeuw, (zoals Enron, Worldcom, en Xerox) wordt er toenemende kritiek geuit naar de rol van de externe accountant als onafhankelijke derde partij. Als reactie op de boekhoudschandalen is er wereldwijd aanscherping van de controle- en verslaggevingregels. Verplichte rotatie is een van de mogelijke oplossingen. Hierbij wordt gewisseld van accountant (auditor rotation) of van het accountantsbureau (audit-firm rotation). Dit zou voorkomen dat de accountant wordt beïnvloed door het bedrijf wat opportunistische manipulatie tot gevolg zou hebben. In deze tekst wordt onderzocht of het wisselen van accountantskantoor daadwerkelijk een gunstige invloed heeft op de kwaliteit van de accountantsverklaring. De primaire rol van de accountant is het verhogen van de kwaliteit van de financiële informatie in overeenstemming met de normen van de PCAOB. Het doel is ervoor te zorgen dat er geen materiële afwijkingen in de jaarrekening van een entiteit zitten (Marshall, McManus, & Viele, 2013, p. 408). Financiële verslaggeving wordt......

Words: 1210 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Auditor Rotation

...I. Audit Quality The primary role of accounting is to reduce information asymmetry by providing investors with relevant and reliable information in order to create an efficient allocation of resources. However, there is often a tradeoff between relevance and reliability that needs to be considered when imposing regulations (Scott, 2012). When information asymmetry is present, investor faith decreases, compromising the efficiency of the market. In order to prevent market failures, it is critical to maintain investor confidence; this can be done by achieving high audit quality. Definition The PCAOB defines audit quality as providing “independent and reliable audits” regarding management’s financial statements, internal controls and potential threat for going concerns (PCAOB, 2013). Four key aspects of audit quality include independence, objectivity, skepticism, and competence. Maintaining and improving the four elements is critical to increasing audit quality and the usefulness of the information provided. Independence According to the PCAOB Auditing Standards, auditors should maintain independent mental attitudes. Independence is defined by the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct as independence of both, mind and appearance. Independence of mind requires the auditor to act with integrity, free of outside influence whereas independence of appearance requires the avoidance of situations leading to potential conflict of interests. Unless, the auditor is truly independent, the...

Words: 5991 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Mandatory Audit Firm Rotation

...the supports “Mandatory Auditor Rotation”: Auditor independence is widely considered one of the main causes for the occurrence of accounting fraud and in 2003 congress considered mandatory audit firm rotation as a possible solution. The ruling congress gave was in favor of mandatory audit engagement partner rotation. The reasoning behind the ruling was the surprising lack of evidence found supporting mandatory audit firm rotation as the best solution to improve auditor independence. If mandatory audit firm rotation were passed by congress, auditor independence is likely to improve, however the consequences may not be exactly as anticipated. Audit firms will be further obligated to perform ethical and appropriate work since the next auditor will deeply examine their work. The vast majority of accounting fraud cases in the past have occurred after several years of a company being audited by the same audit firm. The auditor client long-term relationship clearly impairs the auditor independence but is mandatory audit rotation the best solution for auditor independence? We do not agree with mandatory audit firm rotation as the appropriate solution to strengthening auditor independence. Studies have shown that countries requiring mandatory audit firm rotation show little to no evidence that it improves auditor independence. An auditor’s familiarity with the business and the industry in which it operates is essential to the quality of the audit. While accumulating this......

Words: 364 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

An Examination of Partner Perceptions of Partner Rotation

...Partner Rotation: Direct and Indirect Consequences to Audit Quality Key Points: * In order to improve audit quality by making auditors more independent, regulators mandate partner rotation and cooling-off periods. Specifically, partners would be required to rotate off to another client every five years. As stated in the article, rotation improves independence resulting in a positive impact on audit quality. * However, more often than not, partners would much rather enter a new industry than relocate to preserve their quality of life. Most partners opt to retrain rather than relocate, thus affecting audit quality negatively. Based on the findings described in the article, 93% of audit partners reported needing at least two years to become fully effective in a new engagement. Even partners who stay within the same industry line need some time to get used to differing information technology and other processing systems, client personnel, corporate governance characteristics, and the time it takes to gain client trust at the senior management and board levels. * There are some costs related to rotations, and a cost-benefit analysis should be performed. With that said, it might be hard to quantify the costs and benefits of this situation. How do you weigh the improvement in audit quality due to independence against its decline due to a lag in audit effectiveness (resulting from either a change in client or a change in industry altogether)? * Rotations......

Words: 348 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Audit Partner Rotation

...into the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, under Section 10A: (j) AUDIT PARTNER ROTATION – It shall be unlawful for a registered public accounting firm to provide audit services to an issuer if the lead (or coordinating) audit partner (having primary responsibility for the audit), or the audit partner responsible for reviewing the audit, has performed audit services for that issuer in each of the 5 previous fiscal years of that issuer.[1] For the purpose of clarity it is deemed that the Lead and Concurring partner perform the critical functions that affect the conduct and effectiveness of an audit engagement.[2] With respect to Section 203 of the Sarbanes and Oxley Act of 2002, the initial law was silent with respect to the time out period; therefore, the SEC ruled that the appropriate length would be a minimum of 5-years[3]. It is the belief of the SEC that the auditor’s independence shall be compromised after its fifth year of service and in fact their independency would no longer exist, as they would be auditing their own work beyond that timeline and that there was a real need for new eyes to further enhance the auditor’s independence. It should be noted, the SEC determined that certain partners are deemed specialty experts and that their primary function is to provide technical resources to the audit team members; therefore, they are to be excluded from rotation.[4] As they have no oversight of the audit activities and have limited interaction with the......

Words: 749 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mandatory Audit Firm Rotation

...Mandatory Audit Firm Rotation Mandatory audit firm rotation has been discussed by different accounting boards numerous times since the 1970s. Mandatory audit firm rotation would cause auditing firms to change clients after a certain amount of years with the client. The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has recently opened a discussion on audit firm rotation because the Board is concerned about the many problems that have come up on different auditing reports made by top auditing firms. PCAOB is concerned with auditor independence because they feel that it is being compromised as different firms continue to stay with particular clients for extended periods of time. This paper is going to discuss auditor independence and its effect on audit opinion, the history of audit firm rotation, and the advantages and disadvantages of audit firm rotation because it is a solution that is being considered. According to the PCAOB auditor independence is a description of the relationship between auditor and client and the mindset with which the auditor must approach his or her work. A measure for the mindset is the auditor’s ability to exercise professional skepticism, which is an attitude that includes a questioning mind and a critical assessment of audit evidence. For the last eight years the Board conducted annual inspections of the largest audit firms and found that more than 2,800 of the firm’s engagements were audit failures. An audit failure is a failure to obtain......

Words: 1585 - Pages: 7