Free Essay

Associates Degree of Nursing Versus Bachelors Degree of Nursing: the Road to an Informed Decision

In: Science

Submitted By jlyerger
Words 1059
Pages 5
Associates Degree of Nursing Versus Bachelors Degree of Nursing:
The Road to an Informed Decision
John Yerger
Grand Canyon University: NRS-430V
November 3, 2012

Associates Degree of Nursing versus Bachelors Degree of Nursing: The Road to an Informed Decision When one finds a fork in the road one must look at all options before making an informed decision. When assessing the options to become a registered nurse (RN) what presents itself is just that, a fork in the road. On one side of the road, lies the Associates Degree of Nursing (ADN) and on the other side the Bachelors Degree of Nursing (BSN). Let one examine all aspects that are required for obtaining either degree to make an informed decision. Basic Considerations When one is considering the nursing profession as a career, some important aspects that must be evaluated include one’s family situation (single versus married), future job requirements (how many hours and shifts are needed per week to fulfill the job requirements), and financial circumstances (cost of continuing education). Other topics that must be taken into account include any aspirations to eventually achieve any position in leadership or management and the education that is required to achieve that position. Education and Training When considering the educational requirement, one must first understand the ADN program is a two to three year course that centers primarily on the technical side of nursing (Miller, 2007, p. 9) such as illness and the treatment of illness as well as requiring fewer credit hours (70-72) (Hawkins, 2000, p. 26). However, these programs do have their drawbacks. Most students who graduate from an ADN program have had fewer classes in management, and as a result are either overlooked at promotion time, or lack the education needed for the job if they are awarded it (Hawkins, 2000, p. 26). Now, in regards to the other side of the road, one needs to reflect on the BSN program. The BSN side of the road appears to have many benefits including more curricular classes that promote leadership, theory, management, and the additional education to provide “nursing beyond direct care of the individual to include the care of families, groups, and communities” (Hawkins, 2000, p. 24). Students who enroll in a BSN degree program are moreover exposed to many different arenas within the healthcare field such as more "clinical lab experience” (The University of Kansas Undergraduate Advising Center). Similarly, according to (TCNJ 2012) graduates of BSN programs are also able to “Integrate research findings and nursing theory in [the] decision making in professional nursing practice.” However, as with the ADN program, there are drawbacks to this side of the road as well. The BSN program requires more credit hours (120-130) and because of this requirement could present itself as a financial burden. (Hawkins, 2000, p.26). Study of Competency and the Effect on Patient Outcomes One may look at the above information, and say to themselves, the BSN program obviously has the impression of being the superior program and nurses who possess a BSN degree are superior nurses; however, there is another perspective to observe when comparing these two programs. There has recently been a push by the American Nurses Association and other nationally known organizations to make the BSN degree the minimum education requisite to sit for the National Council Licensure Examination for Registered Nurses (NCLEX-RN®). This push has come due to studies showing that hospitals that have a majority of their staff at the BSN degree level have a lower mortality rate (Rosseter, 2012, p. 2). The American Association of Colleges of Nursing and other national nursing associations have said their position is in support of making a BSN degree the entry point to becoming an RN (Rosseter, 2012, p. 3). To the contrary, and conversely, there have been many studies that have shown little difference in competencies between ADN and BSN prepared students (Miller, 2007, p. iii). Patient Scenario For example, take a look into the following scenario. There is a patient that is unconscious and unresponsive in the intensive care unit (ICU). The ADN prepared nurse is going to focus on the possibilities and potential reasons as to why the patient is unconscious as well as attempt to provide a resolution in regards to any causes that may be resolved. As previously stated, the decision of treatment is based on the ADN trained nurse’s background of concentrating on illness, and the treatment of illness (Hawkins, 2000, p. 22). The BSN prepared nurse; however, if given the same set of circumstances will have a different approach. The BSN prepared nurse will not only concentrate on the illness, and any reasons the patient may be there, but in addition to this, will also attempt to console the family as well. As formerly stated by (Hawkins, 2000, p.24) this decision is based on the BSN trained nurse’s educational background of having classes that allowed the BSN prepared nurse to provide care not only to the patient, but also to the patient’s family. In summary, there are vast differences in the ADN and BSN degree programs. Each degree has many advantages and many disadvantages that one must mull over before embarking on the noble journey to becoming an RN. Furthermore, there are many other points to ponder related to personal circumstances that must be thoroughly thought through before making a decision on which side of the road one will follow.

References
BSN Level Objectives. (2002, October 5). In The College of New Jersey Department of Nursing. Retrieved November 1, 2012, from http://nursing.pages.tcnj.edu/programs/bachelor-of-science-in-nursing-bsn/level-objectives/
Hawkins, P. L. (2000). ENTRY LEVEL COMPETENCE OF NURSES BY TYPE OF PROGRAM (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved November 1, 2012, from http://www.csm.edu/wfdata/files/Academics/Library/InstitutionalRepository/9.pdf
Miller, C. D. (2007). A Comparison of Skill Performance of the ADN and BSN Prepared Nurse at Three and Four Year Post-Graduate Level. Retrieved November 1, 2012, from gradworks.umi.com/1446281.pdf
Rosseter, R. J. (2012, October 24). Creating a More Highly Qualified Nursing Workforce. In American Association. Retrieved November 1, 2012, from http://www.aacn.nche.edu/media-relations/NursingWorkforce.pdf
Undergraduate Advising Center. (2012). In The University of Kansas. Retrieved November 1, 2012, from http://advising.ku.edu/programs/majors/nursing/faq.shtml#difference…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Associate Degree Versus Baccalaureate Nursing

...PREPARED AT THE ASSOCIATE DEGREE LEVEL VERSUS BACCALAUREATE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN NURSES PREPARED AT THE ASSOCIATE DEGREE LEVEL VERSUS BACCALAUREATE Different levels at which a nurse is prepared have a strong impact on the nurse`s ability to practice in a health care setting. In the nursing profession, nurses are prepared at different levels. A baccalaureate nurse is a nurse who has completed a four years formal training in a university or senior college and has completed a 120 hours college and has acquired broader understanding in physical and social sciences, nursing research, public and community health, political, economic and social issues. While an associate degree nurse is a nurse who has completed a two years program in a community college and has completed a 60 hours college credit and only acquired understanding of fundamentals of nursing and sometimes lacks some basic knowledge to handle critical issues as they arise in patient care. Although both Educational levels took the same licensure exam after completing their program and have registered nurse license to practice as a registered nurse, there are still some enormous difference between the quality of their work in terms of positive patient outcome, lower mortality rates, quality patient care, clinical competency, administrative/leadership role, critical thinking and decision making. These roles are also incorporated in the GCU college of nursing philosophy where it states” the baccalaureate nursing......

Words: 1025 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Differences and in Competencies Between Nurses Prepared at Associate-Degree Versus the Baccalaureate-Degree Level in Nursing

...Differences and in Competencies between Nurses Prepared at Associate-Degree versus the Baccalaureate-Degree Level in Nursing The nursing profession has multiple entry levels which are diploma, Associate (ADN) degree and Baccalaureate (BSN) degree (Lane & Kohlenberg, 2010). Historically, The Bachelor of Science in nursing degree was established in 1909, whereas the Associate degree was established in 1958 (Hood & Leddy, 2006). BSN students are required to attend 4 years of college education, mostly given at colleges or universities, and on the other hand ADN students are required to attend 3 years of a community college nursing program (AANC, 2011). These variations in the years of education create differences in competences between BSN and ADN. Some variations include critical thinking, decision making, problem solving, and ethical reasoning. Both, ADN and BSN prepared nurses sit for the same licensure examination (Taylor, 2008). According to Lane & Kohlenberg (2010), “Baccalaureate education provides nurses with critical thinking for complex patients and opportunities for leadership, professional mobility, and advancement, this does not mean associate degree nurses are unimportant” (p. 220). Associate degree nurses demonstrate the critical role in nursing (Lane & Kohlenberg, 2010).They continued by adding that through building onto the fundamentals of Associate degree education, emphasis on research, social and physical sciences, and management of community health;...

Words: 829 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Difference Between Associate Degree and Baccalaureate Degree Nursing

...competence between Associate degree and Baccalaureate degree 1 Running head: EDUCATION PREPARATION Education preparation: Differences in competences between nurses prepared at the Associate degree level versus Baccalaureate degree level nursing Awudu Braimah Shaibu Grand Canyon University: NRS-430V Professional dynamics. Date: 10/07/2012 Differences in competencies between Associate and Baccalaureate degree level nursing 2 Associate degree level nursing is a two year nursing program that is being pursued in most of the community colleges in the United States of America. Students pursuing associate degree complete or earn 60 credits in order to graduate from this program. Baccalaureate degree or BSN level nursing is a four year nursing program that is offered in most of the colleges/universities across America. Students pursuing this program required to complete/earn 120 credits in order to be able to complete the program. This paper is going to look at the differences in competencies in these two programs. Research has shown that quality patient care depend on having a well educated nursing......

Words: 1137 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Associate Versus Bachelor Degree

...Associate degree versus baccalaureate degr Professional dynamics To become a RN, there are two main paths, by earning an associate degree, or a bachelor’s degree. One of the primary differences between an associate and bachelor’s is the length of time that each program takes to finish. To become an RN, more nurses choose to go for associate degree in nursing (ADN), because it is a faster program, 2 year program, and often more affordable. Bachelor versus Baccalaureate degree requires an increase length of study and more expensive. Both ADN versus BSN learn the some basic skills and, must sit for the NCLEX exam to be licensure. The national examination is the same for both ADN and BSN. BSN and ADN nurses must pass the NCLEX-RN exam, but not all nurses are equally prepared to practice at the same level. (“AACN”, 2012, p1). The nursing education system is challenged to balance the goal of providing adequate numbers of baccalaureate-prepared nurses while simultaneously advancing the educational level of nurses prepared at the associate degree or diploma level. (Cresaia, 2010) Baccalaureate degree nurses may go through more years of school, and pay more, but are more educated. “BSN programs cover all the materials covered in ADN program plus a more in depth treatment of the physical and social sciences, nursing research, public and community health, nursing management, and the humanities. The additional work provides new graduates with a better understanding of the......

Words: 966 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Associate Versus Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing

...Nursing is said to be the largest healthcare job in the United States with above 2.6 Million registered nurses (RN’s) working in the hospital and other different settings in the nation. Nursing programs offered by community colleges and four-year universities must meet the growing demand to replace the nearing retiring nurses. (www.aacn.nche.edu/aacn-publications/position/joint-statement) Increasing expansion of clinical knowledge and complexities of patient’s health status mandates current nurses to have a high level of education with diversified skills. The registered nurses requires not only can practice across multiple setting such as simply performing procedures, giving medication and starting an IV’s but also they must exceeds in out of the hospital settings as well. They must know how to think logically and critically in making the appropriate decision in regards to patient care and able to manipulate high tech equipment. Preparation includes greater knowledge to community based health care, giving importance to health promotion, maintenance and cost effective care ("American Association of Colleges of Nursing," 2000, p.1). Nowadays, student can have choices either to have Associate level degree of nursing or Baccalaureate level degree of nursing. Both ADN and BSN must pass the NCLEX-RN licensing examination. The truth is even though nurses pass the NCLEX exam at the same rate does not mean that all entry level nurses are equally prepared for practice. The test only......

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Associate Versus Baccurelate Degree in Nursing

...Associate versus baccalaureate degree in nursing Dawne McCammon Grand Canyon University Professional Dynamics NRS - 430V Melissa Adams January 26, 2014 Associate versus baccalaureate degree in nursing According to the JAMA Network, registered nurses in the United States are able to receive their basic education in a ADN and BSN program in colleges and universities... Although there are a variety of educational programs preparing RNs, some studies have suggested that baccalaureate-prepared nurses are more likely to demonstrate professional behaviors important to patient safety such as problem solving, performance of complex functions, and effective communication. ("Educational Levels," n.d) A large number of situations have been reported in the research studies reviewed. No major differences are noted between the cognitive abilities of students in baccalaureate and associate degree programs. (Davis-Martin, 1990, p. 2) Associate degree nurses are able to perform well in technical roles for which they have been prepared, as well as in some leadership roles for which they were not originally prepared. I am a prime example of that associate degree nurse who has been performing in leadership roles over the years this is due to on the job training and attending management courses. Baccalaureate nursing practice incorporates the roles of assessing, critical thinking, communicating, providing care, teaching, and leading. (, 2) As a result of......

Words: 960 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Associate Degree Versus Bachelor Degree Prepared Nurses

...Differences in Competences of AND versus BSN Nurse Vanguard University Professional Dynamics Mary Jackson MSN RN Many professionals have drawn their attention toward two diverse educational routes to licensure of Registered Nurse and nursing career. One of the most widespread pathways to become a registered nurse is Associate Degree in Nursing (ADN) offered in many community colleges as a two-year degree, and Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN) degree, which requires a four-year education at colleges and universities. Even though, these educational pathways are considerably diverse in studying period and content, they both lead to eligibility to pass the identical National Council Licensure Examination (NCLEX)-RN in order to acquire RN license. The ADN degree focuses primarily on practical scope and utilizes entry level knowledge and clinical skills in the healthcare setting. In the contrary, the BSN degree offers advance in research, leadership, community health and is planned to aim for a better understanding of the economic, cultural, religious, and social concerns influencing healthcare delivery and patients. Both nursing programs offer classroom guidelines and clinical experience in the real health care settings. Students take numerous courses. Over the last decade, ADN nursing programs help to educate approximately 60% of new nurses, and 36% of these new graduates finished BSN programs (Hood, 2010). Despite of many similarities......

Words: 1072 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Associate vs Baccalaureate Degree Nursing

...Between Nurses Prepared at the Associate-Degree Level Versus the Baccalaureate-Degree Level Patricia A. Wrecke Grand Canyon University: NRS-430V December 10, 2014 If you were a patient, do you think you would be able to tell the difference if you had a baccalaureate degree nurse vs. an associate degree nurse? Both the ADN and the BSN have the specifications needed that you get from accredited colleges to take the NCLEX. Once they pass they have licensure to practice as an RN and are capable of going into and being successful in any type of patient care setting. Let us compare the associate and bachelor degree and see if there are any differences or similarities. Some studies show that the BSN prepared nurse can have better patient outcomes. We will look at an example of a clinical situation to show if there is a difference in the care of the patient between an association degree RN and a baccalaureate degree RN. Mildred Montag was a nurse following World War ll. She saw a need to make more nurses in a shorter amount of time so she shortened the four year BSN and made a two year degree program to make technical nurses. (Grand Canyon University, 2014, Mildred Montag slide). These programs did well because they didn’t cost as much and they took less time. In the ITT Tech (2014) Nursing Associate’s Degree Program, things that are addressed in their education are “nursing values, nursing process, health......

Words: 1227 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Associate Degree Nursing Versus Baccalaureate Nursing

...Associate Degree Nursing Versus Baccalaureate Nursing Associate Degree in Nursing Competencies Associate Degree in Nursing (ADN) is usually at a two year community college and it sometimes can be found at a college that only specializes in only nursing degrees. The nursing only colleges are usually a fast paced curriculum and can be achieved in one year to eighteen months to get a degree. “An Associate Degree in Nursing is an economical way of becoming a registered nurse in a short period of time” (Raines & Taglaireni, 2008). “Achieving an Associate Degree in Nursing might alleviate the nursing shortage in a shorter amount of time” (Seago & Spetz, 2002). A diploma nursing program is a three year program based out of a hospital setting and focuses mostly on nursing education and skills provided at a hospital (Hood, 2010). “The typical focus of Associate Degree nurses is on substantial clinical experience and technical nursing skills needed to provide nursing care for explicit patient situations at the bedside” (Starr & Edwards, 2010). All of these programs take the Nursing Licensure Examination for Registered Nurses (NCLEX-RN). “Associate Degree Nursing skills focus around being a caregiver, counselor, and educator” (Hood, 2010). When working in a hospital setting there is a lot of education to patients provided along with giving the nursing care. “Associate Degree nurses provide care to individual clients with common, well-defined nursing diagnoses while considering......

Words: 1135 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Associate Degree Versus Bacholar Degree for Nursing Students

...DETAILED TEST PLAN 2010 NCLEX-RN Detailed Test Plan ® Effective | April 2010 Item Writer/Item Reviewer/Nurse Educator Version Mission Statement The National Council of State Boards of Nursing, composed of member boards, provides leadership to advance regulatory excellence for public protection. Purpose and Functions The purpose of the National Council of State Boards of Nursing (NCSBN ) is to provide an organization through which boards of nursing act and counsel together on matters of common interest and concern affecting the public health, safety and welfare, including the development of licensing examinations in nursing. ® The major functions of NCSBN include developing the NCLEX-RN and NCLEX-PN examinations, performing policy analysis and promoting uniformity in relationship to the regulation of nursing practice, disseminating data related to NCSBN’s purpose and serving as a forum for information exchange for NCSBN members. ® ® Copyright© 2010 National Council of State Boards of Nursing, Inc. (NCSBN) All rights reserved. NCSBN , NCLEX , NCLEX-RN and NCLEX-PN are registered trademarks of NCSBN and this document may not be used, reproduced or disseminated to any third party without written permission from NCSBN. ® ® ® ® Permission is granted to boards of nursing to use or reproduce all or parts of this document for licensure related purposes only. Nonprofit education programs have permission to use or reproduce all or parts of this document for......

Words: 17778 - Pages: 72

Premium Essay

The Difference Between Associate Degree and Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing

...The Difference Between Associate Degree and Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing Increasing clinical understanding and the rising complexities in the health care technologies today requires that professional nurses be educated and competent to the baccalaureate level. Nurses with their RN can be educated to the level of associates degree or to baccalaureate degree. According to the Grand Canyon University Baccalaureate Curriculum Model, the associates degree level nurse differs from the baccalaureate level nurse in three main competencies; client, nurse, and nursing education. One of the different competencies between associate degree (ADN) and Baccalaureate degree (BSN) is type of client or patients they are prepared to treat and the care setting which they are allowed to work in. “ADN nurses are educated to provide nursing care to persons with similar health alterations in structured setting, whereas BSN-prepared nurses are educated to engage in independent thinking and to provide nursing care to persons with complex and differing health alterations within a variety of settings, including the community” (Hood, 2010, pg. 18). Health care is not only centered as inpatient hospitals but throughout the community as preventive care as well, leaving ADN nurses in a disadvantage. Nurses now a day have to be able to practice across multiple settings. Contrasting the graduates of an ADN program with the graduate of a BSN program; the BSN nurse is prepared to practice in all......

Words: 1035 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Bachelors Degree Versus Associates Degree in Nursing

...Bachelors Degree versus Associates Degree in Nursing Steve Doane Grand Canyon University There are three ways to become a registered nurse. A 3 year program working with a hospital earns you a diploma registered nurse. Attending a 2 year college, such as a community college, earns you an associate degree in nursing. Attending a 4 year college, which is a university, earns you a bachelors degree in nursing. Nurses with their associate’s degree are limited in finding a job; they are getting what is considered entry level jobs. For example, jobs at a long term care facility, due to the difficulty for them of getting a job at a hospital. Most hospitals want to hire nurses with their bachelors degree, as opposed to a nurse with their associates degree. Nurses with their associate’s degree do not have the same level of education, leadership skills and critical thinking skills. Nurses with their associate degree are getting the basics in nursing school. Nurses with their baccalaureate are getting a more in depth education. The increased capability means that nurses with their baccalaureate are getting more of the jobs in the hospitals and in management positions. The new healthcare reform is requiring that 80% of nurses have their baccalaureate degree by the year 2020(Wood, Robert 2013). In order to comply with these new regulations, nurses with baccalaureate degree are in demand with the hospitals. Hospitals, federal agencies, the military, nurse executives, magnet......

Words: 839 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Associate Degree vs Bsn Nursing

...Differences and in Competencies between Nurses Prepared at Associate-Degree versus the Baccalaureate-Degree Level in Nursing Yolanda Youngblood Grand Canyon University Some will argue that there is Avast difference between nurses that possess a BSN vs those that possess an AND. Nurses with a BSN when compared to nurses with a AND display apparent variances and likenesses when the amount of education in various programs, the years required to obtain a degree, how educational/degree rankings affect delivery of patient’s care and effect, and the various requirements needed for licensing where all analyzed. It is understood that nurses with a BSN and nurses with a AND are held to the same standards, have the same responsibilities and liabilities, and usually work in the same healthcare settings. Nevertheless; a nurse’ professional experience, work setting, and level of education could possibly create a difference in the manner in which said nurse might administer patient care, handle stressful scenarios, and work towards their career trajectory. The direction in which modern technology and the healthcare industry are heading in a nurse’ level of education should be brought to the forefront. There isn’t substantial evidence to prove that nurses with BSNs are better equipped than nurses with ADNs, but there are those in the healthcare sector that are leaning towards requiring nurses to have their BSNs. A BSN is vastly encouraged in......

Words: 1180 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Differences in Associate and Bachelor Nursing Degree

...Running head: Differences in Competencies Associate degree versus Baccalaureate degree The purpose of this essay is to compare compentencies between the associate and bachelor nursing programs .Competency is an individuals actual performance in particular situation, described by how well the individual integrates knowledge, attitudes, skills and behaviour in delivering care according to expectations(Gurvis& Grey,1995; Nolan, 1998). The Difference between associate degree and bachelors is not much at the beginning of nursing career because at that time they have both graduated and are new in their profession and are still trying to establish themselves as a nurse and are trying to be competent in basic nursing skills. Despite the differences in both programs RNs have to appear for the same entry level exam (Nclex) . This exam tests for minimum technical competency for safe entry into basic nursing practice. A difference in competencies between ADN and BSN prepared nurses plays an important role in safety of patients and quality of care rendered. Nurse prepared with the baccalaureate and higher degrees provide better patient outcomes.(Aiken el, al, 2003) According to JCAHO (2006). Competency for nurses can be defined as “a determination of an individual skills, knowledge, and capability to meet defined expectations” (JCAHO, 2006, p.394). The differences between them is professional as well as educational preparation. ADN programs usually take two......

Words: 789 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Differences in Competencies Between Nurses Prepared at the Associate-Degree Level Versus the Baccalaureate Degree Level in Nursing

...Competencies between Nurses Prepared at the Associate-Degree level versus the Baccalaureate Degree level in Nursing Grand Canyon University NRS-430V Professional dynamics 125 January 11, 2012 The Differences in Competencies between Nurses prepared at the Associate-Degree level versus the Baccalaureate Degree level in Nursing In modern society human being, encompass extensively sophisticated requisites provoking advanced techniques of acquisition directly correlating to health care industry. The health care is intensifying in complexity and observing beneficial amendments. The longevity and expectations have heightened thus nurses are obligate to become educated in higher echelon, the professional baccalaureate level, to comprehensively achieve composite necessities. The professional nurse who graduates with a baccalaureate is primed for broader role in numerous facet of health care in addition to global knowledge of functionality of medical system and diverse methods of application. Enabling the application in daily patient care ,the delegation of tasks ,independent decision making ,secure patient discharge , and numerous other aspects provoking an improvement in quality of care . Research has shown that lower mortality rates, fewer medication errors, and positive outcomes are all linked to nurses prepared at the baccalaureate and graduate degree levels. (AACN, 2011). Education for nurses......

Words: 1739 - Pages: 7