Free Essay

A Short Comparison of the Western Exploitation of Japan, China, India

In: Historical Events

Submitted By Appleseeds
Words 734
Pages 3
The Western Exploitation of Japan, China, and India

History is filled with stories of one culture influencing and exploiting other cultures. Perhaps the greatest example of this is the Western exploitation of Asia. Throughout the nineteenth century various Western powers used their might to exploit the country of Japan. Japan however was not alone in this unfair treatment; China and India were also subject to Western influence. However, the way these influences took place differed in a variety of manners. While Japan and China underwent similar events, with a forced end to isolation and unequal treaties, India was completely taken over by foreign powers. Japan was ever wary of foreign influences to its culture; since the beginning of the seventeenth century the Tokugawa Shogunate had enforced a strict isolationist policy. By the mid-ninteenth century Japan had become too valuable of an economic foothold for the West to leave be. In 1853, President Millard Fillmore sent Commodore Matthew Perry to end Japanese isolationism. When the Japanese government saw the smog-belching, technologically superior, battleships pull into the Tokyo harbor they knew they had no choice but to give into any demands the Americans made. This led to the first of many unequal treaties, the Treaty of Friendship, which opened up several ports to American trade and established an American consulate. The first consul, Townsend Harris, forced even further concessions with the Harris Treaty in 1854. This treaty forced the opening of even more ports and established extraterritoriality for foreign citizens. It also established tariffs that heavily favored foreigners. Similarly China had also been under a self-imposed economic isolation. The Qing Dynasty had established the Canton system, in the mid-eighteenth century, which had limited foreign trade and influence to a very small portion of the Canton region. However, foreign trade still flourished throughout China mainly in the form of opium. Unlike the Japanese, the Chinese were willing to risk armed conflict to protect their isolation. The Chinese government began to try and control the spread of the drug, and in 1839, confiscated supplies from British ships. This sparked the First Opium War, which the British won decisively. This allowed the British to force major concessions from the Chinese in the Treaty of Nanking (1842), which opened more ports to foreign trade and granted extraterritoriality and a most favored nation status. More nations would force these same concessions from the Chinese through further treaties. This process was used as a framework for what would later happen in Japan. While India too was subject to foreign exploitation, this exploitation took place in a far different manner. Rather than just gain economic control through treaties, like in Japan and China, India was made into a colony which the British Empire had complete control over. The East India Company had arrived in India in the early seventeenth century and was granted permission to trade throughout the country. By the eighteenth-century the company had de facto control of most of the region. They began to annex parts of the country in 1772 and resorted to force when natives resisted. Rule of the country was transferred to the crown in 1858 where it was ruled as such for another century. While Japan, China, and India all suffered from foreign exploitation, they suffered in different manners. Japan and China were forced out of isolation and into unequal treaties. India was merely turned into a dependent colony. In the end all were subject to Western demands however.

Word Count: 548

Bibliography: 1. Metcalf , Barbara, and Thomas Metcalf. A Concise History of Modern India. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press, 2006. 2. Murphey, Roads. A Short History of Asia. 6th ed. New York: Longman/ Pearson, 2009. 3. Pyle, Kenneth. The Making of Modern Japan. 2nd ed. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath and Company, 1996.

[ 1 ]. Murphey, Roads. A Short History of Asia. 6th ed. New York: Longman/ Pearson, 2009. 282
[ 2 ]. Class Lecture 10-26
[ 3 ]. Pyle, Kenneth. The Making of Modern Japan. 2nd ed. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath and Company, 1996. 62
[ 4 ]. Class Lecture 10-26
[ 5 ]. Class Lecture 10-24
[ 6 ]. Murphey, Roads. A Short History of Asia. 6th ed. New York: Longman/ Pearson, 2009. 328
[ 7 ]. Class Lecture 10-26
[ 8 ]. Metcalf , Barbara, and Thomas Metcalf. A Concise History of Modern India. 56
[ 9 ]. Metcalf , Barbara, and Thomas Metcalf. A Concise History of Modern India. 96…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

History of Korea China and Japan

...Throughout the 19th century into the 20th century, the west started to have an increasingly great influence on the other parts of the world. Asia, in particular, was faced with the decision of whether to adopt and conform to the western ways or to reject and stick with their traditional ways of life. In the end, Asia adapted to ways of the western “devils”, but most of their efforts seemed unsuccessful while others were quite successful. The main countries that experienced the western influence were China, Korea and Japan. Although all three countries experienced their share of internal and external strife, China and Korea’s modernization efforts were, in comparison to Japan, unsuccessful. The reason for this was because Japan was able to fully utilize their resources and take advantage of the opportunities that they were presented with in Asia, whereas China and Korea were occupied with internal and external conflicts. Although China and Korea weren’t total failures, the Land of the Rising sun overshadowed them. China’s first experience with western imperialism is seen in the 1830’s when they had conflict with the spread of opium and the dwindling of silver within the country. China wished to stop both these events so when they confiscated supplies of opium from British traders, the British government used its newly developed military power to make their dissatisfaction known to the Chinese. This, along with other factors, led to the First Opium War (1839-1842). The......

Words: 1720 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Japan vs China

...Trade between China and Japan is worth about $345bn (£212bn). That alone, stands as a significant portion of trade, investment, and revenue. Short-term revenue, for example would be a one-time exchange of trade whereas long-term revenue would be long-term trade obligations between two business or parties. The full terms of the obligation are usually carried out over more than one year. Some industries are heavily dependent upon long-term revenue for sustained profits and to pay for basic operating costs. Long-term revenue, however, is not simple to define because it can mean different things in different industries. [] Let's take a look at how Japan's economy and trade as well as long-term revenue has been hit as a result of the conflict over the Diaoyu Islands. Japan has the world’s third largest economy, and is the second largest holder of US treasury bonds. It has a large impact on global commodities and energy: it is the largest importer of liquid natural gas (LNG) and third largest importer of crude oil. Despite its financial troubles, it still carries considerable weight in financial global institutions like the IMF, the World Bank, and the World Trade Organization. However, Japan's economy contracted in the latest quarter, signaling that like Europe it may already be in recession, further weighing down world growth. Japan's outlook remains bleak, with most economists forecasting a further decline......

Words: 987 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Japan and China

...| China and Japan | | SOC/335 | April 6, 2013 | | Introduction Nations around the world are ever changing and such cultures have the ability to produce scholars, businessmen, and businesswomen, and educators. It is through such perception that individuals learn of cultures and embrace the distinctions of people to understand the uniqueness of tradition, religion, and working ethnics to build interpersonal relationships among others. In this paper, the relationship between Japan and China will determine how political and economic developments effects Northeast Asia. The relationship between both countries will also present historical meaning toward Japan and China’s relationship, how the relationship changed in the 20th century, and the relationship now. Last, the paper will present Japan and China’s relationship effects on the United States and neighboring countries. Japan and China’s Relationship Affects When considering the relationship of Japan and China one has to perceive the representation of two well-educated countries who illustrates behaviors, strengths, and attitudes of long political and economic tension. However, for Northeast Asia, China, and Japan possess strong will and economic activities that produce economic and political stabilities and enhances its cultures wealth and identity. For Asia, Japan, and China are its giant, and such great incentives places China and Japan in the race of leadership in economic and political......

Words: 1011 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

India and China

...India and China a comparison by Nobel Laureate Mr.Amirtya Sen Modern India is, in many ways, a success. Its claim to be the world's largest democracy is not hollow. Its media is vibrant and free; Indians buy more newspapers every day than any other nation. Since independence in 1947, life expectancy at birth has more than doubled, to 66 years from 32, and per-capita income (adjusted for inflation) has grown fivefold. In recent decades, reforms pushed up the country's once sluggish growth rate to around 8 percent per year, before it fell back a couple of percentage points over the last two years. For years, India's economic growth rate ranked second among the world's large economies, after China, which it has consistently trailed by at least 1 percentage point. The hope that India might overtake Chinaone day in economic growth now seems a distant one. But that comparison is not what should worry Indians most. The far greater gap between India and China is in the provision of essential public services - a failing that depresses living standards and is a persistent drag on growth. Inequality is high in both countries, but China has done far more than India to raise life expectancy, expand general education and secure health care for its people. India has elite schools of varying degrees of excellence for the privileged, but among all Indians 7 or older, nearly one in every five males and one in every three females are illiterate. And most schools are of low quality;......

Words: 927 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Workers' Exploitation in China

...Exploitation of Workers In China: Analyze with suicides of Foxconn Abstract As globalization affected the whole world, the contradiction between leaders and labors has become a world-wide problem. In China, a series of employees’ suicides attracted the public and media’s concentration to consider this problem. A Taiwanese electronics corporation, is acting as the protagonist in this issue and now earning an internationally notorious reputation of running sweatshops. This paper analyze the cause of ongoing trend of exploitation of workers in China with the example of Foxconn, and examine the reasons behind those suicides from the perspective of management, workers and related laws. Based on the fundamental information of China, to illustrate my own analysis about this case from ethical and legal point, and to criticize Foxconn’s management strategy, labor relations and the gaps of Chinese laws. Keywords: workers’ exploitation, China, Foxconn, suicides, management, laws Introduction In the three components of business market, producers, retailers and consumers, corporation is the most common for managers to execute economic activities. The two elements involved in corporation are employers and employees. However, when compared with employees’ welfare, managers prefer to choose maximum profit as their prime selection. In the Marxist theory, this act of utilizing and maximizing employees’ labor to gain more profit without providing them with the equal compensation......

Words: 3522 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

China and India Trends Towards Western-Style Consumption

...China and India Trends towards Western-Style Consumption Roseanna Lasley BUS 330 Principles of Marketing Instructor Kristie Elmore March 31, 2014 “China and India are the world’s fastest-growing major emerging markets; over the first decade of the 2000s China sustained an annual gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate of 9 percent, while India achieved 7 percent growth (Rand, 2011). With U.S. growth sluggish and Europe experiencing its own economic crisis, it is no wonder the “Asian giants” are attracting the interest of marketers.” White, S. (2012) The population growth that has occurred over the past couple decades has been dramatic not just in the U.S., but in several other countries as well. There are many forces that directly affect marketing strategies. Such forces are called micro and macro environmental forces. The economy is now being dominated by a youth-oriented market. The products and services that today's youth focuses on, varies greatly from past generations. With such technological advances that have been made, it's no wonder that the times have changed. The generation of today focuses on speed, convenience, and quality. Marketers of today understand that in order to attract the youth consumer market, they must offer them products and services that interest them. Such products and services should focus on technology, music, fashion, and other influential factors that are important to today's youth. The western style of consumption consists of......

Words: 2144 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

China Japan

...dominant power. Primary Issues Between China and Japan According to the Council on Foreign relations, tensions between the two countries date to the humiliation of China in the Sino-Japanese War. These animosities surfaced in recurring cycles, often involving Chinese anger over Japan’s perceived lack of contrition for wartime crimes (Beehner & Bhattacharji, 2008). The history of World War II remains disputed, and China and Japan face challenges on how to move forward from the past. Growing tensions fueled when a Japanese history textbook distorted historical events surrounding the Nanjing Massacre. Further problems such as territorial and economic issues aggravated the relationship, including Japan’s close alliance with the United States, economic rivalry, trade frictions, and disputes over ownership of islands in the East China Sea. Recently a Chinese trawler collided with Japanese Coast Guard patrol boats near the Diaoyu Islands and resulted in a major diplomatic dispute between the two nations. The rivalry between the two countries continued, when China flexed its muscle to oppose a move to elevate Japan, into permanent membership on the United Nations Security Council. Chinese Government Extends Olive Branch Over the past four decades, Sino-Japan relations have made steady progress, only when both sides honored the agreement reached in the Sino-Japanese Treaty of Peace and Friendship in 1978. Chinese relations with Japan during the 1980s were generally close......

Words: 884 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Gdp Comparison of India and China

...when it was changed to GDP in order to be consistent with other nations. Case Study In recent times there has been a tremendous interest in the growth process of China and India. Both the countries are being looked upon as ‘the so called’ global engines of growth. Their role as ‘global engines’ of growth is not so much based on their current performance, but more so for the potential to lead the future growth process in the world economy. China has started moving towards a pro-market economy since 1978 while India’s reforms have been started much later since 1991. While China dismantled the Soviet style command economy, India broke away from the regime of mixed economy that had a strong role for central planning. While China has attained a high growth path by accelerating the rate of capital formation with a heavy emphasis on government investment in infrastructure, India instead reduced public investment and rather adopted policies to raise private investment during the reform process. In terms of achievement India has performed the best in the financial sector reforms. China had initially taken a different path by way of raising productivity in manufacturing, adopting a path of export led industrialisation and policies to attract more foreign direct investment, domestic and global factors have forced China to redirect the reform process 3for its financial sector since late 1990s. growth in the real sector. Starting from a rate of growth of 3.6% in the pre......

Words: 1697 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

China and Japan

...China and Japan are geographically separated by the East China Sea, while the two countries are so close together, they are far apart when it comes to culture, values, and the economy. China and Japan have been at odds with each other since The Raping of Nanjing in 1937. “In December of 1937, the Japanese Imperial Army marched into China's capital city of Nanking and proceeded to murder 300,000 out of 600,000 civilians and soldiers in the city. The six weeks of carnage would become known as the Rape of Nanking and represented the single worst atrocity during the World War II era in either the European or Pacific theaters of war” ( The people of China felt like it was the war against Japanese aggression and not World War II. China felt like it was a personal attack because the Japanese were so cruel and evil. Till this day China feels like Japan has downplayed the senseless murders and rapes by calling them an “incident.” Thus, here it is over seventy years later and China and Japan have totally different stories of the event that took place. I will discuss how Japan’s lack of empathy towards China has fostered deep wounds for both countries. What are the primary issues that separate China and Japan? The main issues that separate China and Japan primarily “concern the way the two governments, particularly the Japanese government, look at and handle Japan's aggression against China and its other Asian neighbors, and other related issues from the War, such...

Words: 1835 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

China and Japan

...China and Japan are in somewhat of a battle politically and economically. There are several issues that continue to fuel the fires between the two countries and government behavior on both sides is not helping matters. The documentary suggests economic rivalry, territorial disputes, and the Japanese bid for a seat on the United Nations Security Council are behind the tensions. However, a seemingly larger issue is how World War II is remembered; there are two versions of history and each wants their version to be known as truth. (Taguchi) The documentary explains that accounts of World War II have always been conflicting and a Japanese textbook downplaying their involvement has ignited the Chinese youth. The Chinese remember World War II as “a war against Japanese aggression” and by their accounts Japan is the perpetrator, not the victim. (Taguchi) The Rape of Nanjing, by Chinese accounts, was six weeks of Japanese brutality. The Japanese murdered hundreds of thousands of Chinese and villages of women were raped. According to Oi, some Japanese deny the Rape of Nanjing, while others downplay it and say “it was a battlefield and people were killed”. (Oi) The saying “the winner gets to write history” is certainly relevant in this situation. Japan, playing the innocent, chooses to whitewash their actions and attempt to write history as they see fit. Although the rest of the world is taught about the Rape of Nanjing and other horrific acts perpetrated by Japanese, it...

Words: 560 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

China & Japan

...CHINA & JAPAN The main issues primary issues that separate China and Japan is mainly the acknowledgement of the roles each country during the second Simo-Japanese war during the second war. The main bowl on contention is the Nanking massacre in which Japan invaded China and conquered and occupied Nanjing, which was then China’s capital for six weeks and the mass rape and murder that ensued by the Japanese imperialist army. At lot of the victims were buried in mass graves level of evil and China claims that 300,000 of its citizens lost their lives even though the veracity of that number is debated.1 The saying goes winners get to write history and losers get the gallows and it means the when two cultures clash the winners live to write the history of the events and war while the losers are obliterated. However, in the case of China and Japan both the winner and loser got to write the history but two different versions of it. Fast-forward to today over 70 years after the Nanjing massacre, the historical significance of this event that is being passed down to younger generations in both countries could not be more different and therein is the problem. 1 The Japanese then to glaze over this event and instead focuses on the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki which makes them looks like victims during the war. One of the official history books being used middle schools in japan refers to the massacre as the incidence, downplaying the atrocities committed during that period.1......

Words: 974 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

India and China- Prospects and Challenges

...International Research Journal of Social Sciences_____________________________________ ISSN 2319–3565 Vol. 2(8), 48-54, August (2013) Int. Res. J. Social Sci. India and China: Prospects and Challenges Mehraj Uddin Gojree Department of Political Science, Aligarh Muslim University, U.P., INDIA Available online at: Received 16th July 2013, revised 27th July 2013, accepted 12th August 2013 Abstract This paper seeks to assess the future prospects and challenges of the relationship between the two rising giants of Asia namely China and India. As they both are rising as great powers, their mutual relationship will have a significant impact not only on Asia, but on the whole world. At present, the nature of their relationship is something mixed i.e., growing cooperation in the field of trade and commerce along with distrust and mutual suspicions in the strategic fields whether political or geographical. For these apparent factors, the future relationship between India and China can be characterised by the cooperation in those fields whether mutual, regional or international which may be beneficial for the peaceful rise of both these states and confrontation, competition, and even hostility in some other areas where the respective interests of both the giants clash with each other, for example, the border issue, relationship with other countries particularly US and Pakistan, their encirclement policies, competition for energy resources, nuclear arms......

Words: 5602 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

China and India

...2010 India and China: A study in comparison [pic] Neetika Chakraborty Roll number-818 Economics (H) Third Year Acknowledgment I would like to thank my third year teachers- Ms. Nandini Kumar and Mrs. Meeta Kumar for their superior reaching capabilities and constant support. They have always been there to answer every query and help me out with research material whenever I required it. This project would not have been possible without them. This project would also not have been possible without the vast amount of data which was made available through the database of the reserve bank of India and the central bank of the Republic of China. Furthermore, I am indebted to the huge quantity of information available on the internet which was an important part of my initial research. INDEX 1. Introduction 2. Political Evolution ❖ China ❖ India ❖ Drawing a comparison 3. International Trade ❖ China ❖ India ❖ Bilateral trade between India and China 4. Population Trends ❖ Drawing a comparison 5. Conclusion 6. Bibliography Introduction China’s and India’s rapid growth and economic policies, as well as their role in International trade and capital markets, have generated a large amount of interest and research. Much of the attention focuses on their growth prospects and on their faculty to influence global governance. Two salient characteristics of China and......

Words: 5871 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

The Evolution of Tqm in the Manufacturing Sector: a Comparison of Current Practice in Japan and China.

...The evolution of TQM in the manufacturing sector: a comparison of current practice in Japan and China. TQM has many definitions which are influenced by individual interpretations of businesses or academics’. However for the purposes of this study TQM is defined as “the involvement of all of a company's managers and employees in making sure that its products and services are all of a high standard and exactly as designed” (Cambridge Business Online Dictionary 2012). TQM was developed and adapted by Japan after the Second World War. The development was motivated by the visits and lectures of two American management gurus: W Edwards Deming and Joseph Juran. In recognition of the former’s contributions, the Japanese, in 1950, introduced Deming Prize which is a highly prestigious quality management award. As a result of successful TQM implementation Japanese products enjoyed worldwide recognition for their unmatched superiority in quality, durability and design. It was not until the 1980s that the rest of the Western World acknowledged the role of TQM in Japan’s success and subsequently have been trying to embrace it and implement it in their businesses (Powel 1995, cited by Martinaz-Lorente et al 1998). This study aims to compare TQM implementation in Chinese manufacturing to that of Japan with Japan, understandably and unquestionably, being the bench mark and gold standard. There are four main factors which underpin and form the foundations of TQM: management leadership,......

Words: 1479 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

China vs. India

...that no one goes anywhere without their smart phone in their pocket and a GPS in their car. A field that has been completely changed by advances in technology is the medical field. No longer due doctors take ones temperature or blood pressure manually, they have special devices that can give a more accurate reading then a human ever could. Hand held medical scanner technology is showing an astonishing breakthrough and can revolutionize home and hospital medicine just as the home thermometer did. These types of devices have already improved the way care is given in the U.S. greatly and can do the same for countries all over the world. The two countries I chose to enter are ones that have been growing rapidly in almost all aspects, China and India. Handheld medical scanners are a real product being used but are very new and do not have much of a history or a company that solely produces them. So what are they? According to David Freeman in the Huffington Posts article “Star Trek's Tricorder Medical Scanner May Become Reality, Thanks To Nanotechnology Breakthrough,” using nanotechnology, physicists in London and Singapore found a way to make a beam of the "T-rays"--which are now used in full-body airport security scanners--stronger and more directional. The advance, which was described in a recent issue of the journal Nature Photonics, could lead to T-ray scanning devices that are smaller and more portable than existing devices. "T-rays promise to revolutionize......

Words: 4090 - Pages: 17